Fear of missing out, social media influencers, and the social, psychological and financial wellbeing of young consumers · Bartosiak A, Lee JE, Loibl C

Hypothesis development

Previous researchers in the area of communication technology and mental health have consistently found that individuals with higher levels of FoMO are more likely to have social media addictions [52,53]. Fear and anxiety about missing out on socially interactive events and experiences has been related to more frequent use of social network [54,55], which can facilitate interactions with social media influencers. Because a PSI is built upon repeated exposure with a persona [15], individuals who use social media more heavily are likely exposed to influencer posts more frequently and may feel that they are friends with the influencer via social media, resulting in stronger PSIs. Social media influencers may be able to exploit an individual’s FoMO because they tend to design their posts to be intimate and openly honest with followers [18]. Social media influencers are also considered to be similar to and relatable to followers [51] and are most successful if emphasizing a personal connection with their followers [18]. Consumers who turn to social media influencers to address their FoMO are thus creating an attachment which can grow into a PSI [18,56,57]. Therefore, we propose that individuals who possess a higher level of FoMO build stronger PSIs with social media influencers.

  • H1: FoMO is positively related to PSIs with social media influencers.

Relationship of FoMO and social, psychological, and financial wellbeing

FoMO has been shown to be negatively related to social wellbeing. Studies show that individuals can develop apprehensions that they are not being accepted by others [58] and become overwhelmed with the concern that they are not as popular as their peers [54,59] as humans have an innate need to belong that can drive much of their behavior [60]. Individuals who experience higher levels of FoMO want to feel as if they belong in their social settings, express higher levels of social envy, and experience feelings that they are being socially excluded [54,61]. Those individuals with greater FoMO also tend to misperceive others as having better lives than themselves and often overestimate other persons’ positive experiences while underestimating negative life experiences as compared to their own [61]. Based on these feelings, those with heightened FoMO may evaluate themselves as not being integrated into society well, leading to negative self-evaluations of their social wellbeing. Thus, we propose a negative relationship between FoMO and social wellbeing.

Further, with regard to FoMO and psychological wellbeing, FoMO has been associated with symptoms of depression and anxiety, lower self-esteem, lower body image, and general dissatisfaction with life [30,62]. These results have been identified across several age groups. Specifically, across two studies, one demonstrated that FoMO brought on by social media showed that undergraduate students experienced depression and anxiety symptoms [62] while the other study demonstrated similar anxiety and depressive symptoms, as well as boredom, in adults aged between 18 and 90 [63]. These findings are driven by the evidence that FoMO drive individuals’ negative emotions and internal status [8]. Based on the previous literature, we expect a negative relationship between FoMO and psychological wellbeing.

While there was no previous research investigating the direct or indirect relationship of FoMO and financial wellbeing, researchers have shown that FoMO can lead to impulsive purchases [64] and likelihood of purchasing products and services that other people recommended [20]. Further, individuals with greater FoMO tend to purchase products and services that their friends and family recommend in order to belong to the group and to be similar to the majority of people [20,64]. Frequent impulse buying behaviors lead individuals to purchase unnecessary and non-essential products, often leading to credit card debt, which may have a negative impact on their financial wellbeing [64]. Thus, we expect a negative relationship between FoMO and financial wellbeing.

  • H2: FoMO is negatively related to (a) social, (b) psychological, and (c) financial wellbeing.

Relationship of PSI and social shopping

The growing use of social media has changed how consumers shop online, as well as where they seek product recommendations and who they seek those product recommendations from, as is the case with social shopping [47,65,66]. Social shopping is encouraging consumers to become increasingly dependent on virtual communities to read experiences and reviews of products and promote social media platforms as the perfect place to discover new merchandise [47]. For example, younger generations make fashion and beauty purchases based primarily on what they see on social media, specifically from Instagram posts of influencer accounts [1]. Because influencers cultivate an environment that emphasizes accessibility by appearing to be everyday people, meaning their followers feel they share similar interests, background, and social status, influencers are perceived as relatable and trustworthy [2]. The availability of these trustworthy messages from influencers is often the determining factor in a consumer participating in social shopping activities [47].

Influencers build their brands by sharing valuable content and appealing to a captive audience, which provides a baseline for the PSI to be facilitated [67]. One way their success is measured is through the strength of the PSI, which can be strengthened in two ways: by how they share their content to connect with the audience [16] and by the frequency of content sharing for consumer exposure [68]. Social media posts and advertisements which contain the influencer and the advertised product generate a stronger reaction than when a post only contains the product [16]. This is often due to the established PSI a consumer has with the influencer and not the product. The attention given to the influencer drives mental stimulation which drives the interactions that consumers have with influencers [68] and if consumers are connected to influencers, they are more interested in purchasing influencer-promoted products [16,67]. Thus, we proposed H3 as follows:

  • H3: PSIs with social media influencers are positively related to social shopping behaviors.

Relationship of PSI with social, psychological, and financial wellbeing

PSIs are likely to come from increased social media use, which can have a positive relationship with social wellbeing if it inflates a person’s sense of belonging and feelings of validation [32]. Individuals who rely heavily on PSIs have been shown to translate the feelings achieved from these PSIs to face-to-face interactions [69]. A lot of the actions taken on social media (e.g., liking, commenting, responding to stories/poll) are similar to when interacting with an influencer as with a person whom there is a face-to-face connection [70]. These communication sensations and realizations draw upon the same social skills as a face-to-face relationship that often leads to friendship causing the line between parasocial and truly social to be blurred [71], potentially leading to improved overall social wellbeing. Although PSIs are typically unilateral and lack reciprocity [72], it has been shown that developed PSIs can often replace face-to-face relationships [9]. Therefore, the followers who have a strong PSI with their influencers may be likely satisfied with their social wellbeing through these interactions.

Psychological wellbeing needs, focusing on the inward emotional response, may be met through differently formed PSIs [71]. Individuals are more inclined to form PSI with influencers who actively engage in conversations by responding to comments and messages. This interaction not only makes followers feel valued and appreciated but strengthens their emotional attachment to influencers and enhances their perceptions of authenticity towards influencers [18]. Establishing a genuine and relatable connection akin to friendship with influencers can further enhance overall satisfaction and happiness, contributing to heightened psychological wellbeing in individuals’ lives. Moreover, individuals follow influencers to repeatedly receive updated content that resonates with their interests and aspirations [51], adding enjoyment and excitement into their lives while preventing boredom. Thus, we expect that the PSI with influencers will have a positive relationship with follower’s psychological wellbeing by leveraging happiness, enjoyment, and satisfaction in their life.

Social media influencers creating strong PSIs with their followers possess a considerable degree of power over them [73]. This power, promoted through relatable content on social media platforms, has the ability to get consumers to engage in certain acts, such as purchasing items they recommend or partaking in experiences they promote [5,67]. Consumers who are swayed to participate in the actions endorsed by influencers can provoke individuals who try to live a social media worthy lifestyle to go into debt [74,75] and, often times, individuals are swayed to act on impulse when a perceived companion, in this case, an influencer, is involved [76]. Consequently, even the simple act of imagining the presence of an individual, like an influencer, can change self-control habits [77] and potentially prompt impulsive buying behaviors [78], causing a potentially negative outcome on financial wellbeing [79]. Because higher levels of debt have been tied to financial worry and lower overall financial wellbeing [80], we propose a negative relationship between PSI and financial wellbeing.

  • H4: PSI with social media influencers is positively related to (a) social and (b) psychological wellbeing while it is negatively related to (c) financial wellbeing.

Relationship of social shopping with social, psychological, and financial wellbeing

Social shopping can be a key proponent of social wellbeing as the spirit of social shopping emphasizes interaction and involvement in purchase decisions [81]. Products promoted through online communities often fulfill hedonic motivations [73] and through the purchase of that product, a sense of community can be achieved [82]. Social shopping also often allows individuals to interact with others, providing the opportunity to compare experiences and seek opinions [82]. From buying products that a social media influencer recommended (i.e., social shopping), individuals may have a feeling of being included and integrated into the community that they want to belong, possibly leading to positive self-evaluation about their social wellbeing.

In addition, often times, people make purchases that comply with recommendations found on influencer posts and/or through their social communities. Individuals hope to mimic the levels of attractiveness and prestige through these unidirectional and recommended through social shopping purchases [12]. The decision to engage is often a result of consumers trying to purchase goods that will ultimately move them closer to being their ideal self and the act of buying goods is often an act performed to fulfill psychological benefits, like improving self-esteem [83,84]. Social shopping platforms, like Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok, promote and curate enviable, yet seemingly attainable, lifestyles, and many individuals make having a successful platform to share on career goal for [85]. As a person begins to feel the relatability, they feel that they are able to potentially achieve the lifestyle of an influencer and the follower begins to challenge their own self-efficacy, which is the belief that they should be able to achieve certain behaviors based on perceived similarities [86]. Because of this support, we propose that social shopping will have a positive relationship with individuals’ psychological wellbeing.

As consumers typically purchase items via social shopping to belong to their social group and mimic other people’s or influencers’ behaviors that are shown in social media, unnecessary and unplanned purchase (i.e., impulsive purchasing) may lead to overspending. A line can be drawn from general social media use to financial wellbeing as social shopping behaviors may influence the economic situation of consumers [73]. If a consumer is overspending and having greater financial worry due to social shopping, social media use may be negatively related to financial wellbeing [87]. Based on these notions, we propose that social shopping will have a negative influence on financial wellbeing. The research model is shown in Fig 1.

Figure. Research model of the relationships tested in the study. (See the original article for the figure.)

  • H5: Social shopping behavior is related to (a) social well-being and (b) psychological wellbeing positively, while (c) financial wellbeing negatively.