What a Work Sample Measures in Employee Selection

Candidate organizing simulated customer orders

Ask a candidate to organize a set of simulated customer orders and you can observe part of the work directly. The result still depends on which orders you selected, which instructions you supplied, and how the response is scored. A work sample can be close to the job while providing incomplete evidence about performance across the whole role.

Build a small order-processing work sample

Give a fictional candidate three customer orders, a short stock list, and a clear rule for handling an unavailable item. Include one straightforward order, one incomplete address, and one item that has run out. Before anyone takes the exercise, specify how to score accurate entry, detection of missing information, and escalation of the stock issue. A candidate who finishes fastest but silently substitutes a different item has demonstrated speed and a judgment problem. The scoring rule should preserve that distinction. Use the same instructions and resources for everyone who takes the sample.

Introduction to Work Samples

A work sample is a type of assessment that requires applicants to perform a sample job task, which is designed to mimic the actual work they would be doing on the job. For example, suppose a company is hiring a data analyst and, as part of the selection process, asks applicants to complete a work sample involving analyzing a dataset and creating a report of their findings. To illustrate, imagine a fictional company, Green Earth, which has collected data on product sales over the past quarter and wants to identify best-selling products and contributing factors. This example is for illustrative purposes only.

Work Sample Task

In this example, the work sample task might involve asking applicants to analyze the dataset, identify trends and patterns, and create a report to present their findings to the management team. The task might include specific requirements, such as creating a chart or graph to illustrate the data, and writing a brief summary of the key findings. By completing this task, applicants demonstrate their ability to analyze data, think critically, and communicate complex information effectively.

Distinguishing Fidelity, Reliability, and Validity

When using work samples as a selection tool, it's essential to distinguish between fidelity, reliability, and validity. Fidelity refers to how closely the work sample resembles the actual work that the applicant would be doing on the job. In the Green Earth example, the work sample has high fidelity because it involves analyzing a dataset and creating a report, which is a task that data analysts at the company would typically perform. Reliability refers to the consistency of the work sample results, and whether they would be the same if the task were repeated. Validity, on the other hand, refers to whether the work sample actually measures what it's supposed to measure, such as the applicant's ability to analyze data and communicate effectively.

In the Green Earth example, successful completion of the task suggests the applicant can analyze data, think critically, and communicate complex information effectively—skills directly relevant to the task. However, the work sample does not assess unrelated competencies such as leadership or teamwork, which require different evaluation methods. Employers should avoid inferring broad traits or overall job readiness from a single work sample and instead interpret results within the specific scope of the assessed skills.

Contrasting Case: Customer Service Representative

Consider another illustrative case: a company hiring a customer service representative. A work sample might involve responding to simulated customer complaints, with evaluation based on resolution effectiveness, communication tone, and problem-solving. Applicants demonstrate job-relevant skills such as verbal responsiveness and issue resolution under realistic conditions. This scenario is hypothetical and intended to clarify the application of work samples.

In this case, the work sample has high fidelity because it involves responding to customer complaints, which is a task that customer service representatives at the company would typically perform. The reliability of the work sample results would depend on whether the task is consistent, and whether the results would be the same if the task were repeated. The validity of the work sample would depend on whether it actually measures the applicant's ability to communicate effectively with customers, and provide solutions to problems.

Lesson Learned

The key lesson learned from these examples is that work samples can be a powerful tool for selecting the best candidate for a job, but only if they are designed and used correctly. By understanding what a work sample measures, and distinguishing between fidelity, reliability, and validity, employers can use this tool to make informed hiring decisions. It's also essential to remember that work samples should be used in conjunction with other selection tools, such as interviews and reference checks, to get a complete picture of the applicant's skills and abilities.

By applying the lesson learned from these examples, employers can create effective work samples that measure the skills and abilities required for the job, and use the results to make informed hiring decisions. Whether it's a data analyst or a customer service representative, the key is to design a work sample that has high fidelity, reliability, and validity, and to use it as one part of a comprehensive selection process.

Key Takeaways

  • Work samples involve asking applicants to complete a task that simulates the actual work they would be doing on the job.
  • Fidelity refers to how closely the work sample resembles the actual work, reliability refers to the consistency of the results, and validity refers to whether the work sample measures what it's supposed to measure.
  • Work samples can be used to measure a range of skills and abilities, including data analysis, communication, and problem-solving.
  • Employers should use work samples in conjunction with other selection tools, such as interviews and reference checks, to get a complete picture of the applicant's skills and abilities.

By following these key takeaways, employers can create effective work samples that help them select the best candidate for the job, and improve the overall quality of their hiring process.

The company receives several applications, each including a candidate's solution. Evaluators assess submissions for accuracy, clarity, and quality, along with adherence to instructions, critical thinking, and communication effectiveness. A scoring system assigns points for correctness, quality of reasoning, and compliance with task requirements, ensuring consistent and objective evaluation across applicants.

Worked Solution

The company can use work sample results to inform hiring decisions by comparing applicant scores. Higher scores may indicate stronger alignment with job requirements. Additionally, patterns in performance—such as multiple applicants struggling with data interpretation—can highlight areas where applicants may benefit from training. However, hiring decisions should not rely solely on work samples; they are one component of a broader assessment process.

  • The work sample provides a realistic assessment of the applicant's skills and abilities.
  • The scoring system allows the company to evaluate each solution objectively and consistently.
  • The results of the work sample can be used to make an informed hiring decision and to identify areas where the applicants may need additional training or support.

Changing One Condition

If the work sample were modified to be team-based, the company would need to develop a scoring system that evaluates collaborative behaviors such as communication, task coordination, and shared problem-solving. This change would allow assessment of teamwork skills in addition to individual technical ability. The resulting evaluation would reflect both individual contributions and group dynamics, offering a broader—but not necessarily more valid—perspective depending on the job's actual requirements.

  1. The company would need to re-evaluate its scoring criteria to ensure they capture team-based competencies such as collaboration and communication, in addition to individual task performance. This adjustment ensures the assessment remains aligned with the specific skills required for team-oriented roles.
  2. The new scoring system would need to reflect the team-based nature of the work sample, incorporating metrics for group interaction, role distribution, and collective problem-solving, while still maintaining objectivity and consistency in evaluation.
  3. The results of the revised work sample would offer a broader assessment of applicants' skills, including their ability to collaborate and function within a team. However, the comprehensiveness of the assessment depends on how well the task and scoring criteria reflect the actual demands of the job, and it should not be assumed that team performance in a simulated setting fully predicts real-world effectiveness.

For the wider context, read Roovet’s guide to industrial and organizational psychology or explore the social psychology course.

Further reading: U.S. Office of Personnel Management, Work Samples and Simulations.

Related Roovet Academy guides

Keep reading