Discussion
By employing the dynamic functional connectivity analysis, the current study is the first to identify the differences in the dynamic connectivity between the pilots and the controls. Our results revealed that the pilots exhibited an increased interaction of the CEN with the DMN and SN along with a decreased interaction within the CEN. They also exhibited a higher number of transitions.
In the human brain, lower-order brain systems, such as the primary motor and sensory systems, always have limited connections to other brain systems. Higher-order systems, such as the CEN, SN, and DMN, which involve internally guided, higher-order mental functions, have significantly more functional connections with other brain modules [30]. Previous studies have found that the DMN always has high within-network connectivity and high between-network connectivity, while the SN and the CEN always have high between-network connectivity and relatively low within-network connectivity [31]. In addition, long-term cognitive training also led to an increased interaction among the three networks [7]. These functional connectivity profiles may be crucial for optimal cognitive functioning [32] and may be the optimal functional configuration of the human brain. Meanwhile, during development, the CEN becomes increasingly incohesive, which means it slowly reduces the within-network connectivity. This characteristic may enable the system to have different subnetworks to enable more diverse functions [33].
In the current study, the pilots exhibited a decreased within-network functional connectivity in the CEN and enhanced functional connections among the CEN, SN, and DMN. The incohesive CEN in the pilots might enable the network to have more diverse functions. Meanwhile, the CEN, SN, and DMN are increasingly associated with other brain systems during development [31]. An increased between-network connectivity may correlate with the general cognitive performance. The aviation environment is a dynamic and high-consequence environment, and flying is a complex cognitive task. Flying included diverse tasks, such as manipulation, navigation, communication, cross-checking, monitoring, strategy planning, and conflict resolution. Pilots must always perform several tasks in a limited time and, sometimes, simultaneously. They should acquire, integrate, and respond to various task-related cues to make accurate assessment and speedy judgment. They conduct continuous cognitive transitions during work. Thus, the different functional properties of pilots may be related to their increased functional dynamics.
In the current study, the pilots made more state transitions than the controls. A higher number of transitions may be associated with greater functional dynamics and cognitive flexibility [34]. The reduced transition probability between states was associated with the immature and inflexible dynamic interactions between these three networks [35]. Moreover, the reduction in the transition between states was associated with patients with demented Parkinson’s disease [36]. A higher number of transitions in the pilots in our results might suggest that they have better functional dynamics and cognitive flexibility.
The present study has a few shortcomings. First, the age difference between the groups may have some effect on functional connectivity. The age range of the participants herein was 23 to 36. The functional connectivity between the brain areas was relatively stable. We expected that the age difference would not have a major impact on the results. Second, relevant cognitive tests were lacking. The explanation of our results could only be based on speculation. Task-based fMRI studies are needed to provide complementary information. In addition, we aim to foster a long-term relationship with some airlines, and the findings of the current study should be further confirmed with a larger sample.
CC BY 4.0. "Increased functional dynamics in civil aviation pilots: Evidence from a neuroimaging study" by Chen X, Wang Q, Luo C et al., PloS one (2020). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0234790. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC7302522). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.