Resting-state EEG delta and alpha power predict response to cognitive behavioral therapy in depression: a Canadian biomarker integration network for depression study · Schwartzmann B, Quilty LC, Dhami P et al.

Results

In total, forty-one participants were recruited for the study. Thirty-seven completed clinical assessments at baseline and at the end of the therapy. Thirty participants completed EEG sessions at both baseline and week 2 (three participants missed the EEG session at baseline, and four participants missed the EEG session at week 2) and were included in the analysis (Table 1).

Of the thirty participants considered in this study, sixteen (53%) were responders, and fourteen (47%) were non-responders. Groups did not differ by sex (p = 0.134) or age (p = 0.400). However, responders and non-responders differed by ethnicity (p = 0.011). No differences were observed between groups in MADRS scores at baseline and week 2 (p = 0.641 and p = 0.615, respectively).

Relative power EEG spectra

The average relative power EEG spectra for responders and non-responders at baseline and week 2 can be found in Supplementary Fig S1. Relative power measures showed excellent internal consistency with an averaged Cronbach’s alpha across frequencies and electrodes of 0.911 at baseline, and 0.925 at week 2, respectively (Supplementary Fig S2).

Differences in relative power

Analysis of variance showed a significant (p < 0.05) interaction effect of CBT Response x Time [mean F(1, 28) = 5.747 (4.197 to 17.358)] across several frequencies and channels in the sensor space. A significant interaction effect of CBT Response x Time [mean F(1, 28) = 5.791 (4.201 to 14.159)] was also observed across several frequencies and regions of interest in the source space. As such, several post-hoc analyses were conducted. In what follows, the results of post-hoc t tests, correlational and predictive analyses are presented for baseline, week 2 and change in baseline to week 2. For each analysis, cluster-based permutation testing was applied to correct for multiple comparisons.

Relative power at baseline

At baseline, post-hoc analysis revealed a group difference in delta band, with responders exhibiting lower delta activity compared to non-responders (negative cluster, p = 0.016, Cohen d = 0.882, Fig. 1). In the source space, this difference was identified in several brain areas, including bilateral precentral gyrus and sulcus, bilateral central sulcus, bilateral postcentral gyrus and sulcus, bilateral precuneus, bilateral superior and inferior parietal gyri, bilateral middle occipital gyri, left midcingulate cortex (MCC), and bilateral posterior cingulate cortex (PCC) (Fig. 1).

The difference observed between groups in the delta band at baseline was found to be predictive of the treatment outcome (AUC = 0.754, p = 0.006 in the sensor space, and AUC = 0.754, p = 0.006 in the source space, Fig. 2).

Results were similar when including all participants who completed the EEG session at baseline (thirty-four participants) and can be found in Supplementary Figs S3 and S4.

Relative power at week 2

At week 2, post-hoc analysis did not reveal any differences between groups in relative power. There was also no significant correlation between relative power at week 2 and improvement in depressive symptoms.

Results did not differ when including all thirty-three participants who completed the EEG session at week 2 (thirty-three participants).

Early changes in relative power

Post-hoc analysis revealed group differences in delta and alpha bands, with responders exhibiting an increase in delta activity (positive cluster, p = 0.020, Cohen d = 1.118, Fig. 3) and a decrease in alpha activity (negative cluster, p = 0.014, Cohen d = 0.949, Fig. 3) relative to non-responders. Both differences were localized to similar brain regions, including left precentral, postcentral, and superior parietal gyri, left central sulcus, left precuneus, and left MCC and PCC. In addition, decrease in alpha was also localized to right precentral gyrus and left inferior parietal gyrus (Fig. 3).

Early changes observed in delta and alpha activity were good predictors of response to CBT. The significant prediction models had the following characteristic: early changes in delta activity model (AUC = 0.848, p = 0.001 in the sensor space, and AUC = 0.799, p = 0.002 in the source space, Fig. 4), and early changes in the alpha activity model (AUC = 0.830, p < 0.001 in the sensor space, AUC = 0.768, p = 0.007 in the source space, Fig. 4).