What Determines Vaccine Hesitancy: Recommendations from Childhood Vaccine Hesitancy to Address COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy · Rodrigues F, Block S, Sood S

2. Methods

We (two of the authors, FR and SB) conducted a literature review of peer-reviewed articles, utilizing Google Scholar and the PubMed database, and grey literature from UNICEF and WHO written in the English language to see approaches that have worked to improve vaccine hesitancy. Overall, the 117 articles were extracted because they addressed vaccine hesitancy and uptake, measurement tools, and quality of service between the health provider and caregiver. The literature review specifically included looking for sets of tools that incorporate direct data collection with providers and caregivers, including the constructs included in the model below. To begin, we conducted a document review and discovered 91 tools that showcase provider and caregiver characteristics. The literature review started with a keyword search for “patient-provider/client-provider interpersonal communication”, which led to a variety of assessment tools in various fields such as counseling and therapy in family planning and drug treatment adherence. Next, when searching for keywords “vaccine hesitancy and interpersonal communication” and “motivation interviewing and vaccine hesitancy”, assessment tools addressing various health concerns and topics were found through Google, Google Scholar, and PubMed. These domains were selected based on available literature on areas where counseling has been examined, such as HIV/AIDS, medication adherence, mental health, reproductive health, and cancer. Inclusion criteria included the presence of valid and reliable tools and questionnaires addressing the quality of service between clients and providers. We presented the conceptual model at capacity-building workshops with professionals from 23 countries in the Europe and Central Asia Region. These colleagues included individuals with affiliations to different health sectors, and all of them had experience in training FLWs. These meetings served as a form of validation for our conceptual model constructs through discussions and feedback based on research and personal experience.

2.1. Conceptual Model for Addressing Vaccine Hesitancy

The creation of our conceptual model below is based on a review of 15 articles specifically relating to vaccine uptake and hesitancy. Our final model combines three existing vaccination models: WHO Increasing Vaccination Model (Figure 1), the SAGE Vaccine Hesitancy Determinants Matrix (Figure 2), and the Journey to Immunization–UNICEF (Figure 3). Each of these models has its strengths and weaknesses. The core strength of each of these models is that they illustrate causal factors associated with vaccine hesitancy.

2.2. WHO Increasing Vaccination Model

The 2017 Increasing Vaccination Model showcases the factors that increase vaccination uptake among individuals [13]. This model is set in a context where governments fund some of the cost of vaccinations, or private insurance covers the cost. These factors result from a variety of behaviors by a multitude of different factors [14]. The three main propositions in the model are that vaccination uptake results from what people think and feel and the social processes that lead to motivation and ultimately vaccination uptake (Figure 1).

The first proposition in this model is that an individual’s thoughts and feelings motivate vaccine uptake [14]. This includes perceived risk, hesitancy, confidence, and trust. Social processes come next, motivating the uptake of vaccines and consist of a recommendation from health providers, social and gender norms, information sharing, and rumors. Motivation, as shown in the middle, plays a vital role in predicting vaccine uptake. The practical issues box underscores the barriers to vaccination, but these issues are measurable and can be addressed through vaccination programs. In isolation, these factors might not always have a meaningful impact on vaccine uptake (i.e., individual thoughts and feelings) [14]. Still, their interactions, including the role of practical issues, make this a promising model. Overall, the Increasing Vaccination Model showcases the interrelated factors, resources, and behaviors that affect vaccination uptake.

While very practical, the Increasing Vaccination Model is relatively simple and includes one-way relationships between individual and social processes that can increase vaccination coverage. These one-way relationships fail to consider other interactions that could take place. This model places vaccine hesitancy as part of the “motivation factors” followed by structural issues such as availability and affordability. However, vaccine hesitancy is a complex process that exists despite the availability of vaccines [5,14]. This distinction is important from an intervention perspective. In the model’s current state, it appears that if a provider recommends a vaccine, that will influence motivation, but motivational factors would not impact how a recommendation is perceived. It has been previously demonstrated that an individual who is motivated towards something is selective in how they perceive external factors [15]. In addition, this model does not indicate a relationship between individual thoughts and feelings and social processes. Lastly, as the creators of this model acknowledge, more research is needed to determine the role of social processes on vaccine uptake [14].

While providing ample information on the barriers to vaccination uptake at each level of the socio-ecological model (SEM), the Increasing Vaccination Model falls short of explicating the specific causal linkages between the barriers that cut across the different levels of SEM.

2.3. The Vaccine Hesitancy Determinants Model

The Vaccine Hesitancy Determinants Model, created in 2012, was adapted from the results of a discussion held with approximately 40 experts from relevant fields during the “Workshop on the Cultural and Religious Roots of Vaccine Hesitancy: Explanations and implications for the Canadian Healthcare” [7] (Figure 2). This model was based on the 3Cs, which postulates that vaccine hesitancy exists at the intersection of three factors: confidence, complexity, and complacency. The detailed matrix showcases the variety of factors that influence individual behavior regarding vaccine hesitancy [16]. The Vaccine Hesitancy Determinants Model consists of three interrelated areas addressing vaccine hesitancy, including the role of the individual decision-making process, the role of public health, and the role of health professionals. Individual reflection and their decision-making process are influenced by communication and media, religious and cultural characteristics, attitudes, risk perception and evaluation, knowledge, and beliefs. The role of public health influences vaccination programs and coverage. Public health also plays a large role in communicating with the population in an acceptable manner. The role of health professionals is influenced by knowledge, beliefs, and training, and influences counseling and vaccine delivery services [17]. Overall, the model stresses that individual decision-making regarding vaccination is multifaceted and involves emotional, cultural, social, religious, and political factors just as much as it involves cognitive factors.

The Vaccine Hesitancy Determinants Model is a comprehensive approach to understanding multiple causal factors influencing vaccine hesitancy. It has been used widely in research to examine vaccine hesitancy in specific contexts as well as a global phenomenon. While this model has the potential for standardization of the determinants of vaccine hesitancy, there is still a lack of clarity in some of the constructs. For example, previous research has highlighted the challenges of determining vaccine hesitancy at the population level [18]. Additionally, it may be much too complex to understand and apply holistically to intervention research.

2.4. The Journey to Immunization–UNICEF

The third model, the Journey to Immunization, created in 2017, follows a caregiver or vaccine recipient’s journey to immunization [19]. This model may also be used to follow the journey of a health care provider since the end goal is immunization (Figure 3). This model spans from the knowledge and awareness of vaccines to what happens after vaccination and allows interventions to focus on the area that needs the most attention. The elements of this model are situated within a socio-ecological framework and include individual, family, community, health care, and political systems. The model applies a steps approach by highlighting six core factors within a vaccination journey. These include knowledge and awareness, intent, preparation, cost and effort, point of service, and after service. Knowledge and awareness address the actual vaccine, disease, and service (such as when, where, and how to get the vaccine). Intent is overcoming the gap between intent to vaccinate and getting vaccinated. Willingness to vaccinate is contributed to attitudes towards the behavior, subjective norms, and perceived behavioral control. Preparation considers the disease, vaccination, and service and determines the logistics of acquiring the vaccination (for example, transportation, cost, and childcare). Cost and effort relate to opportunity, transportation, lost income, uncertainty of service, and social and security costs. Point of service involves all aspects of the vaccination experience (such as client satisfaction and interpersonal communication with health providers). Finally, after service includes some factors such as feedback, next steps, side effects, and reminders.

Figure. Journey to Immunization–UNICEF (2017) [19]. (See the original article for the figure.)

The Journey to Immunization Model is useful to understand barriers and provides a process-oriented framework for designing future interventions. Still, its cyclical nature makes it difficult to utilize as an evaluation framework.

2.5. Front Line Health Workers and Interpersonal Communication and Counselling

UNICEF has found that a key determinant leading to vaccine hesitancy is linked to the quality of communication between health workers and clients. Health workers can be perceived as either trusted sources of information or having insufficient knowledge [20]. Therefore, the final opportunity to be influenced lies in the skills of the FLW. Even though most caregivers support immunizations and immunize their children before entering school, questions and concerns are still customary. Questions and concerns regarding childhood vaccinations and COVID-19 vaccinations can relate to side effects, ingredients, and number of doses [21]. According to WHO, FLWs are seen as influencers and trusted sources of information on vaccines [5]. Therefore, FLWs must be trained and supported to provide accurate information and support to patients. Strengthening health workers’ interpersonal communication and counseling (IPC/C) capacities is one effort to deliver messages and promote vaccine uptake effectively. Interpersonal communication (IPC) specifically focuses on informing and educating caregivers, soon-to-be-caregivers, and vaccine recipients about vaccination. A recommendation from a health provider can move a caregiver or vaccine recipient from hesitant to accepting a vaccine [7,14,16,20,22,23]. Recommendations from a frontline worker may increase confidence, set a social norm, or showcase a direct behavior change method [14].

After studying these models and conducting an extensive literature review, the conceptual model below reflects important constructs to consider when addressing vaccine hesitancy (Figure 4). The overarching goal for this model is “To improve demand for and equitable delivery of immunization services with a focus on increased access to and demand for immunization services.” The impact of reducing vaccine hesitancy is measurable through improved vaccination uptake and subsequent declines in the incidence of vaccine-preventable diseases. This is the long-term view of the process. Several proximal factors contribute to the reduction in vaccine hesitancy. Background factors include age, gender, socioeconomic status, and geographic location, to name a few.

Furthermore, other factors can be classified into upstream factors and downstream factors. Upstream factors include facilities, supplies, policies and laws, and communication and media environment. Challenging upstream factors falls within the realm of governments, international organizations, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and national and local governments. Successful vaccination uptake requires addressing upstream factors that are linked with vaccine uptake but not directly connected with the constructs in our model. The purpose of this model is not to provide a holistic picture but to measure specific intermediate outcomes (indicators), which can then be directly linked to the intention to vaccinate.

The impact of vaccination programs can truly be verified by studying trends in vaccine uptake. This data takes time to collect, is collected at an aggregate level, and does not provide a nuanced look at the ground level. Therefore, one specific key measurable outcome for intervention evaluations can be identified as “intention to vaccinate” and/or “vaccination reported by vaccine recipients”.

This model specifically focuses on provider and caregiver/vaccine recipient factors that influence the intention to vaccinate. This outcome is achievable through a series of related steps. Although most constructs are standalone, some constructs for providers are multidimensional and cannot be directly measured. In these cases, broader topics were identified and subdomains created. For example, the broader topic of affective counseling by providers is measured through empathy, active listening, cultural competence, and interpersonal communication. Combining these questions can help create an affective counseling scale measure, which can then be correlated with other constructs. Additionally, motivation is a function of confidence, follow-up, and interest towards the caregiver.

The constructs under the caregivers’ box in the conceptual model showcase the levels of the SEM. Individual-level constructs include attitudes, perceived threat, social norms, perceived behavioral control, decision-making, complacency, confidence, counseling satisfaction, and interpersonal communication; community-level constructs include trust in providers, caregiver vulnerability, sources of information, misleading information, and community responsibility; finally, at the societal level is convenience and the right to vaccination. This conceptual model is intended to be adaptable to local contexts, and sub-measures that are not relevant to specific contexts can be deleted.