"Warning: ultra-processed": an online experiment examining the impact of ultra-processed warning labels on consumers' product perceptions and behavioral intentions · D'Angelo Campos A, Ng SW, Duran AC et al.

Introduction

Ultra-processed foods (UPFs) consist of industrial formulations that contain little or no whole food ingredients, are assembled using intense processing methods (including physical, chemical and biological processing), and contain synthetic additives such as flavorings, colorings, aromas, and emulsifiers [1]. A substantive body of epidemiological evidence shows an association between consumption of UPFs and a range of adverse health outcomes [2–10], with especially strong evidence linking higher UPF intake to increased risks of cardiovascular disease-related mortality, mental disorders, and type 2 diabetes [11]. While many UPFs are high in nutrients of public health concern (e.g., added sugars, saturated fats, sodium) and low in more beneficial nutrients (e.g., fiber, vitamins, minerals, protein) [12–16], nutrient content and degree of processing represent different product dimensions. Public health interventions such as food labeling have traditionally focused on foods’ nutrient content, but recognition of the additional importance of degree of processing for dietary patterns has been growing [17] as epidemiological evidence points to UPFs’ nutrient content only partly explaining their associations with adverse health outcomes [18–24].

Brazil has in many ways been at the forefront of public health efforts targeting UPF consumption. The Nova system, which was developed in Brazil, divides foods into four categories based on their degree of processing (i.e., 1 = unprocessed or minimally processed, 2 = processed culinary ingredients, 3 = processed foods, and 4 = ultra-processed foods) and provides the most widely accepted definition of UPFs globally [25]. Nova has had a large influence on Brazil’s general public health discourse, which culminated in the Brazilian Ministry of Health using Nova as the basis for its Dietary Guidelines for the Brazilian Population, published in 2015 [26]. The Guidelines recommend that Brazilians make unprocessed or minimally processed foods the basis of their diets, use culinary ingredients in small amounts to create culinary preparations, limit processed foods, and avoid UPFs [26]. Despite these efforts, UPF consumption remains a concern; as of 2018, 19.7% of the calories consumed in Brazil were estimated to come from UPFs, which represented a 5.5% increase from 2008 [27]; and as of 2022, around 10% of premature deaths among Brazilian adults were attributed to UPF consumption [28]. Importantly, recent increases in UPF consumption have been greater among individuals with the lowest income and education levels, individuals who identify as Black, pardo (i.e., “brown” or mixed-race) or Indigenous, and in the lowest-income regions of the country (i.e., North and Northeast) [27].

In 2022, in a parallel effort to improve population-level diet quality, Brazil joined the now more than 10 countries in the Americas that mandate interpretive nutritional front-of-package labeling (FOPL) for foods and non-alcoholic beverages. Interpretive FOPLs provide nutritional information through visual cues (symbols and graphics) to aid consumers’ interpretation of such information [29]. The World Health Organization recommends FOPLs for their wide reach and low cost [30], and studies show that FOPLs help consumers identify unhealthier foods, discourage their purchase, and encourage the food industry to reformulate many such products [29, 31]. Brazil’s FOPL scheme, similarly to other countries in the Americas, is composed of warning labels applied to products that exceed added sugar, saturated fat, and sodium thresholds set by the Brazilian Health Regulatory Agency (ANVISA). Although not all existing FOPL schemes use this warning label model, all convey information exclusively about products’ nutrient content [32]. However, experts and global advocacy organizations have proposed that information about products’ degree of processing also be incorporated into FOPLs [33]. In the Brazilian context, ultra-processed warning labels could enhance coherence between the country’s Dietary Guidelines and its FOPL scheme.

To date, the benefits of adding ultra-processed labels to existing nutrient labels remain unknown. Previous studies with samples from the United States and France suggest that different types of ultra-processed labels (i.e., an octagonal ultra-processed warning label and an ultra-processed banner as part of a summary nutritional label) could help consumers better identify UPFs, decrease perceived healthfulness of UPFs, and discourage consumption [34, 35]. However, in both studies, ultra-processed labels were only tested in comparison to control conditions (i.e., no labels or neutral labels). No research has yet examined whether there would be any benefits to changing the status quo in countries that already mandate FOPLs by adding ultra-processed labels to existing nutrient labels.

This study aimed to assess the impact of adding an ultra-processed warning label to nutrient warning labels on a sample of Brazilian consumers’ product perceptions and behavioral intentions. We hypothesized that participants who saw combined ultra-processed and nutrient warning labels would be more likely to identify all products presented as ultraprocessed and would report lower intentions to purchase the product, lower perceived product healthfulness, and higher perceived message effectiveness than participants who saw only nutrient warning labels. We also explored consumers’ prior understanding of the term “ultra-processed” to contextualize experimental results.