Background
Unhealthy dietary behaviours and lack of physical activity account for over half of the burden of type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular diseases (CVD), and both behaviours are important determinants of other major non-communicable diseases such as cancer and neurodegenerative diseases [1]. These unhealthy behaviours tend to cluster in people with a lower socio-economic status (SES) [2], making this an especially vulnerable group and a key focus for intervention approaches. Social cognitive theories suggest that individual-level factors such as attitude, knowledge and motivation are important determinants of lifestyle behaviours and should be intervened upon via educational strategies [3–6]. However, educational interventions targeting these individual-level level factors often lack sufficient effects in changing behaviours and health, especially on the longer term, and particularly in lower SES groups [7]. One reason for this may be the lack of sufficient consideration of the social, physical and economic context in which these health behaviours take place. Socio-ecological models posit [8, 9], and a growing body of evidence shows, that environmental interventions, i.e., changing food and/or physical activity environments, can be effective in changing dietary behaviours, physical activity and as a result cardiometabolic health [10–13]. As environmental interventions become incorporated into structures and systems [14, 15], they have the potential to sustainably make the healthy choice the easy choice. An additional benefit is that environmental changes reach all those who are exposed to these environments, including populations that are considered ‘difficult-to-reach’ in traditional experiments, such as people with a low SES [14, 16]. With the Supreme Nudge project we aim to develop, implement and evaluate environmental changes for a sustained impact on lifestyle behaviours and cardiometabolic health in low SES adults.
Pricing, nudging and food choice
Pricing and nudging strategies are expected to be promising environmental strategies. Indeed, the first economic law of demand states that if pricing of a certain product increases, demand will decrease, and vice versa [17]. Pricing strategies such as subsidies or taxes are effective in changing food purchases and consumption [18], where greater effects may be accomplished by combining subsidies on healthier products and taxation of unhealthier products [19]. Discounts on fruits and vegetables increase the purchase and intake of fruit and vegetables [20–23], whereas recently implemented food taxes reduced purchases when prices were increased; especially among low-SES individuals [24, 25]. Vulnerable populations, including lower SES consumers, are most price-responsive and, in terms of health, may benefit most from changes in the relative prices of foods and beverages [19, 26, 27].
However, the dual process theory describes that although individuals make choices based on both their rational, reflective system, they also use their impulsive, automatic system [28]. Nudging - also referred to as ‘choice architecture’ - encompasses subtle environmental changes that are implemented to make the desired choice more likely, without eliminating or forbidding the alternative option or changing economic incentives [29]. Nudges specifically target the heuristic choices, rather than rational, reflective choice and as such do not require conscious decision making [28, 30, 31]. The contemporary scientific literature demonstrates that nudging has great potential to influence food purchase- and intake behaviours [32–35], as well as physical activity [36], and is accepted by the public [37–39].
Although the evidence base on pricing and nudging strategies is growing, evidence is largely restricted to short-term effects on food purchases and (proxies of) health behaviours. Little is known about the combined and long-term impact of such integrated interventions on behaviours and cardiometabolic risk factors, and how to best implement these strategies in real life policy and practice.
Supermarket environment
Supermarkets play a central role in the food system. In large parts of the world, including the Netherlands, supermarkets are the place where people buy the majority of their food [40, 41]. Furthermore, generally a small number of companies hold a large share of the retail food market [42], implicating that changes by one or two retail chains have the potential to affect dietary choices of the population at large. As such, supermarkets provide a suitable setting for implementing and testing pricing and nudging strategies at the point of purchase, and can play a crucial role in developing strategies that can be adopted and sustained long-term.
Physical activity
Point of dietary choice settings such as supermarkets are well-suited to promote more healthful diets, but improving cardiometabolic health also requires changes in physical activity levels. Social cognitive and self-regulation theories suggest, and research has shown, that it is more likely for physical activity interventions to be effective if approaches are individually tailored and provide context-specific feedback on physical activity opportunities and performance levels [36]. Indeed, individually tailored feedback, goal setting and advice on dietary and physical activity behaviours have been shown to be superior to generic and more traditional health education attempts [43]. By making use of artificial intelligence and present those via app-based mobile technology, individually tailored and context-specific feedback can be computed automatically and provided instantaneously. The GPS sensor in smartphones and geo-fencing techniques enables users to receive prompts at crucial as well as contextual decision-making moments, e.g., choosing between taking their bicycle or car, or between taking the stairs or the elevator. The fundaments for a Supreme Nudge app that will provide such feedback were recently developed in our lab, following a systematic process and using theory-based behaviour change techniques [44]. The model-based and adaptive predictions used in that app enable highly tailored feedback, i.e. not only tailored to the user’s physical and social context and beliefs, but also communicated in a way that fits the user’s preferences, which is critical for actually reaching the low-SES users and support them to make healthy physical activity choices. The integration of informatics, psychology, and communication and media studies in the development of an adaptive individual and context-tailored ‘mHealth’ (‘mobile health’) intervention has great potential to promote physical activity, especially in high risk groups such as low-SES adults [45].
Implementation and upscaling
In order to induce sustainable behavioural changes and increase the maintenance of interventions all stakeholders need to be involved from the start of the project [46–48]. Community projects or multilevel interventions that have involved the target group from the start, taking a bottom-up approach, are generally more effective in reaching those most in need of the intervention. Co-creating intervention components is also more likely to generate the desired change, as the intervention components focus on behaviours or settings that are meaningful and feasible to the target group [49–54]. Involving stakeholders from food retail will provide insight into the dynamics of supermarkets operation and the barriers and opportunities to make the supermarket environment healthier, for instance through price deals or contracts with manufacturers and/or suppliers. Upscaling the intervention also requires the involvement of stakeholders, to embed the intervention components within a social systems’ culture and structure, as opposed to mere dissemination [55]. Current knowledge on how to effectively scale up health behaviour change interventions is scarce [56]. Within Supreme Nudge, we will use insights from the Transition Theory to optimise the upscaling of the intervention using a three-step approach: First, to gather evidence on the mechanisms and structures underlying effects (deepening). Second, to replicate the intervention in different settings (broadening). And third, to embed the intervention in broader societal structures such as policies of government and other organizations (embedding). Central to this approach is a System Innovation that takes into account: 1) the culture, containing the values and perspectives held by actors in the system, 2) the structure, consisting of the rules and organisational elements guiding and constraining system practices, and 3) the practice, representing actions relevant to the system, carried out by agents in the system [55].
The combination of using an environmental approach targeting the supermarket environment to stimulate healthier food purchases and using a personalized approach to support physical activity seems promising for the initiation of a healthy lifestyle and improving cardiometabolic health. Investigating the implementation and the evaluation of such a combined intervention within Supreme Nudge enables us to address a range of knowledge gaps that are highlighted in previous studies, including: 1) testing the effectiveness of a combination of promising intervention strategies as opposed to a single intervention; 2) pre-testing intervention components in controlled environments that mimic real-life situations as best as possible; 3) provision of evidence on the longer-term effects, including cardiometabolic health indicators; and 4) insights into whether pricing and nudging strategies in the supermarket can be effectively used to facilitate a healthy diet.
The Supreme Nudge project has been designed to address these gaps, with the overall objective to carefully develop, implement and evaluate –including evaluation of the development and implementation- a combination of pricing, nudging, and individualized feedback strategies in a point-of-choice intervention package for low-SES adults, in order to improve dietary behaviours and physical activity levels and, ultimately, cardiometabolic health.
CC BY 4.0. "Improving cardiometabolic health through nudging dietary behaviours and physical activity in low SES adults: design of the Supreme Nudge project" by Lakerveld J, Mackenbach JD, de Boer F et al., BMC public health (2018). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-018-5839-1. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC6054749). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.