Why Two Managers Give the Same Work Different Ratings
Two managers watch the same employee handle a difficult request. One rewards the quick response; the other notices that an important detail went unconfirmed. Before averaging their ratings, ask what each manager thought the score represented. A disagreement about the definition of good work calls for a different response from a disagreement about what happened.
Introduction to Rater Effects
Rater effects refer to the systematic errors or biases that influence a manager's evaluation of an employee's performance. These biases can arise from various sources, including personal preferences, expectations, and experiences. For instance, a manager who values teamwork may give higher ratings to employees who demonstrate strong collaborative skills, even if their individual performance is not as strong.
A Worked Example
Let's consider an illustrative example to clarify this concept. Suppose we have two managers, Alex and Maya, who are evaluating the performance of two employees, Jack and Sarah, in a marketing department. Both Jack and Sarah are responsible for creating social media campaigns, and their performance is measured by the engagement generated on the company's social media platforms. Alex gives Jack a rating of 4.5 out of 5, while Maya gives Sarah a rating of 3.8 out of 5, despite both employees generating similar engagement metrics.
In this illustrative example, we cannot infer that Alex is a more lenient rater or that Maya is a stricter rater based solely on these two ratings. Differences in ratings could stem from variations in how each manager interprets performance criteria, weights different aspects of the work, or observes behaviors not captured by engagement metrics. This scenario highlights how rater effects—systematic differences in evaluation tendencies—can lead to inconsistent ratings even when objective outcomes are similar.
Calibration and Concrete Behavioral Anchors
To address rater effects, organizations can implement calibration techniques, which involve training managers to evaluate performance using a standardized framework. One effective approach is to use concrete behavioral anchors, which provide clear and specific examples of behaviors that correspond to different levels of performance. By using these anchors, managers can ensure that their evaluations are based on observable behaviors rather than personal biases or expectations.
For instance, a calibration framework for the marketing department might include the following behavioral anchors:
- Level 1: Fails to meet deadlines, resulting in delayed campaign launches
- Level 2: Meets deadlines, but campaigns lack creativity and engagement
- Level 3: Consistently meets deadlines and creates campaigns that generate moderate engagement
- Level 4: Exceeds deadlines and creates campaigns that generate high engagement and exceed targets
- Level 5: Consistently exceeds deadlines, creates innovative campaigns that generate exceptional engagement, and demonstrates leadership in the team
By using these anchors, Alex and Maya can ensure that their evaluations of Jack and Sarah are based on specific, observable behaviors rather than personal opinions or biases. This approach helps to reduce rater effects and provides a more accurate and fair assessment of employee performance.
A Contrasting Case
Now, let's consider a contrasting case where calibration and concrete behavioral anchors are not used. Suppose we have a sales team where managers are expected to evaluate employee performance based on their sales numbers. However, the evaluation criteria are vague, and managers are not provided with clear guidelines on what constitutes high or low performance.
In this scenario, managers may rely on their personal experiences and biases when evaluating employee performance, leading to inconsistent and potentially unfair ratings. For example, a manager who values aggressive sales tactics may give higher ratings to employees who use these tactics, even if they are not effective in generating sales. On the other hand, a manager who values building relationships with customers may give higher ratings to employees who focus on customer service, even if their sales numbers are lower.
This lack of calibration and clear behavioral anchors can lead to confusion and frustration among employees, as they may not understand what is expected of them or how their performance is being evaluated. It can also lead to unfair treatment of employees, as some may be held to different standards than others.
Lesson Learned
The key takeaway from this discussion is that rater effects can have a significant impact on employee evaluations, and that calibration and concrete behavioral anchors are essential for ensuring fair and accurate assessments. By providing clear guidelines and expectations, organizations can reduce the influence of personal biases and ensure that evaluations are based on observable behaviors.
It's also important to note that calibration is not a one-time event, but rather an ongoing process that requires continuous training and monitoring. Managers should be regularly trained and updated on the evaluation criteria and behavioral anchors, and their evaluations should be reviewed and discussed to ensure consistency and fairness.
Ultimately, the use of calibration and concrete behavioral anchors can help organizations to create a more fair and transparent evaluation process, which can lead to increased employee satisfaction, engagement, and performance. By recognizing the potential for rater effects and taking steps to mitigate them, organizations can ensure that their evaluations are based on accurate and unbiased assessments of employee performance.
Advanced Applications of Rater Effects and Calibration
To further illustrate the importance of calibration and concrete behavioral anchors, consider a hypothetical scenario where a company evaluates customer service representatives using a 1–5 rating scale. The scale lacks clear definitions for each level, and managers receive no standardized guidance on what distinguishes performance levels. In such cases, evaluations may reflect individual rater tendencies more than actual differences in employee performance, leading to inconsistency across assessors.
For example, a manager who values technical knowledge may give higher ratings to representatives who can quickly resolve complex technical issues, even if they are not as effective in handling customer complaints. On the other hand, a manager who values empathy and communication skills may give higher ratings to representatives who are able to de-escalate conflicts and provide excellent customer service, even if they are not as knowledgeable about the company's products.
A Hypothetical Application
Suppose we have two customer service representatives, Emily and David, who work in the same team and handle similar customer inquiries. Emily is highly technical and resolves complex issues quickly but sometimes comes across as abrupt. David excels at de-escalating conflicts and providing empathetic service but occasionally needs help with technical details. Without a standardized evaluation system, managers might rate them inconsistently based on personal priorities. A calibration framework with behavioral anchors can help ensure evaluations reflect specific, observable behaviors relevant to job performance.
For instance, a calibration framework for customer service representatives might include the following behavioral anchors:
- Level 1: Fails to resolve customer complaints in a timely and effective manner
- Level 2: Resolves customer complaints, but may not always provide excellent service
- Level 3: Consistently resolves customer complaints and provides good service
- Level 4: Exceeds expectations by resolving complex issues and providing exceptional service
- Level 5: Consistently exceeds expectations and demonstrates leadership in the team
Using these anchors, we can evaluate Emily and David's performance based on specific, observable behaviors. For example, if Emily consistently resolves technical issues quickly and effectively, but sometimes comes across as abrupt to customers, she may receive a rating of 4 for technical knowledge and a rating of 2 for customer service skills. On the other hand, if David consistently provides excellent customer service and de-escalates conflicts effectively, but sometimes struggles with technical questions, he may receive a rating of 4 for customer service skills and a rating of 2 for technical knowledge.
Worked Solution
To illustrate how calibration can address rater differences, imagine two managers, Rachel and Michael, evaluating Emily and David. Rachel emphasizes technical proficiency and rates Emily a 5 and David a 2. Michael prioritizes interpersonal skills and gives Emily a 2 and David a 5. These divergent ratings reflect rater effects—differences in interpretation rather than absolute performance. Applying a shared calibration framework with behavioral anchors allows both managers to assess each employee across distinct competencies, such as technical problem-solving and customer interaction, leading to more balanced and consistent evaluations.
Using a calibration framework with behavioral anchors, evaluations can be broken down by specific job-relevant dimensions. For example, Emily might receive a 4 in technical knowledge for resolving issues efficiently but a 2 in customer service if her tone is perceived as abrupt. David might earn a 4 in customer service for effective conflict resolution but a 2 in technical knowledge if he frequently escalates issues. This multi-dimensional approach reduces reliance on subjective impressions and aligns ratings with observable behaviors.
By using a calibration framework with concrete behavioral anchors, we can reduce the influence of personal biases and ensure that evaluations are based on observable behaviors. This approach can help to mitigate rater effects and provide a more accurate and fair assessment of employee performance.
Changing One Condition
To illustrate how changing one condition can change the explanation, let's consider an example. Suppose we change the evaluation criteria to include a new metric, such as employee engagement. If we add this metric to the calibration framework, we may need to adjust the behavioral anchors to reflect the new criteria. For example, we may add a new anchor for employee engagement, such as:
- Level 1: Fails to demonstrate engagement and enthusiasm for their work
- Level 2: Demonstrates some engagement and enthusiasm, but may not always be motivated
- Level 3: Consistently demonstrates engagement and enthusiasm for their work
- Level 4: Exceeds expectations by demonstrating exceptional engagement and enthusiasm
By adding this new metric, we can ensure that our evaluations are more comprehensive and take into account multiple aspects of employee performance. However, we must also ensure that the new metric is aligned with the overall goals and objectives of the organization, and that it does not introduce new biases or inconsistencies into the evaluation process.
In conclusion, calibration and concrete behavioral anchors are essential for ensuring fair and accurate assessments of employee performance. By providing clear guidelines and expectations, organizations can reduce the influence of personal biases and ensure that evaluations are based on observable behaviors. By using a calibration framework with concrete behavioral anchors, we can mitigate rater effects and provide a more accurate and fair assessment of employee performance.
The key takeaways from this discussion are:
- Calibration and concrete behavioral anchors are essential for ensuring fair and accurate assessments of employee performance
- Rater effects can have a significant impact on employee evaluations, and can be mitigated through the use of calibration and concrete behavioral anchors
- Changing one condition, such as adding a new metric to the evaluation criteria, can change the explanation and require adjustments to the calibration framework
- Organizations must ensure that their evaluations are based on observable behaviors and are aligned with the overall goals and objectives of the organization
Readers can observe that the use of calibration and concrete behavioral anchors can help to mitigate rater effects and provide a more accurate and fair assessment of employee performance. By using a calibration framework with concrete behavioral anchors, organizations can ensure that their evaluations are based on specific, observable behaviors rather than personal opinions or biases. Readers can also observe that changing one condition, such as adding a new metric to the evaluation criteria, can change the explanation and require adjustments to the calibration framework.
For the wider context, read Roovet’s guide to industrial and organizational psychology or explore the social psychology course.