5. How We Can Reduce the Effect of Periodontal Treatment on Systemic Inflammation?
Given these short-term effects of periodontal treatment on systemic inflammation and associated claims of potentially increased cardiovascular events [82], it is legitimate to think about ways to treat periodontitis, while not incurring this risk. However, not many studies have investigated methods to manage systemic inflammation after periodontal therapy.
Table 1 summarizes studies investigating methods for modulation of systemic response to periodontal treatment. An investigation tried to modulate the inflammatory reaction after periodontal treatment [81]. Inflammatory cytokine production 24 h after treatment was compared in subjects undergoing full-mouth treatment versus quadrant scaling, and it was found that the subjects undergoing conventional quadrant scaling did not show a significant increase of CRP, IL-6 or TNF-α as compared to the ones undergoing full-mouth approach. On the other hand, in patients that underwent the full-mouth scaling, a strong systemic inflammatory reaction was observed. Furthermore, it was observed that one of the factors that was associated with the systemic response was the overall treatment time. Thus, it was suggested that, in subjects with complex medical histories and/or uncontrolled comorbidities, a conventional treatment approach and shorter appointments should be preferred in order not to cause an intense systemic inflammatory reaction [81]. Nevertheless, it is very important to remark that some other patients should be ideally treated in the minor number of appointments, since they might need antibiotics prophylaxis (e.g., endocarditis) [83] or other preparation prior to the treatment (e.g., hematological disorders and cardiovascular diseases) [84,85,86].
A randomized placebo-controlled clinical trial tested the possible adjunct effect of folic acid (FA) provided together with PMPR on homocysteine (Hcy) and CRP levels in GCF of periodontal patients. Although the FA group showed significant clinical attachment level gain, there was no significant change in biochemical parameters compared to placebo [87]. In support of these findings, low level serum and insufficient dietary FA intake showed impairment of periodontal health, in particular in smoker patients [92], whereas FA supplements and mouth-rinses led to a significant reduction of gingival inflammation and overgrowth [93].
Another study evaluated the effect of long-term weekly supragingival irrigations with aerosolized 0.5% hydrogen peroxide as maintenance therapy followed by PMPR on hs-CRP and white blood cell (WBC) count assessed at baseline and at 1, 2 and 3 years. After 1- and 2 years follow-up, the plasma levels of inflammatory markers decreased significantly, whereas at 3 years a less evident decrease was found, with values almost similar to the ones recorded after 2 years [88]. In light of the results, supragingival irrigations with 0.5% hydrogen peroxide may be considered a promising method. In fact, as has been previously reported, supragingival irrigations can reduce the number of periodontal pathogens [94], bacterial toxins [95] and host inflammatory products derived from periodontitis [23]. In contrast, a split-mouth study comparing 0.02% chlorhexidine (CHX) irrigations with sterile water, showed that CHX irrigations did not have any influence on increasing levels of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and IL-6, 5 min and 120 min after ultrasonic instrumentation, respectively [89].
Concerning the important of maintenance, a study observed that, despite an immediate reduction of systemic inflammation, lack of maintenance results in a long-term return to the baseline levels of inflammation [96].
Rasperini and et al. in 2019 assessed the effect of micronutrient supplements on systemic and local inflammatory markers, including CRP and salivary MMPs-8/-9. All patients followed the Mediterranean Diet (MD), characterized by the high consumption of olive oil, vegetables and fruits rich in antioxidants and vitamins; together with PMPR, one group received a micronutrient complex and the other olive oil-filled capsules. After one month, the patients underwent a full-mouth session of PMPR. No statistically significant differences were observed between groups in terms of salivary and serum MMP-8/-9 levels at any time point (baseline, 1- and 3 months post-treatment). Concerning the intra-group analysis, in the olive oil group the reduction of MMP-8/-9 in saliva was not significant at 1 and 3 months; in the other group, MMP-8/-9 levels were significantly reduced at 3 months, whereas at 1 month only MMP-9 levels decreased significantly. CRP serum levels were reduced after 3 months in both groups, but not enough to reach statistical significance. Overall, even though micronutrients are suspected to provide a beneficial effect on periodontal tissues by reducing inflammation and damage due to inflammatory diseases [97], MD did not affect local and systemic inflammatory parameters, except for a slight decrease in MMP saliva levels [90].
Graziani et al. in 2019 compared PMPR with application of enamel matrix derivative (EMD) (test group) versus PMPR (control group) in order to compare acute phase (at 24 h) and medium-term (3 months) inflammation in periodontal patients. Serum glucose, lipids, hs-CRP, cystatin C, D-dimer and fibrinogen were studied. Both treatments resulted in a marked increase in systemic inflammation at 24 h, with significant increase of CRP, D-dimer and cystatin C in the control group and only an increase in CRP and fibrinogen in the test group. D-dimer only showed a significantly higher increase in control group 24 h after treatment. At 3 months, biomarker levels significantly dropped and returned to baseline values in both groups, except for glucose, which was significant lower in the test group. The authors concluded that the adjunctive use of EMD led to a lower fibrinolysis. This may be due to the anti-inflammatory effect that EMD has, acting as a blood clot stabilizer and, consequently, improving wound healing [91].
CC BY 4.0. "Managing the Systemic Impact of Periodontitis" by Mainas G, Ide M, Rizzo M et al., Medicina (Kaunas, Lithuania) (2022). https://doi.org/10.3390/medicina58050621. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC9147054). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.