Discussion
This review of reading comprehension interventions for children with DLD included 24 studies spanning 24 years. This field of intervention research is dominated by group design and single-case studies with only one intervention that have been replicated (Wright et al., 2015). Nonetheless, the current review shows that 19 out of 24 studies reported some forms of significant improvement in reading comprehension, and all studies align with the AVR model. This pattern of findings is promising and, with further research, suggests that strong evidence-based practices for children with DLD can be developed. It should be noted that most of the studies were with young children from elementary school-age, and code-based interventions also had significant improvement in reading comprehension. Threats to validity were present, including variations in dosage and intensity of the interventions and measurement approaches, which would limit the clinical application of the findings, should be considered in future research. Despite these reservations, different reading comprehension interventions showed significant improvement, and future research should investigate the efficacy and effectiveness of these interventions on a larger scale.
Findings in the context of the AVR theory
We were able to classify all included studies into one or more components in the AVR based on the target skill(s) of the intervention (Duke & Cartwright, 2021). The intervention programs included one or more of the following components based on their treatment focus: self-regulation (with a focus on reading strategies instruction), word recognition (with a focus on phonological-level instruction), bridging process (with a focus on vocabulary knowledge and morphological awareness), and language comprehension (usually addressing extended discourse as the treatment target). Given the variations of participants and intervention features, it is difficult to draw strong conclusions evaluating the effectiveness of reading comprehension interventions. However, based on the available studies, all interventions targeting vocabulary knowledge and morphological awareness (categorized as the bridging process) had significant positive gains (Katz & Carlisle, 2009; McLeod & Apel, 2015; Rousseau et al., 1993; Staudt, 2009). This is consistent with findings from a meta-analysis (Burns et al., 2023) that interventions targeting bridging processes had the largest effect size compared to interventions targeting other components in typically developing children and children with reading difficulties. This is likely because the bridging process accounts for more shared variance of word recognition and listening comprehension than each of their variances (Foorman et al., 2020; Lonigan et al., 2018), leading to greater improvements in reading comprehension.
The relation between target skills in reading comprehension interventions and age remains unexplored. The included studies with adolescent participants focused on either strategy use or vocabulary knowledge, while the included studies with child participants focused on various aspects of reading comprehension skills. This is in line with the rope model of reading (Scarborough, 2001), which suggests that word recognition becomes more automatic and language comprehension skills become more strategic across ages for skilled reading comprehension. Thus, reading comprehension intervention in adolescents might focus on developing strategies for extended discourse skills, and that in children might focus on various aspects of reading skills. However, the included studies mostly focused on young children with DLD: they mostly focused on the learning to read stage, and less was understood on later stages of reading comprehension, including reading to learn, multiple viewpoints, and construction and reconstruction (Chall, 1983). The later stages are more complex and have a strong relation with academic success, and should not be ignored for the DLD population. More studies are needed to understand (1) the appropriate age for introducing reading comprehension strategies and (2) the extended discourse support on reading comprehension in adolescents with DLD. Children with DLD showed lower performance on executive functioning skills compared to age-matched peers (e.g., Blom & Boerma, 2020). Utilizing various reading comprehension strategies which can alleviate the lower executive function in children with DLD which in turn lower the linguistic processing demands. Thus, it is important to investigate the appropriate age for various reading comprehension strategies to prevent overloading their cognitive demands during reading comprehension. In addition, most of the extended discourse interventions focused on children in early school-age only, and the importance of extended discourse in reading comprehension increases over time when word recognition becomes automatic (Nation & Snowling, 2004). Given that DLD is a lifelong condition (Georgan et al., 2023), extended discourse support or intervention in adolescents might be effective for children with DLD to understand more complex texts.
It should also be noted that seven sub-components of the AVR had no studies included in the current review (motivation and engagement, alphabetic principle, reading fluency, graphophonological-semantic cognitive flexibility, cultural and other content knowledge, reading-specific background knowledge, and theory of mind). However, previous studies show that these components are related to reading comprehension skill in children with DLD (Lam et al., 2024), and interventions on these components can improve reading comprehension in both typically developing and struggling readers (Duke & Cartwright, 2021).
Threats to validity to reading comprehension intervention
One of the most important limitations that may hinder the ability to generalize the findings of the current scoping review is variations in dosage and intensity of the interventions. The included studies have a wide range of dosages and intensities, and no studies have examined the optimal amount of intervention needed for a significant effect size on reading comprehension performance. Thus, it remains unclear whether the non-significant results are due to non-optimal dosage and intensity.
Another area of limitation is the measurement approaches employed in the reviewed studies. Although the majority of studies used standardized reading comprehension tasks, such assessments may not be able to fully capture the complexities of the reading development of children with DLD. Children’s performance in reading comprehension varies by a number of factors, including individual factors (i.e., age, linguistic backgrounds, various skills involved in the reading comprehension process), text features (i.e., differential linguistic and structural features in various genres), and question types (e.g., literal and inferential comprehension questions; Kim & Petscher, 2021). The more specific, nuanced gradations that criterion-referenced measures can capture could be ignored when using general standardized reading comprehension measures (McCauley & Swisher, 1984). Standardized measures thus make it challenging to understand the multifaceted nature of reading comprehension development for this group of children, whose development and demands in various aspects of language and literacy skills likely vary. Therefore, it is important to use reading comprehension measures with ecological validity in addition to standardized assessments to examine the performance of various key component skills of reading, and how the performance differs by genres and question types. It is also worth noting that three of the studies utilized experimental tasks without reporting reliability information. Furthermore, interventions were often carried out without blinding of assessment, and only a small number of studies conducted follow-up assessments to evaluate the sustainability of intervention effects. This limitation restricts our understanding of the long-term impact of reading comprehension interventions in children with DLD.
Gaps in the literature
A gap in the literature is the lack of representation of multilingual children with DLD or children speaking another language as first language. Among the studies we reviewed, there was a strong focus (88 % of the studies) on monolingual English-speaking participants. This may have overlooked the diverse experiences and demands of multilingual children with DLD and children who speak a language other than English as their first language. The diverse linguistic backgrounds among multilingual children with DLD necessitate tailored and culturally sensitive reading comprehension interventions. Instruction that draws on children’s diverse linguistic backgrounds and funds of knowledge can facilitate their literacy development. Neglecting the needs of this population may risk leaving a large portion of the DLD population underserved. Future studies should examine the features of reading comprehension interventions that can cater to the needs of multilingual readers and readers with various first languages.
Furthermore, the optimal intervention dosage for reading comprehension interventions needs to be explored. The intervention dosage for various areas to achieve optimal treatment effectiveness is important for clinical practice. Future studies can consider examining the optimal intervention dosage, such as session length, dose frequency, total intervention duration, cumulative intervention intensity, and so on, based on the types of intervention (Zeng et al., 2012). This can help examine the outcome of interventions while balancing the economic or resource concerns. In addition, the frequency of the intervention (i.e., spacing effect and massed learning) might also be a topic for future research, given that reading comprehension is a skill that takes time to develop, and children with DLD may thus need continuous support in this area.
Clinical implications
Although the nature of a scoping review limits our ability to provide definitive instructional practice recommendations regarding the feasibility, appropriateness, and effectiveness of specific interventions (Munn et al., 2018), there are two major clinical implications. First, the current review highlights a wide range of treatment approaches for improving reading comprehension in children with DLD. Interventions targeting different components of the AVR framework, including oral language, decoding, bridging processes, and active self-regulation, showed significant and positive outcomes for individuals with DLD. This suggests that clinicians can consider a variety of approaches when designing interventions. Second, clinicians should take into account both the individual’s characteristics (e.g., language profile, developmental stage, and comorbidities) and dosage-related information (e.g., frequency, intensity, and duration) when tailoring interventions. Considering these factors may help maximize effectiveness of interventions for individuals with DLD.
CC BY 4.0. "Reading comprehension intervention in populations with developmental language disorder: A scoping review" by Lam JHY, Wang J, Pratt AS et al., Journal of communication disorders (2026). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcomdis.2025.106608. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC13286734). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.