The longitudinal association between children's growth mindset in senior primary school and their parents' growth mindset · Chen J, Liu C

Discussion

Mindset has a powerful impact on many aspects of child development, such as educational attainment, emotions, health, and self-esteem (Robins and Pals, 2002; Blackwell et al., 2007; Yeager et al., 2011, 2013, 2014; Romero et al., 2014). However, less is known about the trajectory of mindset in children or the role of parents’ mindset in shaping children’s mindset over a long period of time and its growth pattern. In this study, through five waves of longitudinal data, latent variable growth models were adopted to explore these questions. The results showed that the growth mindset of the senior primary school children decreased over time, and there were significant individual differences in the initial level and growth of mindset. Paternal and maternal growth mindsets were also on the decline. Our results in the parallel process latent growth curve model suggested that whether controlling for children’s gender and age, paternal education level, maternal education level, and annual family income (1) children in senior primary school showed higher levels of growth mindset after two-and-a-half years if their mothers reported higher levels of growth mindset in the beginning; (2) children showed higher levels of growth mindset after two-and-a-half years if their mothers’ growth mindset declined slower during this period, while they showed lower levels if their mothers’ growth mindset declined rapidly; (3) the mothers’ growth mindset declined and the children’s growth mindset also showed a downward trend during this time; and (4) there was no significant relationship between both the initial level and the decline of the father’s mindset and the development pattern of the children’s mindset.

The developmental trajectory and characteristics of growth mindset

Consistent with the results of previous studies (Ablard and Mills, 1996; Cheng and Hou, 2002; Harter, 2012), in this study, the growth mindset of children in senior primary school showed a downward trend. With increasing age, the children at this age increasingly believed that they were invariable and could not be improved through tasks. The developmental trajectory of children’s growth mindset is consistent with the development of children’s average levels of self-evaluation. In elementary school, children’s social cognition changes in the following aspects. One is that children can gradually distinguish between their ideal selves and their real selves, and they do not see themselves as positively as they did when they were young (Harter, 2006b). Another aspect is that they acquire increasingly more social information, which they use to make comparisons when evaluating themselves (Harter, 2006b; Gore and Cross, 2014). Another aspect is that children gradually learn to put themselves in others’ shoes, and they know how others evaluate themselves, which is not always positive (Harter, 2006a). Accordingly, because of the improvement in social cognition, children’s self-evaluation will decline (Robins and Pals, 2002; Harter, 2006b,c). Reduced self-evaluation permeates everything, with children acting less confident, refusing challenges to avoid failure, and not believing that their abilities are malleable, which is the decline of growth mindset. In addition, students in the upper grades of primary school are about to enter adolescence, face challenges about biological, cognitive, emotional, and social changes, and become more negative in early adolescence, particularly in the domains of academic abilities and self-expression (Eccles et al., 1984; Marsh, 1989; Wigfield et al., 1991).

In our study, parents’ mindset of children in senior primary school also decreased over time. People in middle age, after experiencing the struggles of career and life, become more mature and stable psychologically and emotionally. Studies have shown that adults experience both job burnout and parenting burnout (Mikolajczak et al., 2019; Roskam and Mikolajczak, 2020). This relatively less positive attitude and emotion can spill over into every aspect of life. Based on this view, parents may think that hard work is less likely to change their ability.

In this study, we found that the initial level and rate of descent of the growth mindset had a significantly negative correlation in both children and mothers but not fathers, that is, when the level of mindset is higher, the rate of decline is faster. This may reflect the “regression-toward-the-mean” effect. Both the initial level and the rate of change of mindset showed significant individual differences in all the participants, which is the same as in previous studies (Bempechat et al., 1991; Pomerantz and Ruble, 1997; Wang, 2003). There are many reasons for this difference, including not only the characteristics of the participants themselves but also the characteristics of their significant others, and even the influence of the family’s socioemotional environment could affect children’s beliefs directly and indirectly (Simpkins et al., 2015). Therefore, this explains the importance of exploring the antecedent variables that influence the development of different age groups’ mindsets.

The influence of parents’ growth mindset on the development of children’s growth mindset in senior primary school

In the process of parental education involvement, according to self-determination theory, parents support their children in three ways, namely, affinity support or engagement (respect and warmth); ability support (adequate help and noncritical feedback); and autonomy support (providing choices and encouraging exploration; Grolnick et al., 1997; Joussemet et al., 2008). Competence support refers to parents helping their children build a sense of ability or competence and giving attention to learning and developing existing and new skills, such as discovering their children’s gifts and interests and providing support for developing these gifts and interests. In the process of cultivating children’s sense of ability, children form an understanding of their own or others’ abilities and gradually establish a concept of ability and stability of ability. Parents with a growth mindset insist that ability consists of increasing knowledge and skills, and they will devote more attention to the learning and development of children’s knowledge and skills in parent–child interactions, which may influence children’s mindset from the two aspects of parenting beliefs and behavioral interaction. In terms of parenting beliefs, parents’ belief in their children’s failure (failure mindset)—Do parents view their children’s failures as positive and helpful or do they view these failures negatively as obstacles to their children’s success?—will affect children’s mindset. Parents with a growth mindset are more likely to look at failure positively, let the child learn from the failure of growth, help the child to grow in the failure and to not be afraid of challenges, and believe that efforts will be made to help the child to form a growth mindset (Haimovitz and Dweck, 2016). In terms of behavioral interaction, a previous study with an online sample of 300 parents indicated that when parents believed more that their abilities were fixed, they were more likely to engage in controlling and performance-oriented behaviors; in contrast, parents engaged in autonomy-supportive and mastery-oriented behaviors when they believed that their abilities were not fixed (Muenks et al., 2015). In addition, the way that parents praise and criticize their children can also have an impact on their children’s mindset. Person praise, which attributes a child’s success to a fixed trait, such as praising children for cleverness, will build the perception that a child’s abilities are beyond his or her control. Process praise and criticism, which attributes the success and failure of the child to his efforts to give more or less, will make the child think that he can achieve success through his own efforts and form a growth mindset (Xing et al., 2011; Gunderson et al., 2017b, 2018). Parents with a growth mindset believe that ability is malleable, thus, praise and criticism for children are more based on the external performance of children and less evaluated from the fixed characteristics of children, which is also conducive to the formation and development of children’s mindset. This study indicates that mothers’ mindset plays a vital role in the development and change of children’s mindset.

However, we did not find an influence on fathers’ mindset; this is not to say that fathers have no influence on all children samples, although parents play different roles in the care of their children. Mothers give more attention to the physical development of their children, while fathers exert an important influence on their children’s intelligence, emotional volition, socialization, and other aspects through interaction with their children (Steinberg and Silk, 2002; Paquette, 2004; Craig, 2006; Xu and Li, 2019). In general, mothers assume the primary role of child care, and during the middle and teenage years, mothers seem to interact with their children more frequently than fathers (especially regarding care and daily family tasks) by spending significantly more time with their children than fathers and other family members (Craig and Mullan, 2011). Moreover, considering traditional Confucianism in China, the idea that fathers are mainly responsible for work and mothers are mainly responsible for the family is deeply rooted (Wu et al., 2012). Even the role of the mother may restrict the involvement of the father in the education of the child, which is called maternal gatekeeping (Allen and Hawkins, 1999; Zvara et al., 2013), thus, the mother plays a greater role in the education of the child. The beliefs and values of the mother will be transferred to the child in more frequent parent–child interactions, and the child’s perception of the mother’s beliefs will be greater than that of other caregivers, thus, it is speculated that the formation and development of the child’s mindset will be more influenced by the mother.

Multiple group analyses suggested that fathers’ mindset influences girls’ mindset more than boys’ mindset. This is inconsistent with the results of previous studies that supported the idea that children may be more likely to model the attitudes, values, and behaviors of their same-gender parent (Bussey and Bandura, 2004; Pomerantz et al., 2004). The probable reason is that fathers tend to be more democratic with their daughters than with their sons (Kausar and Shafique, 2008), and fathers dote on their daughters and give them more support. In addition, girls show more attachment and identification with their fathers because of the Oedipus complex.

Implications and limitations

In general, this study investigated the developmental trajectory of children’s mindsets, and there were significant individual differences in the initial level and rising rate of children’s mindsets in senior primary school. Previous studies have not found a link between parental mindset and children’s mindset, while the relationship was proven from the perspective of the developmental trajectory, and we also found the role of fathers and mothers to be different. Theoretically, this study enriches the longitudinal research on mindset and provides support for mindset interventions and a reference for research on the parent–child mindset. From the perspective of practice, this study indicates the different roles of parents in the development of children and suggests that parents should actively participate in family education.

Although this study extends prior studies in this area, there are still some limitations to note. First, we investigate the relationship between the mindset of children in the upper grade of primary school and their parents’ mindset in the Chinese context; however, the generalizability of the current study to other populations is less clear. For example, it is well known that as adolescents transition into adolescence, they are faced with greater environmental changes, and how their mindset develops and is influenced by other factors during this process remains to be further investigated. Future studies could also investigate the relationship that we found in this study in other cultural contexts. Second, this study does not explore the specific mechanism of the influence of parental mindset on the development of children’s mindset, and future studies could investigate this mechanism in more detail so that more parents can understand this relationship and give educational advice specifically and operationally.