Breakfast and Exercise Improve Academic and Cognitive Performance in Adolescents · Kawabata M, Lee K, Choo HC et al.

1. Introduction

Good evidence demonstrates the benefits of regular breakfast intake on cognitive function in children and adolescents [1]. Much of the influence of breakfast on cognition likely results from acute intake of food rather than a long-term improvement in nutrient status [1,2,3,4,5]. The immediate benefits of breakfast are evident on measures of memory and in terms of fewer errors on tasks related to attention, especially later in the morning when performance deteriorates with fasting [1,3,5]. Satiation and hunger alleviation, improved fuel and nutrient provision for the central nervous system, and an increase in the synthesis or levels of brain neurotransmitters are all mechanisms via which breakfast may mediate short-term improvements in cognition [1,4,6,7]. Breakfast composition is one aspect of important consideration with lower glycemic index (GI) or glycemic load breakfasts appearing favorable in terms of cognitive outcomes [2,3,4,6,8]. This may result from better blood glucose regulation or, alternatively, from a favorable hormone or neurotransmitter response [1,6].

Whilst breakfast can improve acute cognitive function, effects on academic performance or attainment are more difficult to demonstrate. An early randomized controlled study in 405 undernourished and 405 well-nourished rural Jamaican children suggests small improvements in test achievement scores in those children who were given breakfast to consume [9]. More recently, observational data support the effect of regular breakfast intake on academic performance and grades and longitudinal data from the United Kingdom have shown an association of regular breakfast consumption with performance measured 6 and 18 months before Statutory Assessment Tests [10]. From the perspective of the acute intake of food, breakfast is unlikely to cause any lasting changes in academic outcomes. However, it seems logical to suggest that through its acute influence on various aspects of cognitive function, such as attention, this could translate into better performance in academic tests, although we are not aware of data showing this.

Regular physical activity also has a positive relationship with academic and cognitive outcomes [11,12,13,14]. Randomized controlled trials have found increased attentional inhibition and cognitive flexibility with improvements in fitness in children [15]. Improved executive function and mathematics achievement that show a dose–response relationship with exercise training [16] have also been demonstrated. However, as with breakfast, there are immediate benefits of exercise on cognition not resulting from changes in fitness. Speed of processing, response accuracy, concentration and improvements in mathematical computation can all improve after acute bouts of exercise; although the optimal type, amount, and frequency of exercise need better clarification [11,12,13,14]. One important note is that most studies on the relationship of physical activity with academic performance and cognitive outcomes are in younger children aged 6–13 years. A paucity of rigorous randomized designs in adolescents (aged 14–18 years) led the 2018 Physical Activity Guidelines Advisory Committee in the US [17] to conclude that there was insufficient evidence available to provide even a limited grade for the effect of physical activity on cognition in adolescents. A subsequent follow-up review in 2019 found “limited but promising evidence” for positive effects of physical activity on cognition in adolescents [13]. For academic outcomes, one recent meta-analysis found a positive effect (Cohen’s d = 0.37) of physical activity based on 10 studies [18]. For cognition, several systematic reviews have generally found a positive relationship with physical activity in adolescents but with some heterogeneity in the findings [19,20,21,22,23]. Thus, further research in this age group is justified.

One interesting observation in adolescents relates to acute coordinative exercise, which emphasizes the ability to balance, react, adjust and to differentiate within a short time. A study in German adolescents found that only 10 min of this type of exercise led to improvements in attention and concentration on a paper and pencil letter cancellation test compared with those who completed moderate intensity exercise without any specific coordinative request [24]. Potentially, coordinative exercise may activate parts of the cerebellum and areas of the prefrontal lobe related to mathematics processing and reading comprehension to a greater extent than other types of exercise [24]. Further substantiation of the benefits of this type of exercise on cognition in adolescents is required.

Although both breakfast and exercise independently improve cognitive function, we are aware of only one study examining how they interact in children [25]. In that investigation, 42 early adolescents (12.4 (0.4) years), were randomized to receive either a high or low GI breakfast and then complete two trials in a random order which involved either a morning of rest or exercise taken 1 h after breakfast. Cognitive tests 30 min before and 90 min after exercise showed that the low GI breakfast and exercise were individually beneficial for improving response times on a test of working memory but conferred additive benefits on response times for a test of selective attention and inhibition. Conversely, for the high GI breakfast response times for selective attention and inhibition improved only under conditions of rest whereas exercise alone improved response times of working memory. This demonstrates the importance of elucidating the combined effects of breakfast and exercise on cognition. Further work needs to examine if this can result in improved academic as well as cognitive outcomes.

Thus, the present investigation examined the combined effects of exercise and breakfast intake on academic and cognitive outcomes over a morning in adolescents. We combined a low GI breakfast with a mixture of 30 min of aerobic and bilateral coordinative exercise. We hypothesized that adolescents in the combined exercise and breakfast intervention would show better outcomes than those who remained sedentary and fasted over a morning or adolescents given only exercise or breakfast.