When a Manager and Employee Define Success Differently
A manager asks for a draft “by Friday.” The employee delivers a thoughtful outline on Friday afternoon; the manager expected a finished document that morning. The deadline was only one part of the expectation. The example illustrates how assumptions about obligations can grow alongside explicit instructions, and why naming the deliverable can resolve more than repeating the date.
Introduction to the Psychological Contract
The psychological contract refers to the unwritten, implicit expectations that exist between an employer and an employee. These expectations can include things like job security, opportunities for advancement, and a sense of belonging. The psychological contract is often based on assumptions and can vary significantly from one individual to another. For instance, an employee may assume that their hard work and dedication will be rewarded with a promotion, while their manager may not necessarily share this expectation.
A Worked Example
Consider the fictional case of Emily, a marketing specialist who has been with a company for three years. In this illustrative example, Emily defines success as working independently, taking on new challenges, and receiving regular feedback. Her manager defines success primarily by meeting sales targets and completing tasks on time. Emily meets her sales targets consistently but feels undervalued because she is not receiving the autonomy or feedback she values. Her manager views her as high-performing but is puzzled by her dissatisfaction.
In this example, the psychological contract between Emily and her manager is unclear, leading to differing definitions of success. Emily's manager assumes that meeting sales targets is the primary measure of success, while Emily believes that her autonomy, challenges, and feedback are equally important. This discrepancy can lead to misunderstandings and decreased job satisfaction for Emily.
Explicit Performance Standards
Explicit performance standards, on the other hand, refer to the clearly defined, measurable goals and expectations that are communicated to an employee. These standards are often outlined in job descriptions, performance reviews, and goal-setting meetings. Explicit performance standards provide a clear understanding of what is expected of an employee and how their performance will be evaluated.
In the case of Emily, explicit performance standards could include specific sales targets, deadlines, and key performance indicators (KPIs). By clearly outlining these expectations, Emily's manager can ensure that she understands what is required of her and can work towards achieving these goals. However, explicit performance standards do not necessarily address the psychological contract or the implicit expectations that Emily may have.
Clarifying Expectations
To avoid misunderstandings and ensure that both parties are working towards the same goals, it is essential to clarify expectations. This can be achieved through regular communication, feedback, and goal-setting meetings. By discussing and agreeing upon explicit performance standards, managers and employees can ensure that they share a common understanding of what success looks like.
In addition to explicit performance standards, managers should also be aware of the psychological contract and the implicit expectations that exist between them and their employees. By acknowledging and addressing these expectations, managers can create a more positive and supportive work environment. In Emily's case, her manager could have a conversation with her to understand her expectations and values, and work together to create a plan that aligns with both her explicit performance standards and implicit expectations.
Individual-Level Explanations
At the individual level, differing definitions of success can be attributed to various factors, including personality, values, and motivations. For instance, some employees may be more driven by intrinsic motivators, such as personal satisfaction and growth, while others may be more extrinsically motivated, focusing on rewards and recognition. Managers should be aware of these individual differences and tailor their approach to each employee's unique needs and expectations.
In Emily's case, her manager could have recognized that she is more intrinsically motivated and provided her with opportunities for growth and development, such as training or mentoring. By understanding and addressing Emily's individual needs and expectations, her manager could have created a more supportive and motivating work environment.
Team-Level Explanations
At the team level, differing definitions of success can be attributed to factors such as team culture, communication, and collaboration. When team members have differing definitions of success, it can lead to conflicts and decreased teamwork. Managers should foster a team culture that encourages open communication, collaboration, and a shared understanding of goals and expectations.
For example, Emily's team could have established a shared understanding of their goals and expectations through regular team meetings and feedback sessions. By encouraging open communication and collaboration, Emily's manager could have created a more cohesive and effective team, where each member understands and works towards the same objectives.
A Contrasting Case
Consider the fictional case of David, a software engineer in a team-oriented environment. In this illustrative example, David's manager defines success by the team’s ability to deliver high-quality products on time. David, however, initially focuses on his individual contributions as the measure of his success. The manager emphasizes teamwork, encourages open communication, and provides feedback that highlights both individual and team achievements. Over time, David begins to value collaborative outcomes more highly and adjusts his personal understanding of success to include team-based goals.
In this contrasting case, the manager's emphasis on teamwork and collaboration helps to create a shared understanding of success among team members. By recognizing the importance of individual contributions and team goals, David's manager can foster a positive and supportive team environment, where each member understands and works towards the same objectives.
In conclusion, when a manager and an employee define success differently, it can lead to misunderstandings and decreased job satisfaction. By understanding the psychological contract and explicit performance standards, managers can clarify expectations and create a more positive and supportive work environment. At both the individual and team levels, recognizing and addressing differing definitions of success is crucial for fostering a cohesive and effective team. By encouraging open communication, collaboration, and a shared understanding of goals and expectations, managers can help to create a workplace where each employee can thrive and succeed.
- Key Takeaways:
- Psychological contract refers to the unwritten, implicit expectations between an employer and an employee.
- Explicit performance standards refer to the clearly defined, measurable goals and expectations communicated to an employee.
- Clarifying expectations is essential to avoid misunderstandings and ensure that both parties are working towards the same goals.
- Individual-level explanations for differing definitions of success include personality, values, and motivations.
- Team-level explanations for differing definitions of success include team culture, communication, and collaboration.
- Organizational psychology plays a crucial role in understanding the dynamics between managers and employees within a workplace setting.
- Success can be defined differently by managers and employees, leading to misunderstandings and decreased job satisfaction.
- Psychological contract and explicit performance standards are two key concepts that can help to clarify expectations and create a more positive and supportive work environment.
Rachel's performance is evaluated using a combination of sales targets and client feedback. After several months, her sales figures are below target, but she has received consistently positive feedback from clients. In a performance review, Michael and Rachel discuss these results and recognize a misalignment between the current evaluation criteria and Rachel’s strengths. They consider how to better balance quantitative and qualitative outcomes in her role.
They decide to add more weight to customer satisfaction metrics in Rachel's performance evaluation. This change allows Rachel to focus on building strong relationships with clients while still working towards meeting her sales targets. As a result, Rachel's job satisfaction increases, and she becomes more motivated to succeed in her role.
Worked Solution
To resolve the discrepancy between Michael's and Rachel's definitions of success, they follow these steps:
- Identify the differences in their definitions of success
- Discuss and agree upon explicit performance standards that include both sales targets and customer satisfaction metrics
- Create a plan that aligns with the company's overall goals and Rachel's strengths and motivations
- Regularly review and adjust the plan as needed to ensure it remains effective
By following these steps, Michael and Rachel are able to clarify expectations and create a more positive and supportive work environment.
Changing Conditions
If the company were to undergo a significant change, such as a merger or a shift in market trends, Michael and Rachel's definitions of success might need to be re-evaluated. For example, if the company's new goal is to expand into a new market, Rachel's sales targets and customer satisfaction metrics might need to be adjusted to reflect this new objective.
- Communicate changes clearly and promptly to all employees
- Re-evaluate and adjust performance standards and expectations as needed
- Provide training and support to help employees adapt to changes
- Encourage open feedback and discussion to ensure that everyone is aligned with the new goals and objectives
By being aware of the potential impact of changing conditions, Michael and Rachel can proactively adapt their plan and ensure that Rachel's definition of success remains aligned with the company's overall goals.
How might Rachel's definition of success change if she were to take on a new role within the company? What steps could Michael take to ensure that Rachel's performance evaluation is fair and accurate? How might the company's overall goals and objectives influence the definitions of success for other employees?
For the wider context, read Roovet’s guide to industrial and organizational psychology or explore the social psychology course.
Further reading: CIPD, The Psychological Contract.