Case Brief
Name: ______________________ Date: __________
Brief one appellate decision assigned in class or found in a free law database. Use your own words.
The case
Case name, court, year and citation. (2 pts)
Parties: who sued whom, and who is appealing. (2 pts)
Brief
Facts: only the facts that matter to the outcome. (5 pts)
Procedural history: what the lower courts decided. (3 pts)
Issue: the legal question, phrased as a yes-or-no question. (3 pts)
Holding: the court's answer and the rule of law it states. (4 pts)
Reasoning: why the court decided as it did, including the main precedent or text relied on. (8 pts)
Concurrences or dissents, if any, and their main point. (3 pts)
Assessment
Do you find the reasoning persuasive? Argue one way, addressing the strongest point on the other side. (6 pts)