Background and literature review
In the latter half of the 1930s, the US Federal government authorized the Home Owners’ Loan Corporation (HOLC) to draw “security” maps for investment purposes [16]. These maps were drawn with color codes to reflect areas that were more or less safe for investment. Four color codes were used: green, blue, yellow, and red. Green areas were labeled “A Best”, Blue areas “B Still Desirable”, Yellow areas “C Definitely Declining”, and Red areas “D Hazardous”. Red signified the highest risk areas to HOLC, which led to the term “redlining”. These color-coded categories reflected race and were most likely drawn to discourage investment in majority Black neighborhoods [13]. Redlined areas were explicitly labeled as such due to a large proportion of Black residents, using language characterizing “detrimental influences” such as “infiltration of Negro” while yellow categories often included the tag “infiltration of Foreigners” [16–19].
Evidence that redlining might still have impacts today
Even time-limited urban changes can have long-lasting cumulative effects. Michaels and Rauch [20] found that the differential collapse of Western Roman urbanization in Britain and France in the 6th century CE differentially impacted the spatial efficiency of urbanization even 1500 years later in the 21st century. Similarly, evidence supports that redlining still has cumulative impacts on various social factors today. Aaronson et al. [12] found that living in close proximity on two sides of differently graded borders—as represented in the 1930s HOLC security maps—is strongly associated nation-wide with increased residential racial segregation from the 1930s to today. The effect on residential racial segregation was particularly strong from 1930 to 1970 and the effect size began to decrease after 1970. Aaronson et al. provide additional support that maps were likely drawn with race in mind: only areas marked category D had a primarily Black population in the 1930s. In addition to increased segregation, Aaronson et al. found support for reductions in home ownership, house values, and credit scores throughout the 20th century that are maintained even today nearly a century later. They also found evidence of “yellow-lining”: areas marked as category C also had disparate current outcomes when compared to higher rated areas. Using a different methodology, Appel and Nickerson [21] found that redlined neighborhoods had lower home prices in 1990 compared to surrounding areas, and that these discriminatory effects remained even after nearly 60 years. The presence of these discriminatory effects can be compounded across time: Massey et al. [22] found that Black residents of redlined neighborhoods face greater barriers to residential mobility than white residents that negatively impacts Black residents’ social and economic well-being.
Potential impacts of redlining on health
A growing body of scholarship examines the relationship between neighborhood characteristics and health outcomes [23], though few studies have specifically considered the legacy of redlining. The shadows of historical redlining are seen on present day health where structural racism and neighborhood segregation persist. The potential pathways for redlining’s impact on health reflect those found in residential segregation [23] and fall across the entirety of the life course [9,23–40]. Proposed pathways span both differential exposures to environmental and social hazards (including both the proximity and imposition of hazards and the reduced presence of mitigatory systems such as reduced access to health services [23,27]) and possibly the concentration of populations that have previously suffered such hazards [25,29]. Lynch et al. [27] find that historical redlining was associated with sustained disinvestment and lending discrimination in Milwaukee neighborhoods, as well as poorer present day physical and mental health. Similarly, neighborhood quality is thought to affect environmental health and reduce access to resources that enable protective behaviors [28–31]. Kreiger et al. [24] found that residing in a previously redlined area in Massachusetts was associated with an elevated risk for late stage at cancer diagnosis, even for residents of census tracts with present-day economic and racial privilege.
Redlining’s impact on health through disinvestment potentially starts before birth and in childhood. O’Campo et al. [29] found that neighborhood risk factors were significant in predicting low-birth weight. Specifically, they found that low-income census tracts (those with less than $8000 per capita annual income) were associated with higher risk of low birthweight. In examining birth certificate data and HOLC grade, Krieger et al. [25] concluded that historical redlining may be a structural determinant of present-day risk of preterm birth in New York City. On the other hand, Mendez et al. [31] found that redlining as represented through current mortgage discrimination was not associated with pregnancy outcomes. However, Mendez et al. stated that there was not enough variation in their sample to estimate associations and hypothesized that redlining might have measurable health impacts in other realms.
Wilson et al. [28] show the pathway from historic redlining to worsened pollution and housing stock and ultimately to poor asthma outcomes. Similarly, Alexander and Currie [30] found that sustained racial segregation in neighborhoods in New Jersey is associated with increased prevalence of asthma in low birthweight children. Nardone et al. [26] report that historically redlined census tracts in California have significantly higher rates of emergency department visits due to asthma.
Neighborhood quality and redlining might have an impact on physical activity as well. Boone et al. [32] find that redlined neighborhoods in Baltimore had reduced availability of greenspaces. The availability of greenspaces, walkability, other neighborhood built environmental factors, and neighborhood income in Baltimore and Seattle were found to be significantly associated with physical activity and better physical quality of life [6], which are factors that are important for the prevention and management of chronic diseases [41].
Potentially negative health impacts can also be a manifestation of direct state subjugation of and lack of political responsiveness to marginalized populations through environmental injustice. McCoy [34] found that coal-fired plants were more likely to be sited in communities of color. Trangenstein et al. [33] find HOLC category best predicts slow responsiveness of liquor store closures to depopulation and store clustering in Baltimore. Pappoe [9] in examining Freddie Gray’s case in Baltimore, argues that government-enabled and sponsored housing segregation and concomitant impacts of underfunded education, overpolicing, and deliberate impoverishment is the best frame to understand both structural and interpersonal violence (including state-sponsored violence) against Black people living in Baltimore.
The totality of potential health impacts across the life course may be reflected in life-expectancy [25,40] and age-differentiated mortality. Richardson et al. find large differences in life expectancy by HOLC grade [40]. To our knowledge there has not been a study yet on associations with age-differentiated mortality.
Methodological issues in measuring redlining
HOLC map categories do not map well onto other, more conventional geographical units. HOLC categories cross census tracts (both contemporaneous and current), as well as larger neighborhood boundaries. This non-cartographic categorization can cause issues in classifying neighborhoods according to HOLC category as well as obtaining representative sets of sociodemographic characteristics of neighborhoods in ecologic studies. Predominance, or the use of the largest category feature to assign a non-cartographic category to a conventional geographic unit, is commonly used across disciplines [42–46]. In studies where the unit of analysis is an individual or their address, these categorization issues are no longer relevant, but such access is almost always subject to restrictions. Studies under those restrictions for individual-level data have sometimes used multilevel models for area-level effects while using addresses only for precision in geographical unit assignment [24,25]. While smaller sizes of conventional geographical units, such as census tracts or block groups, may offer better resolution than larger units, such as CSAs, they are still susceptible to the ecological fallacy.
HOLC categories also do not necessarily function as “equal steps” away from each other [47]. Some studies have treated HOLC categories as intervals specifically for the purpose of examining potential determinants of those HOLC categories, but have also noted the limitations of taking such an approach [47]. Although changes in neighborhood demographic composition are by no means exogenous, HOLC maps cannot directly capture the demographic changes that have occurred over the last century nor other federal and local policies [12] that may either augment or reduce the potential demographic and health impacts of redlining in a given area.
CC BY 4.0. "Association of historic redlining and present-day health in Baltimore" by Huang SJ, Sehgal NJ, PloS one (2022). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0261028. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC8769359). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.