The Impact of Racism on Health: A Health Equity Training on Structural Racism for Military Residents and Fellows · Wright V, Stepp E, Flemming B et al.

Methods

We (a group of residents, fellows, and two faculty advisors) developed a five-part DEI curriculum as members of the DEI Committee at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center. The project was granted IRB exempt status at our institution. Curriculum developers were from different specialties (internal medicine, pediatrics, psychiatry, physical medicine & rehabilitation, radiation oncology, and adult hematology/oncology) and each had various experiences in public health, clinical care, and DEI education. The Impact of Racism on Health module described in this publication is one part of this curriculum developed using Kern's 6-Step approach.5

Step 1: Problem Identification and Needs Assessment

Development of this module was a dynamic process. Our DEI Committee recognized a need for more opportunities for GME trainees to have formal DEI discussions. Before implementing our curriculum, many of our programs had yet to dedicate a didactic session to addressing these topics. In discussing our collective past experiences and the known scarcity of curricula focused on the application of DEI concepts in military health care, we determined that the ideal approach would be a curriculum that could be a primer on DEI concepts through a lens of military cultural competency.

Step 2: Targeted Needs Assessment

We conducted informal interviews of a subset of DEI committee representatives on their exposure to structural racism teaching in the past to identify the current practices of our GME programs and perceived best practices. Our informal interview of committee members’ prior experiences with anti-racism education revealed a preference for small group discussion, reflection, and case-based learning when being taught this material.

We also conducted a literature search of structural racism curricula. From this work, we identified structural racism as a gap in current DEI education within most of our GME programs and were able to identify teaching approaches that were successful in other anti-racism curricula.8–11

Step 3: Goals and Objectives

Based on our needs assessment we compiled a list of DEI concepts to focus on for this curriculum and literature review, which included structural racism and social determinants of health. Thereafter, we decided upon specific learning objectives for this module based on what we perceived as core topics and skills related to structural racism.

Step 4: Educational Strategies

We selected a combination of educational strategies aligned with our learning objectives and literature review: traditional lecture for introducing concepts, large-group discussion to explore understandings of concepts, and small-group discussion to allow for reflection and case-based learning. We included a case representative of a known racial health disparity in the MHS from the literature: pediatric asthma outcomes. This was included to encourage the application of structural racism and social determinants of health lenses to a clinical scenario familiar to our target audience as consequence of factors (e.g., absence of health insurance or job opportunities) that lead to health disparities in many other communities which are not typically faced by ethnic/racial minorities in our patient population.

Step 5: Implementation

The Impact of Racism on Health module (Appendix A) was designed to be approximately 1-hour, including 30 minutes of didactic material with large-group discussion prompts throughout the presentation followed by 20 minutes of small-group work.

The session began in a large classroom with seats arranged in circles of four to six chairs for small groups that were not preassigned. Learners began by completing a pretest (Appendix B) in Google Forms via a QR code within the presentation. Next, the facilitator presented the didactic portion of the module for approximately 25 minutes, which provided the core content for each learning objective. The last section of the module was used for small-group case-based learning where learners discussed the case for 15 minutes. The small-group activity was followed by a 10-minute debrief where each small-group provided one or two examples of structures in the case that might be impacted by racism and how this knowledge might change the way they counsel the patient and family.

We presented the module as part of required didactic sessions for all residents within both programs. We designed it to be generalizable to GME trainees of other specialties as well.

Two residents who helped develop the module facilitated the presentations. Neither facilitator had significant experience with anti-racism teaching prior to facilitating so prepared for this presentation by reviewing the facilitator guide (Appendix C) and doing practice runs with codevelopers. Feedback from the other developers was used to revise the facilitator guide to a more user-friendly version that future facilitators could use to adequately prepare.

Between the first and second implementation of this module, we included additional literature about pediatric asthma disparities in the MHS due to the first facilitator's observation that many participants were not aware that this data existed and were questioning the applicability of the module's content and case example.

Step 6: Evaluation and Feedback

We developed pre- and posttest knowledge assessment (Appendix B) related to the learning objectives to assess this module. The development was not based on anything previously used or published. No pilot testing was completed.

We collated assessment data for our analysis. Given concerns about the nonnormal continuous data from the collected assessments and an inability to pair the data, the data informatics team at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center's partnering institution, Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, was consulted for analytic assistance. We used a two-sample Mann–Whitney U test for data analysis at their recommendation.