Training Transfer: Why a Workshop Skill Stays in the Classroom

Employee practicing a workshop skill at an actual workstation

An employee performs a new skill correctly in a workshop and returns to a workstation where the old routine is faster, familiar, and expected by coworkers. The workshop demonstrated learning under one set of conditions. Transfer asks whether the skill shows up in the actual job, where the cues, time pressures, and opportunities to practice may differ.

Learning vs. Transfer

It is essential to distinguish between learning and transfer. Learning refers to the process of acquiring new knowledge, skills, and attitudes, whereas transfer refers to the application of what has been learned to a different context. In other words, learning is about acquiring knowledge, while transfer is about using that knowledge in a practical setting.

A Worked Example

Consider the case of a company that provides customer service training to its employees. The training program includes a workshop on effective communication skills, where participants learn how to actively listen to customers, empathize with their concerns, and respond in a professional manner. The training is well-structured, and participants are engaged and motivated. However, after the training, the employees return to their jobs and fail to apply the skills they learned. They continue to respond to customer complaints in a defensive and unprofessional manner, just as they did before the training.

In this example, the employees have learned the skills, but the transfer of learning to the workplace has not occurred. The training has not resulted in a change in behavior, and the employees are not applying what they have learned to their actual work. This is a common problem, and it highlights the need for organizations to focus on transfer of learning, rather than just learning itself.

Opportunities for Transfer

So, why does a workshop skill often stay in the classroom? One reason is that the training program may not provide sufficient opportunities for learners to practice and apply what they have learned. Without opportunities for practice and application, learners may not be able to develop the skills and confidence they need to transfer their learning to the workplace.

Another reason is that the work environment may not support the transfer of learning. For example, if the workplace culture is not conducive to learning and development, or if there are barriers to applying new skills, such as lack of resources or inadequate feedback, learners may not be able to transfer their learning.

Follow-up Observation

Follow-up observation and evaluation are critical to ensuring that learning is transferred to the workplace. After a training program, it is essential to observe and evaluate whether learners are applying what they have learned. This can involve monitoring their behavior, providing feedback, and coaching them to improve their performance.

In the case of the customer service training program, follow-up observation might involve monitoring the employees' interactions with customers, providing feedback on their communication skills, and coaching them to improve their performance. This would help to ensure that the learning is transferred to the workplace and that the employees are applying the skills they learned in the training program.

A Contrasting Case

Consider the case of a manufacturing company that provides training to its production staff on a new machine. The training program includes a combination of classroom instruction and on-the-job training, where participants learn how to operate the machine safely and efficiently. After the training, the production staff are able to operate the machine with ease, and their productivity and quality of work improve significantly.

In this case, the learning has been transferred to the workplace, and the employees are applying what they have learned to their actual work. The training program has resulted in a change in behavior, and the employees are able to perform their jobs more effectively and efficiently. This is an example of successful transfer of learning, where the training program has had a positive impact on the workplace.

Lessons Learned

The contrasting case highlights the importance of providing opportunities for practice and application, as well as a supportive work environment, to facilitate the transfer of learning. It also emphasizes the need for follow-up observation and evaluation to ensure that learning is transferred to the workplace.

In conclusion, training transfer is a critical aspect of any training program. It is essential to distinguish between learning and transfer, and to provide opportunities for practice and application, as well as a supportive work environment, to facilitate the transfer of learning. Follow-up observation and evaluation are also critical to ensuring that learning is transferred to the workplace.

By understanding the factors that influence training transfer, organizations can design and deliver training programs that result in meaningful and lasting changes in behavior, and that have a positive impact on the workplace.

  • Job analysis is critical to identifying the tasks and worker requirements that are essential to the job, and to ensuring that the training program is relevant and effective.
  • Selection of participants is also important, as it ensures that the right people are receiving the training, and that they have the necessary skills and knowledge to benefit from the program.
  • Training should be designed to provide opportunities for practice and application, as well as a supportive work environment, to facilitate the transfer of learning.
  • Evaluation is critical to ensuring that the training program is effective, and that the learning is transferred to the workplace.
  1. Provide opportunities for practice and application to facilitate the transfer of learning.
  2. Create a supportive work environment that encourages the application of new skills and knowledge.
  3. Conduct follow-up observation and evaluation to ensure that learning is transferred to the workplace.
  4. Use job analysis to identify the tasks and worker requirements that are essential to the job, and to ensure that the training program is relevant and effective.

By following these principles, organizations can design and deliver training programs that result in meaningful and lasting changes in behavior, and that have a positive impact on the workplace. Effective training transfer is critical to achieving this goal, and it requires a focus on providing opportunities for practice and application, as well as a supportive work environment, and follow-up observation and evaluation.

In this scenario, the company can take several steps to facilitate the transfer of learning. First, they can provide opportunities for practice and application during the training program. This can include hands-on exercises, case studies, and group discussions. Second, they can create a supportive work environment that encourages the application of new skills and knowledge. This can include providing feedback and coaching to employees, as well as recognizing and rewarding their achievements. Finally, they can conduct follow-up observation and evaluation to ensure that the learning is transferred to the workplace.

Worked Solution

For example, the company can use a combination of metrics to evaluate the transfer of learning. These metrics can include the number of employees who are able to use the software correctly, the number of errors or issues that arise, and the overall productivity and efficiency of the employees. By tracking these metrics, the company can identify areas where the employees need additional support or training, and provide targeted interventions to facilitate the transfer of learning.

On the other hand, if the company decides to add a component on how to troubleshoot common issues with the software, the employees may be better equipped to handle problems that arise in their daily work. This can result in an increase in the transfer of learning, and the company may see an improvement in productivity and efficiency.

  1. Identify the learning objectives of the training program and ensure that they are aligned with the needs of the organization.
  2. Design the training program to provide opportunities for practice and application, as well as a supportive work environment.
  3. Deliver the training program in a way that is engaging and interactive, and that provides opportunities for feedback and coaching.

For the wider context, read Roovet’s guide to industrial and organizational psychology or explore the social psychology course.

Related Roovet Academy guides

Keep reading