Health Informatics Is Needed to Reduce Healthcare's Carbon Footprint
Healthcare is responsible for between 4 and 5% of global carbon dioxide emissions, the biggest carbon footprint of any service sector. Carbon dioxide emissions embedded in goods and services provided by medical retailers, hospitals, ambulatory, long-term, and preventive healthcare services have been calculated and compared across OECD countries and China and India, for the period since 2000 (18). Major contributors to these emissions are medicines (including inhalers), anesthetic gases, patient and staff transport, heating and cooling of facilities, electricity use, waste management, and food and catering services (19).
Furthermore health information and communication technologies themselves can be part of the problem. Globally digital health may contribute to carbon dioxide emissions through the production and disposal of health wearables and medtech devices, through the energy costs of operating data centers and telecommunication centers, and through the increasingly intensive energy consumption of data processing to support health applications of artificial intelligence and machine learning (20, 21).
Health informatics can play a mitigation role in healthcare services' general carbon-emitting practices in several ways. One is by directing health data science efforts toward this; examples show how it is possible to model the emission consequences of decisions in surgical anesthesia and in intensive care, using industrial life cycle assessment software (22, 23). Another approach is to support the expansion of virtual care, by refining telehealth platforms and tools: a systematic review found 14 studies from around the world claiming that telehealth reduces emissions as compared with in-person care, mainly by reducing travel-related fuel consumption. However, the review notes that the calculations in these studies may not give a full account of the carbon footprint of telehealth (24). A higher level approach to this mitigation role is health informatics work to build the new national health information infrastructure needed to support governments to reduce carbon emissions across their entire hospital networks and health systems, such as the UK Delivering a Net Zero NHS initiative (https://www.england.nhs.uk/greenernhs/) and the US Office of Climate Change and Health Equity (https://www.hhs.gov/ocche/index.html). In work at this level, health terminology standards and healthcare information systems need to incorporate emerging metrics of healthcare sustainability, such as Hensher and McGain (25).
To minimize the specific impacts of digital health itself, there is a role for health informatics to provide guidance on low-carbon health IT infrastructure decisions. This will entail adapting generic technology industry standards such as TCO Certified (https://tcocertified.com) for health IT contexts. For example, hospital IT management strategies should include upgrading to energy-efficient equipment and systems and adopting responsible electronic waste disposal practices (26). Further, health informatics can guide wise use of digital and data-driven health technologies, in ways that minimize wasteful over-servicing. For example, algorithms for analyzing large databases of routinely collected clinical data and patient trajectories can be designed not only to support more accurate diagnostic decisions, but also to reduce the likelihood of overdiagnosis that has arisen from proliferation of new digital screening technologies (27).
CC BY 4.0. "Climate Change, Human Health, and Health Informatics: A New View of Connected and Sustainable Digital Health" by Gray K, Frontiers in digital health (2022). https://doi.org/10.3389/fdgth.2022.869721. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC8964515). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.