Discussion
The present study describes intake and sources of total dietary fibre and dietary fibre fractions in children aged 6 months, 1 year, 3 years, and 6 years. Absolute intake of dietary fibre increased with age, but energy adjusted intake decreased with age. Breastfeeding was a major determinant of dietary fibre intake, contributing to higher total dietary fibre intake and a higher proportion of dietary fibre coming from the SDFS fraction. This was especially clear in 6-month-olds, where breast milk derived SDFS accounted for almost half of total dietary fibre intake. In older and non-breastfed children, insoluble dietary fibre was the major dietary fibre fraction, followed by the soluble dietary fibre fractions SDFP and SDFS. Important food sources of dietary fibre included cereal products, fruits and berries, potatoes, and vegetables, while the role of legumes, nuts, and seeds was relatively minor. We also studied socio-demographic differences in energy-adjusted intake of total dietary fibre in non-breastfed 1-year-olds, 3-year-olds, and 6-year-olds. Energy-adjusted intake of total dietary fibre was higher in children with older, more highly educated parents, and lower in those with smoking mothers.
Strengths of our study include utilising a representative, large sample with balanced drop-out, and follow-up through formative years of a child’s diet. Although prospective, self-reported dietary assessment methods may cause conscious or unconscious changes in food behaviour, our dietary data has been found to be of high quality in previous validation studies(25,26). Our study is among the first conducted using new, CODEX-compliant values for dietary fibre, and provides novel information on intake and sources of both total dietary fibre as well as dietary fibre fractions. To our knowledge, this is the first study assessing the role of HMO to dietary fibre intake in relation to the child’s total diet.
Regarding the weaknesses of the study, we must consider that dietary fibre fractions are merely an analytical classification and do not necessarily represent the diverse nature of dietary fibre accurately in terms of physiological effects. Furthermore, not all our updated database values were based on directly AOAC 2011·25 analysed values. This would, however, be unfeasible considering the number of entries in the database, as well as the fact that new, more refined dietary fibre analytical methods are still being developed(27,28). In the future, the methods AOAC 2009·01 and 2011·25 will be replaced by the method AOAC 2017·16, as it is still a further improved version of the previous one. Due to the changes, the latest method better mimics physiological conditions and improves the analysis of resistant starch and some NDO. The scale of effects on dietary fibre results are however likely to be much smaller than the effect of the transition from older methods to the CODEX-compliant methods.
The levels of total dietary fibre intake of Finnish children are in line with previous results of children in selected countries(6). We did find very high energy-adjusted levels of dietary fibre intake in breastfed children, but there is no previous data on dietary fibre intake in breastfed children that would have included HMO. Based on previous literature updated dietary fibre analysis methods also produce higher dietary fibre values(21,22,29,30). Due to the introduction of a new definition and analytical methods, it may be necessary to re-evaluate dietary fibre intake recommendations, as updates may result in higher intakes than previously produced.
Dietary fibre density of the diet decreasing as the child adapts a diet more similar to the rest of the family has also been reported in German children(31). It is possible that parents are more mindful of the healthiness of their child’s diet when preparing food separately and adopting a diet more similar to the rest of the family lead to a decrease in nutrient and dietary fibre density. Also consistent with our findings, USA children within the lowest quartile of dietary fibre intake had less educated caregivers with less purchasing power compared with children in the highest quartile(32). Other nutrients were not considered in our study but based on the sources of dietary fibre in our study children, a higher intake of dietary fibre could in general reflect a more nutrient-dense diet.
In source analyses, we did not find specific dietary fibre fractions to come from specific food groups. This would imply that source classifications such as cereal fibre or fruit fibre do not represent an analytically distinguishable dietary fibre type. Dietary fibre fraction analysis could provide an alternative classification method for studying health effects of different types of dietary fibre with reduced confounding effects by the food matrix.
Breast milk provides an infant with human milk oligosaccharides, which are vital for intestinal colonisation by gut microbiota, maturation of the immune system and in providing protection from infection(33,34). Mechanisms include providing structurally diverse energy sources for the microbiota, inhibition of microbial adhesion, cell signalling, short-chain fatty acid production and anti-inflammatory properties(33,34). Fructo- and galacto-oligosaccharides can be added to infant formulas to mimic the prebiotic content of breast milk, but based on our results, formulas can in no way replace breast milk as a source of NDO. More research is needed on HMO and the age and order of introduction to solid foods in relation to long-term child health.
Dysbiosis of the gut microbiota has been associated with the development of autoimmune diseases such as type 1 diabetes, and it is possible that appropriate prebiotic dietary fibre intake may ameliorate these processes(35). However, what exactly is appropriate remains unclear, as higher intake of total dietary fibre has also been associated with increased risk of type 1 diabetes(36). This could, however, be due to contaminants in the fibre matrix rather than dietary fibre itself, as harmful associations of, e.g. trypsin inhibitors, mycotoxins, heavy metals, or pesticides, all common contaminants in the cereal fibre matrix, have been speculated(36).
Cereal products, the main source of dietary fibre in our study children aged 1, 3 and 6 years, are also sources of harmful mycotoxins, inorganic arsenic, cadmium and lead(37,38). While exposure to these substances does not seem to be an issue in adults, recent data indicate that safety levels may be exceeded in children. As much as 88 % of Finnish 3-year-olds and 64 % of Finnish 6-year-olds exceed the tolerable weekly intake of cadmium(38). Diversifying dietary fibre sources in children could therefore be called for. Based on our results, there would be room for increasing the role of legumes, nuts and seeds in the diet of Finnish children.
Current recommendations for dietary fibre intake in children are inconsistent(39–45) as well as loosely evidence based. Recommendations for dietary fibre intake in children are often based on extrapolation from adults, but children are not ‘little adults’ and dietary fibre may serve a multitude of health benefits in children beyond laxation(46). More research is needed to assess health effects of dietary fibre and dietary fibre fractions in children, especially young children with developing gut microbiota and immunity. The role of the different dietary fibre fractions on the development of gut microbiota, gut immunity and childhood-onset autoimmune diseases should be explored. New recommendations for intake of dietary fibre for children should consider the multifactorial nature of dietary fibre for children’s health.
The Finnish nutrition recommendations for infants from 2004(47), around the time of the collection of our data, recommended exclusive breast-feeding until the age of 6 months. Introduction of solid foods was recommended to be started with spoon-fed purees made from potatoes, vegetables, fruits and berries. Cereal products, in the form of spoon-fed porridge, were to be added only after these introductory foods. The recommendations were reflected in our results: due to their later introduction, cereal products were a distinctly less important source of dietary fibre in children aged 6 months than at later age points. Also, a shift from oat as a more important source of dietary fibre in younger children to rye and wheat gaining importance in older children could be seen, as porridge is typically made from oat, but bread more commonly from wheat and rye in Finland. These food cultural phenomena could imply that our results can only be generalised to populations with similar food cultures as well as breast-feeding and early feeding recommendation.
The generalisability of our results may be restricted if other food composition databases are not updated with appropriate AOAC-method-based values as well. With the establishment of a CODEX definition for dietary fibre, homogenous analysis methods should allow different countries to utilise analysis results across borders. European food composition databases alone contain over 39 000 food entries, creating strong incentive for sharing the financial burden of database updating. Usage of outdated definitions and analytical methods not only hampers the exchange of database entries but also the comparability of study results. Mismatched dietary fibre definitions are an additional confounder that should be considered when studying dietary fibre, as the definition and analytical methods used can affect results related to the dietary fibre content and composition of foods. In young children, special consideration should be given to the inclusion of NDO and especially HMO in the definition of dietary fibre.
Conclusions
Our study based on updated CODEX-compliant food database values for dietary fibre and dietary fibre fractions found that the intake of dietary fibre fractions as well as the contribution of different food sources to dietary fibre intake shift through the first 6 years of life. Including oligosaccharides in the definition of dietary fibre values results in high intakes of total dietary fibre and SDFS in breastfed children, as breast milk is a major source of non-digestible oligosaccharides. In non-breastfed children, IDF is the major dietary fibre fraction followed by SDFP and SDFS, with cereal products, fruits and berries, potatoes and vegetables acting as the major food sources of dietary fibre.
CC BY 4.0. "Intake and sources of dietary fibre and dietary fibre fractions in Finnish children" by Salo TEI, Niinistö S, Korhonen TE et al., The British journal of nutrition (2023). https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007114523000466. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC10511677). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.