Eyewitness testimony by individuals who stammer: Evidence, experience and perceived credibility · Maras K, Park S, Grafton P et al.

BACKGROUND

Navigating the criminal justice system (CJS) is challenging for any witness, but it can be especially difficult for those with speech, language and communication difficulties (Learoyd & Bryan, 2023). These challenges arise, in part, from the significant communication demands imposed during police interviews and court proceedings (Bagnall & Maras, 2025). Furthermore, case outcomes rely heavily on juror decisions that are significantly influenced by the presentation of individuals who testify (Bornstein & Greene, 2011). Juror assessments of credibility are often (erroneously) influenced by factors such as speech disturbances (e.g. hesitations, pauses and slower speech rate), emotional expression, eye contact, behavioural quirks, perceived confidence, likeability and trustworthiness, all of which are linked to an individual's communication and expression (e.g. Chalmers et al., 2022; Cooper et al., 2014; Jules & McQuiston, 2013; Neal & Brodsky, 2008; Vrij, 1998; Vrij & Fisher, 2020).

One group who, anecdotally, are suggested to face disproportionate challenges are people who stammer (PWS; Pritchard & Short, 2022). Stammering (also sometimes referred to as stuttering) is a speech fluency disorder that affects approximately 5% of the population at some point across their lifespan (Yairi & Ambrose, 2013). Stammering is characterized by difficulty in producing a smooth flow of speech, which typically manifests in core speech behaviours (e.g. elongations of syllables, hesitations and tense blocks), secondary behaviours (e.g. facial tension and excessive blinking), and cognitive and emotional features (e.g. speaking anxiety and stammering anticipation) (American Psychiatric Association, 2013; Jackson et al., 2015; Maguire et al., 2012). These features can significantly impact communication, with individuals often limiting their speaking or changing their syntax and engaging in behaviours such as foot tapping and eye closing to work through moments of stammering (Bricker‐Katz et al., 2013; Ward, 2008).

Stammering may impede effective communication in legal settings through a complex interplay of bio‐psycho‐social factors (Constantino et al., 2022). Providing testimony is stressful and anxiety‐provoking for most witnesses (Fairclough, 2024), which may in turn impair speech in an otherwise fluent speaker (Buchanan et al., 2014). However, giving testimony is likely to be disproportionately stressful and detrimental to the communication abilities of PWS (Parsons et al., 2022). Although stammering is not caused by anxiety or stress, such emotions often increase the frequency or intensity of stammering, particularly in high‐stakes interpersonal situations where communicative pressure is higher (Guitar, 2013; Parsons et al., 2022). This exacerbation may be partly due to the disruption these emotions cause to the motor control pathways responsible for speech fluency (Alm, 2004; Sander & Osborne, 2019).

Anticipating negative reactions from listeners contributes to the anxiety and speech disfluency PWS experience during communication exchanges (Boyle, 2018; Messenger et al., 2004; Tichenor & Yaruss, 2018). PWS are often perceived to be less competent and confident than those who do not stammer (Connery et al., 2020) and they encounter (and expect to encounter) negative responses to their speech (Connery et al., 2020; Guntupalli et al., 2007). Acute awareness of these assumptions leads many PWS to remain constantly vigilant to how they are being perceived when communicating (Bricker‐Katz et al., 2013), which can lead to heightened anxiety surrounding speaking and avoidance of certain situations and trigger words (Iverach et al., 2011). This hypervigilance is especially pronounced in interactions with public authorities, where some PWS fear being perceived as suspicious or dishonest (Wunderlich et al., 2023).

Resultantly, many PWS report prioritizing fluency at the expense of accurately articulating their intended message (Constantino et al., 2017; Parsons et al., 2022; Yarzebinski, 2022); for example, by using avoidance or coping strategies (e.g. swapping words or finding a different way to say something, saying less, or choosing not to participate in certain situations at all) to minimize their risk of stammering (Constantino et al., 2022; Grisham et al., 2015; Jackson et al., 2015, 2021). While these strategies may conceal overt stammering, they can undermine communication, leading to less precise word choices, abandoned speech and convoluted phrasing (Bricker‐Katz et al., 2013; Connery et al., 2020; Constantino et al., 2022). The cognitive burden of employing these strategies may further impact upon the content of communication (Iimura et al., 2016; Sander & Osborne, 2019); in bilingual speakers, for example, increased cognitive load from language‐switching reduces recall accuracy and self‐perceived credibility (Akehurst et al., 2018; Alm et al., 2019; Hu & Naka, 2023). It is possible, therefore, that the completeness and/or accuracy of the testimonies of PWS are impacted by the cognitive strain associated with using such avoidance or coping strategies.

In best practice (Ministry of Justice, 2022), police investigative interviewers typically ask witnesses to freely recall events in detail without interruption (‘free recall’), probing with follow‐up questions for further detail (‘cued recall’). Free recall not only protects the integrity of memories but also tends to be more cognitively demanding than cued recall, as it requires witnesses to retrieve episodic memories without external prompts, thereby increasing cognitive load (Boraxbekk et al., 2015; Chevroulet et al., 2021). For instance, it is well established that autistic individuals typically experience difficulty retrieving episodic memories, which is exacerbated in unsupported free recall and generally ameliorated under cued recall (Desaunay et al., 2020; Norris & Maras, 2021). However, two contrasting predictions can be made with regard to the effect of free and cued recall on the testimony of PWS. On the one hand, the demands of free recall may intensify cognitive load for PWS, as they must retrieve memories without having explicit cues while still engaging in speech‐monitoring, resulting in diminished recall quality (in terms of completeness or accuracy, or both). Conversely, cued recall may limit the ability of PWS to engage in coping strategies to avoid stammering, such as word substitution, circumlocution or pausing (Lowe et al., 2017; Menzies et al., 2008), as responses are dictated by specific questions. This may increase anxiety and cause a concomitant increase in cognitive load (Chen & Chang, 2017), to the detriment of recall.

Despite the challenges that PWS may experience when providing accounts, no research has examined how they fare when providing eyewitness testimony, nor how they are perceived by others. To address this gap, a series of three mixed methods studies were co‐produced with UK charity STAMMA to examine: (1) the quality (in terms of accuracy and completeness) of eyewitness accounts provided by PWS compared to a cognitive ability‐matched comparison group with no stammer (Study 1a); (2) how PWS experience and navigate the process of providing eyewitness testimony and how they believe the interview process could better support them (Study 1b); (3) the perceived credibility of PWS (Study 2); and (4) whether the provision of information about stammering improves jurors' perceptions (Study 3).