Addressing Structural and Systemic Racism in Social and Health Care Systems to Advance Health Equity · Chin MH, Gyau-Moyer A, Kelliher A et al.

STRUCTURAL RACISM EMBEDS INTO MULTIPLE SOCIAL AND HEALTH SYSTEMS

Structural racism is embedded into society’s fabric, and its effects cascade. Structural racism becomes insidiously invisible to many of those who blame persons of racial/ethnic minority groups for misfortunes. For example, structural racism caused discrimination and redlining in the housing and mortgage markets2, preventing many Blacks from owning homes and building wealth through housing equity. Many Blacks live in areas with lower property tax bases, leading to fewer resources to fund public schools. Poor-quality education could lead to low-paying jobs that do not provide health insurance, limiting access to high-quality health care. Low income contributes to more limited housing options, and poor and racial/ethnic minority groups are more likely to live near and be exposed to environmental toxins and pollution2. Moreover, racially segregated areas such as American Indian reservations frequently have food deserts and limited transportation options11.

Structural racism affects justice and legal systems, diminishing access to opportunity structures with downstream economic, labor, and health effects2. Mass incarceration of Black, Latino, and AIAN men results in part from racial profiling and disproportionately higher rates of police stops, arrests, and convictions2. Incarceration has profound generational effects on families. Incarceration increases mental and physical health issues from stress and trauma, and it limits resources and causes financial hardship through loss of income and social support. Communities lose economic and social resources of incarcerated members2. Families also face social stigma and discrimination, which can isolate them from community and social support. Formerly incarcerated persons have difficulty obtaining jobs. Additionally, children of incarcerated parents are more likely to encounter the criminal justice system themselves, perpetuating a cycle of incarceration12.

Structural racism also impacts media, including news and entertainment industries, with synergistic effects in systems such as immigration and foreign policy2. The media can perpetuate racism and discrimination by reinforcing stereotypes and biased portrayals of minority groups, which can shape public perception negatively. Historically, anti-Asian immigration laws dating back to the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 have been accompanied by media tropes otherizing Asians as “perpetual foreigners” and the “yellow peril.”2Modern-day terms such as “kung flu” build on prior racist imagery of Asians as vectors of disease. American foreign policy such as the Vietnam War and Iraq War has harmed many immigrants. Support for refugees and pathways to citizenship has been limited, and discriminatory surveillance and profiling policies intended for national security have targeted MENA2. Accompanying media, language and representation frequently dehumanize and create negative stereotypes. For example, Hollywood often portrays diverse MENA persons as Muslim terrorists who oppress women2. Words and stories matter. Negative messages and imagery directly stigmatize and traumatize individuals and communities and create subconscious narratives that influence beliefs and attitudes about different populations, and their support for anti-racist solutions that increase access to opportunity structures and improve health.

Structural racism is also perpetuated by aggregating data classification of racial and ethnic populations, which masks inequities among subpopulations. For example, “Hispanic” classification was only introduced as part of the US census in 1980, after a 1976 mandate by Congress. It was included as an ethnic categorization and defined as “Americans [who] identify themselves as being of Spanish-speaking background and trace their origin or descent from Mexico, Puerto Rico, Cuba, Central and South America, and other Spanish-speaking countries.” This broad classification makes invisible the dire health, education, and economic conditions of Hispanic subgroups—specifically Mexican American and Puerto Ricans—who share involuntary historical incorporation in the USA2. These two groups have disproportionately experienced long-standing intergenerational life course disadvantages due to US policies, such as segregation and English-only laws and practices, which have created a significant wealth gap. Lack of disaggregating racial and ethnic categories also makes invisible inequities among Asian subgroups, such as for some disadvantaged Southeast Asian populations2. Failure to disaggregate Native Hawaiians or Pacific Islanders from more numerous Asians also masks their inequities2.

AIAN peoples have a history of unique experiences resulting in health challenges and inequities2. Nearly 700 Tribes remain in the USA, with 574 federally recognized. With unique political status, they celebrate their own histories, cultures, languages, and practices enduring centuries of efforts toward genocide including systematic limits on basic human rights, subsequent relocation, exposure to disease, enslavement, violence, boarding schools, forced sterilization, and persistent socio-economic disadvantages2. Data genocide removes AIAN peoples from data, making their problems invisible. It has taken hundreds of years for the US government to acknowledge and apologize for boarding school atrocities, let alone substantially remedy their effects. AIAN peoples experience the intersectional effects of poverty and racism including lack of access to high-quality health care, exposure to trauma, and disproportionate exposure to extreme weather events and toxins resulting in increased risk for higher rates of chronic conditions13. Historically, the Indian Health Service (IHS) has been funded at only half the per capita rate of other key health systems. Loss of access to land, sacred sites, and traditional medicines including ceremonial practices disrupts key methods AIAN peoples use to sustain their well-being and the health of their communities. Health systems do not always prioritize culturally safe care for AIAN peoples. Justified mistrust of colonial health systems persists in Tribal communities due to a history of abuse and research misconduct, though Tribes do prioritize the health of their citizens14.

Health care is not immune to structural racism. For example, structural racism influences payment and financing of the US health care system, resulting in fewer resources for health care delivery organizations that serve racial/ethnic minority populations, affordability problems for many patients, and weak accountability of systems for the health and well-being of persons and communities2,7,15. State variation in the resourcing of the Medicaid program has roots in the racial politics of the 1960 s when Medicaid was founded, and today’s underfinancing harms poor people, regardless of their skin color2.