Discussion
The purpose of this study was to investigate gender differences in financial literacy, as well as the association of financial literacy with individual characteristics (e.g. age and education). Our findings are twofold:
First, we find an inverse U-shaped relationship between financial literacy and age for both men and women. However, for self-rated financial knowledge, particularly for men, the opposite trend was observed: a U-shaped relationship with age was found. This trend is consistent with findings in many other countries [3]. The study indicates that younger and older people are likely to have lower financial literacy than those middle-aged. A recent study indicates that the decline in crystallised intelligence and fluid intelligence contributes to a corresponding decline in financial literacy [26]. Furthermore, among older people, while financial literacy declines, self-rated financial literacy remains high. As known as an ‘overconfidence bias,’ the miscalibration of self-assessment is explained by heuristics biases, the probabilistic mental model, and individual differences [27]. Among older people, self-confidence in financial management does not decline even though financial literacy drops in alignment with cognitive decline, potentially reflecting beliefs about accumulated experiences or reluctance to accept a decrease in cognitive functioning due to natural aging [28,29]. Although gender differences in the accuracy of self-assessment are inconclusive, the fact or stereotype that men are more financially literate than women may contribute to a larger magnitude of overconfidence among men [30,31].
Second, gender gaps in financial literacy are driven by differences in the distribution of the independent variables that impact financial literacy (e.g. education and the amount of financial assets). Previous research also suggests that women tend to be less financially literate than men both in the younger and older age groups [3]. This could be perpetuated by an underinvestment in financial literacy for women due to the stereotype that the financial capabilities of women are low [32] or that men and women acquire financial literacy differently [33]. However, no explicit reason had been confirmed. As women live longer than men, on average [34], they have to have a financial plan for managing their longer lives. Thus, strategies are needed that enhance financial literacy, particularly among women, and support financial decision making for a lifelong plan.
Our findings suggest that attaining higher education largely accounts for gender differences in financial literacy. It has been pointed out that those with higher educational are more financially literate, as financial literacy is affected by skills that those with higher education tend to possess potentially due to a positive association between financial literacy and cognitive skill [3]. Other research suggests that higher education is correlated positively with the ability to process information [35]. Therefore, gender differences could be mitigated through enhanced educational opportunities, including financial education for women.
However, financial behaviours and attitudes among women were more positive than men despite the better financial knowledge among men, in line with the previous findings [15]. This could be because the linkage of knowledge with behaviour and attitude is not always evident [36,37]. In addition, we find that the unexplained parts account for the gender gaps, as traditionally, women tend to be more risk averse and have the higher propensity to save [38–41]. Therefore, while enhancing financial knowledge is important, transforming it into actual behaviour and attitude is also necessary.
Our findings suggest two important policy implications. First, there is a need to support older adults regarding their financial decision making and for financial education for those with low financial literacy. If an individual remains confident, even when financial literacy declines, he/she may choose an inappropriate option or be subject to financial fraud without sufficient understanding of the option and support from advisors. Therefore, it is crucial that to provide appropriate assistance, financial planners in charge of support for financial decision making among individuals understand that preferences, abilities, and natures can change as people age. Simultaneously, individuals should be made aware that their financial literacy may decline as they age. Second, financial education and resources that individuals can access easily are required to ensure that necessary and timely information is available according to each life stage. These resources should be well organised so that individuals can accumulate knowledge that can enhance their actual financial behaviours and attitudes.
While our study investigates the determinants of financial literacy in Japan, focusing in particular on age and gender differences, it has several limitations. First, selection bias may exist, as the sample of the Financial Literacy Survey 2016 was collected through an internet survey. Thus, the surveyed sample may include those with higher IT literacy, especially among seniors. Furthermore, the respondents may be more interested than the general population in topics related to financial assets and decision making. Thus, the actual distribution of financial literacy among all Japanese people may have a lower mean and decrease more as a consequence of ageing. In fact, any sample of seniors randomly selected to measure financial literacy may be biased due to the decline in cognitive functioning. Unbiased methods to measure financial literacy, financial behaviour, and financial assets among a general sample, particularly among seniors, should be developed in future studies.
Second, as the Financial Literacy Survey 2016 is cross-sectional, it fails to follow any changes in financial literacy in the participant associated with ageing, thus, results may be subject to cohort differences rather than effects of age. Nevertheless, it would be unrealistic to study individuals from early to later life due to cost and sample attrition. Instead, it would be helpful to utilise panel data, even considering a relatively short follow-up period, to verify when and how individuals enhance their financial literacy and financial behavioural choices for better strategies related to financial asset management.
Additionally, endogeneity can be problematic in research on financial literacy and financial behavioural choices: as high financial literacy enables better financial behavioural choices, individuals might acquire literacy related to financial decision making when they have to make financial choices [3]. Moreover, unobserved factors, not considered in this study due to data restriction, may account for financial literacy and generate gender differences in financial literacy. Therefore, a further investigation should focus on: (1) causal impacts of financial literacy on financial behavioural choices and outcomes of actual asset management; (2) when and how individuals acquire financial literacy, and whether it improves financial behavioural choices; 3) if any other factors account for gender differences in financial literacy, behaviours, and attitudes. One previous work found that financial literacy, even among an educated group, was low [42]. However, concrete evidence for reasons why women are less financially literate than men seems difficult to find [3]; thus, accumulating such evidence is needed to enhance women’s financial literacy.
In conclusion, we found an inverse U-shaped relationship between age and financial literacy for both men and women, while the opposite trend appeared for age and self-rated financial knowledge, particularly among men. Furthermore, men were more financially literate than women and this difference could be explained by endowment effects, specifically higher education, coefficient effects, and interaction effects. Due to time and budget constraints, most studies on this topic utilise observational approaches. Hereafter, intervention studies and evidence-based policymaking will be required to support individuals in financial asset management to enable ‘the 100-Year Life’.
CC BY 4.0. "Age, gender, and financial literacy in Japan" by Okamoto S, Komamura K, PloS one (2021). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259393. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC8598074). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.