Closing the dietary fibre gap - developing a novel dietary fibre screening tool (SCREEN-IT) for the UK population: validity, reproducibility and usability insights · Norton V, Lovegrove JA, Weech M et al.

Discussion

The novel SCREEN-IT tool was successfully developed adopting a multi-stage process utilising insights from NDNS, previous dietary fibre-derived research and food-based examples with relevant portion size photographs to ensure suitability and relevance for a UK population. Key objectives were tool development, initial validation (against FFQ) and reproducibility (re-test on two occasions) to understand areas for improvement and future applications of SCREEN-IT.

Validity was conducted in line with previous research and best practices; for example, SCREEN-IT was compared with a country-specific FFQ (one of the most common methods to capture habitual food intake) using a relevant sample size (n = 70) for this purpose [27–29, 39]. The estimated dietary fibre intake from SCREEN-IT was lower compared with eNutri-FFQ as expected. SCREEN-IT included considerably fewer food items (10 vs. 157-item) and category groupings (e.g., nuts, seeds, snacks, etc.). This may have contributed to reduced data granularity; therefore, limiting dietary fibre quantification from all food sources [27, 28]. The differing timeframes of dietary assessment (two weeks [SCREEN-IT] vs. four weeks [eNutri-FFQ]) may also have contributed to the observed differences. Rijnaarts et al. [28] validated a dietary fibre screening tool for a Dutch population focusing on key dietary fibre food categories (fruit, vegetables, whole-grain products, pasta, rice, potatoes, legumes, nuts and seeds). They also reported their dietary fibre screening tool had lower recorded intakes compared with a more comprehensive FFQ [28]. Similar findings were present in a short food frequency questionnaire (DFI-FFQ) to identify low, medium and high dietary fibre intakes in New Zealand; however, this research was limited by the number of dietary fibre-rich food categories (vegetables, fruits, breads + cereals, nuts + seeds, legumes) [27]. The overall agreement between methods (SCREEN-IT vs. eNutri-FFQ) was categorised as “acceptable to good” suggesting SCREEN-IT was a suitable tool for quantifying and/or ranking dietary fibre intake in the UK. In addition, despite the relatively low dietary fibre intake per se, it was possible to rank participants based on low or high intake. This is increasingly relevant since only 4.0% of the UK population meet dietary fibre recommendations [2]; therefore, this tool is warranted and could highlight gaps in consumption habits to drive future strategies to increase intake. Moreover, the good usability and speed of completion (less than 5-min) demonstrated its suitability for use in different settings (e.g., home, healthcare, communities, supermarkets, etc.) and its potential role as an educational resource in contexts where nutrition expertise can be limited. Further insights beyond initial validity with a FFQ could include prospective dietary assessment methodologies (weighed food records, 24-hr recalls) and time-periods (short vs. long-term) to understand variation as well as additional analyses by dietary fibre-rich categories. Objective metrics are an important aspect of validating dietary assessment tools but identifying relevant biomarker(s) for total dietary fibre (rather than specific dietary fibre foods) is a cited challenge within the literature [46].

The reproducibility and usability assessment included a larger cohort to enable insights from three distinct age-groups. Utilising a life-course approach can help identify “populations of interest” and opportunities for change, as well as understanding any unique challenges associated with each age-group [47, 48]. SCREEN-IT was reproducible (“acceptable or good”) based on capturing dietary fibre-related trends from two occasions (four-weeks apart) using a range of statistical agreement-based techniques and this was broadly similar across all three age-groups. Key metrics such as time, usability and device size were also recorded. Initially, older adults took more time to complete SCREEN-IT compared with both younger age-groups (main age-related difference). However, completion time was quicker for SCREEN-IT on the second occasion suggesting exposure and familiarity with such a tool was beneficial. Usability scores (SUS) were comparable across all three age-groups; previously such scores from dietary assessment tools were lower in older adults compared with other age-groups [34]. SCREEN-IT usability was high (84.9/100); therefore, similar to common everyday technologies (Gmail: 83.5, microwaves: 86.9) and current UK dietary assessment tools (Intake24: 71.5, eNutri-FFQ: 74.0) [32, 49, 50]. It is important that the tool was evaluated using different device sizes (small to large) to reflect common societal usage (smartphone, tablet, PC and laptop; [51]) and ensure suitability as well as providing future design cues. Feedback was positive and key themes included: easy-to-use, functional, thought-provoking, enjoyable and concise. This demonstrates SCREEN-IT’s potential as an educational resource to raise awareness compared with typical dietary assessments. One of the challenges raised with the SCREEN-IT tool was the portion size estimation to facilitate this process (despite two photographs presented per category); however, this is not unique to SCREEN-IT but appears to be ongoing issue for all dietary assessment methods [52]. Accordingly, adding more portion size photographs as examples and/or providing more detailed instructions could be beneficial; however, a balance is needed as more text and photographs would impact the simple design as well as time to complete (two key benefits of SCREEN-IT) [40]. In addition, there are challenges with contextualising guidance (e.g., what is a standard portion size and how to visualise?) resulting in difficulty translating Eatwell Guide information into everyday eating habits [53].

Short dietary screening tools (<35-items) are inherently unable to provide complete data on intake but can estimate intakes for specific nutrients and highlight dietary components for improvement [21]. This research adhered to best practice for validation of dietary assessment tools by evaluating agreement between methods at individual and group levels (including different statistical techniques, interpretation criteria, sample size) [29, 39]. The dietary fibre categories (n = 10) were informed from pilot testing and captured food-level insights from the NDNS; however, consideration of meat-based alternatives and other relevant sources (including supplements) could help improve dietary fibre estimates in the future. All dietary assessment tools are associated with key challenges such as bias (e.g., self-reported, reliance on memory, social desirability, etc.), misclassification and measurement error [16, 18–20]. This may contribute to the higher dietary fibre estimates from the FFQ and/or result in overreporting of certain categories such as fruit and vegetables. The rationale for the two-week timeframe was twofold to support a more user-friendly approach (e.g., minimise burden, recall challenges, etc.) and in line with previous research [28]; therefore, differences in assessment time period (SCREEN-IT vs. eNutri-FFQ) may explain some of the variation identified between methods. In addition, despite using a randomised cross-over design, order effects are common in dietary assessments, typically resulting in lower intake on second measurements without necessary translating into an actual change in food intake [32]. Following evaluation, four key areas for improvement and future research were identified as summarised in Table 3.