Introduction
Sleep after learning stabilizes and integrates memories for long-term storage,1 while sleep prior to learning prepares the brain to encode new information.2 However, many adolescents obtain insufficient sleep, with 68% of teenagers in the US reporting sleep below the recommended 8–10 h each night3,4 Actigraphically assessed sleep length has been consistently shown to dip below 6 h on weekday nights for adolescents in East Asia.5,6 Chronic sleep restriction is associated with poorer academic performance7 and a reduced capacity to encode new information.6 Delaying school start times8 and setting limits on bedtime9,10 can improve adolescent sleep, but implementing these will entail significant effort and take time to employ effectively. In the interim, it remains an open challenge to improve learning given the restricted sleep adolescents currently obtain.
Daytime naps consistently enhance memory in laboratory studies involving children11–13 and adults.14–18 Recently these findings have been translated to classroom learning by examining the utility of napping using educationally realistic learning materials. When learning detailed facts about ecology, a mid-afternoon nap enhanced memory to a similar extent as when that time was spent cramming.19 A separate study found that a 2 h nap opportunity after a lecture was associated with better test performance in adolescents when compared to those who attended regular classes,20 while a third study found a similar advantage when weekly lessons were followed by naps of longer than 30 min.21
These findings suggest that it might be preferable to split available sleep time between a nocturnal bout and a daytime nap. Critically however, prior experimental research exploring the memory benefits of napping has only examined napping as a supplement to a fixed amount of nocturnal sleep.11–15,17–19 As such, nap conditions were associated with more total sleep in the 24 h period prior to cognitive tests compared to wake conditions that did not include a nap. Enhanced post-nap cognition could therefore be a function of total sleep obtained, rather than the nap per se. Determining if naps can benefit learning and memory when total sleep duration is held constant is crucial, as it could inform whether educational institutions should make the considerable practical adjustments that would facilitate napping in schools, or whether alternate solutions that focus on nocturnal sleep would provide similar benefits.
A handful of studies—conducted in adults with a view to optimize shift-work—controlled for total sleep obtained by splitting sleep into nocturnal and afternoon nap periods,22 or two equivalent periods across 24 h.23,24 Performance on a battery of cognitive tests was compared with continuous nocturnal sleep of the same overall duration. Measures of subjective alertness, psychomotor vigilance and processing speed were found to be determined by total sleep obtained, rather than how that sleep was distributed across the day.22–24 It remains to be determined how long-term memory is affected when learning takes place under a similar split sleep schedule.
To address these gaps in our knowledge, we compared long-term memory in adolescents who learned across two simulated weeks of restricted sleep in a naturalistic school setting, where sleep opportunities on each day were either split into 5 h nocturnal sleep and a 1.5 h daytime nap, or 6.5 h of continuous nocturnal sleep (Fig. 1). During the second week and for three consecutive days, participants spent an hour learning detailed facts about six amphibians in the morning, and another hour learning about six different amphibians after the nap in the late afternoon (Factual Knowledge Task; Fig. 2a). Participants were then tested the following evening after recovery sleep (9 h time-in-bed (TIB)). This makes provision for both groups being rested during retrieval, so that observed memory effects could be reasonably assigned to the effects of splitting sleep on prior encoding and/or consolidation, rather than retrieval. We determined whether memory for material learned in the morning and afternoon would differ between groups, since there are different encoding and consolidation advantages for each. Specifically, the relative loss of nocturnal sleep in the split sleep group could impair their ability to encode in the morning.6,25,26 However, the subsequent nap might compensate by enhancing consolidation of what was learned.18 If memory were purely a function of total sleep obtained, then memory for information learned in the morning or afternoon would not differ between split and continuous sleep schedules. This design permits the evaluation of how splitting sleep affects learning that is similar to the way students study and revise across multiple episodes in school. However, this methodology does not allow a clear attribution of group differences to encoding or consolidation.
To assess the effect of splitting sleep specifically on encoding, participants performed a separate task during the first week of the protocol: encoding pictures6 in the late afternoon on the fifth day of sleep restriction. Recognition of those pictures was tested after two nights of recovery sleep (9 h TIB; Fig. 2b). Since the opportunity to consolidate during this retention interval was the same in the two sleep conditions, performance at retrieval provides a reliable measure of encoding success.6,25 Prior work has shown improved encoding after a single daytime nap,17 motivating us to test if encoding capacity would also be enhanced under a habitual napping schedule where prior sleep was matched between nap and no-nap conditions.
CC BY 4.0. "Does splitting sleep improve long-term memory in chronically sleep deprived adolescents?" by Cousins JN, van Rijn E, Ong JL et al., NPJ science of learning (2019). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41539-019-0047-z. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC6599038). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.