Breakfast and Exercise Improve Academic and Cognitive Performance in Adolescents · Kawabata M, Lee K, Choo HC et al.

2. Materials and Methods

This study was conducted according to the guidelines laid down in The Code of Ethics of the World Medical Association in the Declaration of Helsinki 1964 and its subsequent amendments. All procedures involving human subjects were approved by Nanyang Technological University Institutional Review Board (IRB-2014-01-030). Adolescents were recruited from four local junior colleges and high schools with the consent of the Ministry of Education Singapore and the Principle of each institute. Written informed parental consent and adolescent assent was obtained from all subjects involved in the study before testing began. Inclusion criteria for the study were: (i) age: 14–19 years; (ii) body mass index normal for age and sex as defined by the Ministry of Health in Singapore [26]; (iii) no clinically diagnosed learning or attention disorders; (iv) no clinically diagnosed eating disorders; (v) free of diabetes mellitus; (vi) not partaking in any dietary restrictions for personal or religious beliefs (e.g., Ramadan); (vii) exercise training < 5 days per week for < 20 min each session (determined by self-report) and (viii) not color blind (one cognitive test used color coding).

2.2. Anthropometric and Preliminary Testing

Participants underwent anthropometric measures of stature, body mass and waist circumference. Stature was measured to the nearest 0.1 cm using an electronic wall-mounted stadiometer (Seca 242, Seca, Hamburg, Germany). Body mass was recorded to the nearest 0.1 kg using an electronic scale (Mettler-Toledo ID1 Plus, Mettler-Toledo S.E.A Pte Ltd., Singapore). Waist circumference was measured to the nearest 0.1 cm using a flexible measuring tape at the midpoint between the lowest rib and the iliac crest. Resting blood pressure and pulse rate were measured in duplicate using an automated sphygmomanometer (Omron IW2, Omron Healthcare, Kyoto, Japan). Following these measures, all individuals completed a preliminary 20 m multi-stage shuttle run test to assess cardiorespiratory fitness [27]. Heart rate was recorded continuously throughout the tests and used to predict peak oxygen uptake from standardized regression equations [27] and to determine running speed for the subsequent main trials.

2.3. Main Trials

Participants were randomized to one of four groups for the main trials: (i) a group who were fasted and sedentary all morning (F-S); (ii) a group who ate breakfast but were sedentary all morning (B-S); (iii) a group who fasted all morning but completed a 30 min exercise bout (F-E); and (iv) a group who ate breakfast and completed a 30 min exercise bout (B-E). Participants were transported to the laboratory by 08:30 a.m. by car, taxi or public transport having not eaten food or consumed any liquids other than water ad libitum since 23:00 p.m. the previous evening.

Upon arrival in the laboratory, participants sat in a chair for 10 min before a fingertip blood sample was taken for a baseline measure of blood glucose. Ten minutes later, participants were provided a series of baseline academic and cognitive tests (test-series1). Motivation was assessed before (pre-test1) the tests and hunger, satiety, fullness and appetite, arousal, and feeling before and after (pre-test2) the test-series in the same order. Mental effort was assessed immediately after the test-series (pre-test2). The entire set of procedures took ~30 min to complete. At 09:30 a.m., participants in the F-E and B-E groups performed a single 30 min bout of exercise consisting of treadmill running and bilateral coordinative ball exercises. Participants in the F-S and B-S groups engaged in quiet activities during this time (allowed to use computers/phones, work or read but were not allowed to engage in gaming activities). At 10:00 a.m., participants in the B-S and B-E groups were given a standardized breakfast to consume within 15 min while those in the F-S and F-E groups rested. A second battery of cognitive tests only (test-series2) was provided at 10:20 a.m. with the same set of subjective measures given for test-series1 provided (post-test1) and after (post-test2). Participants then remained seated engaging in quiet activities for a further 60 min. A final battery of academic and cognitive tests (test-series3) was then provided to participants along with the same subjective measures before (post-test3) and after (post-test4). Immediately after these final measures, a second fingertip blood sample for the measurement of blood glucose was taken. Participants were unable to eat anything all morning except for the breakfast provided but were allowed to drink water ad libitum. A schematic of the study design over the morning is provided in Figure 1.

2.4. Exercise

Participants in the two exercise trials, F-E and B-E, completed a 30 min bout of exercise between the first and second test-series. The exercise itself involved an 8 min run on a treadmill at a speed equivalent to 60% of peak oxygen uptake. Heart rate was recorded continuously during running and rating of perceived exertion (RPE) [28] at the end of the run. This was followed by 20 min of bilateral coordinative ball exercises adapted from a published protocol based on coordinative training forms for soccer and exercises from the Munich Fitness Test [24]. These exercises stressed different bilateral coordinative abilities within a short amount of time and were organized into five stations with participants completing two rounds of 90 s work at each station and 30 s rest between stations.

At station 1, participants bounced a basketball alternating with the left or right hand while standing on two wobble boards. For station 2, the task was to bounce a basketball and volleyball with the left and the right hands simultaneously. The balls were swapped between hands midway through each 90 s bout. At station 3, the task was to throw a handball alternating with the left and right hand into a gymnastic hoop held at waist level by an experimenter at a distance of 5 m for girls and 8 m for boys. In station 4, participants faced an experimenter, who served as a partner, at a distance of 5 m, one with a handball and one with a volleyball. Balls were thrown between partners for catching at the same time alternating with the left and right hands. At station 5, participants faced a partner at a distance of 5 m, one holding a volleyball in their hands and the other with a soccer ball at their feet. The balls were passed between partners simultaneously alternating hands/feet with each pass.

2.5. Breakfast

The breakfast provided to participants in the B-S and B-E groups employed common foods which were easy to consume by local children and adolescents. It consisted of a sandwich made from two slices of Gardenia Nutri multi-grain bread (estimated GI = 62) and 20 g of Nutella Ferrero hazelnut spread with cocoa (GI = 33), and a 200 mL packet of Nestlé Milo (GI = 35)—a chocolate malt powder drink popular in South-East Asia [29]. The breakfast provided 382 kcal (1.6 MJ) of energy and had 52.7 g of carbohydrate, 12.4 g of fat and 14.3 g of protein. The total meal GI was calculated based on an established formula [30]. The GI of each individual food was multiplied by the grams of available carbohydrate in the food, the total summed for all three foods in the meal and then divided by the total available carbohydrate in the meal. The calculated total meal GI was 46.

2.6. Blood Glucose

Blood glucose was measured from fingertip blood samples at the start (08:40 a.m., pre-test1) and end of the morning (12:30 p.m., post-test4). At both time points, a 30 μL sample of whole blood was collected into a capillary micro-tube. Samples were immediately dispensed onto a reagent strip and inserted into a dry-chemistry analyzer (Reflotron Plus, Roche Diagnostics, Mannheim, Germany). The analyzer was cleaned and calibrated according to the manufacturer’s specifications (Reflotron Clean & Check, Roche Diagnostics, Mannheim, Germany) and accuracy and precision was monitored using quality control sera (Reflotron Precinorm U Control, Roche Diagnostics, Mannheim, Germany).

2.7. Academic Tests

Academic performance was assessed with the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test, Third Edition (WIAT-III) [31] at the first and final test-series of the morning. The WIAT-III is a comprehensive, self-administered achievement test designed for children and adolescents. Subtests of the WIAT-III were used to determine mathematic and oral word fluency under time-limited conditions of 60 s. For mathematic fluency, participants were given 60 questions to complete which assessed the speed and accuracy of simple addition, subtraction, and multiplication calculations. They were instructed to answer as many questions as possible in the time provided. The total number of correct questions answered (score) and the number of correct questions answered each second (speed/computational time) was calculated. For oral word fluency, participants completed tests that measured the efficiency of their word retrieval to a given category, with 60 s provided for recall for each category. Participants were encouraged to provide as many words as possible. Proper nouns were excluded and the total number of words provided and time taken per word retrieval calculated. For both mathematic and oral word fluency, two versions of each test were provided to participants in a random manner at the start and end of the morning.

2.8. Cognitive Tests

Three tests to measure different aspects of cognitive function were provided using Inquisit software (Millisecond Software 2014, Inquisit 4, Seattle, WA, USA) in the same order at each test-series assessment point over the morning. Selective attention and inhibition were assessed using the Stroop Color-Word Test. In this computer test, cognitive interference was enhanced by asking participants to identify the color of ink in which a color name was written and to disregard the color name itself. The test consisted of three different conditions: (i) congruent trials; (ii) incongruent trials; and (iii) control trials [32]. The Digit-Span Test was employed as a working memory task in which participants read a series of single digits and were asked to repeat those digits in either a forward or backward sequence [33]. The number of digits committed to memory increased with the length of the test. Once a participant was unable to repeat back the digits at a given difficulty level on two occasions, the task was terminated. Attention was assessed using the Go/No-Go Task [34]. During this task green and black rectangles were presented on a computer screen as a continuous stimulus with participants having to react and perform a binary decision for each stimulus with a green rectangle requiring a motor response (Go) and presentation of a black rectangle requiring participants to withhold their response (No-Go). Accuracy and reaction time were measured for each event.

2.9. Hunger, Satiety, Fullness and Appetite

Hunger, satiety, fullness and appetite were measured by participants marking 100 mm visual analogue scales for each variable [35]. These measures were made before and after each academic and cognitive test-series.

2.10. Motivation, Arousal, Feeling and Mental Effort

A participant’s motivation was measured before each test-series and evaluated using a 10-point single-item scale ranging from 1 (“not interested at all”) to 10 (“very interested”). Before and after each test-series arousal and feeling were measured by the Felt Arousal Scale [36] and a Feeling Scale [37], respectively. The Felt Arousal Scale is a 6-point single-item scale ranging from 1 (“low arousal”) to 6 (“high arousal”). The Feeling Scale is an 11-point bipolar scale of pleasure and displeasure that ranges from −5 (“very bad”) to +5 (“very good”). Immediately after each test-series, the associated mental effort was measured using the Rating Scale for Mental Effort [38]. Participants were instructed to rate the level of psychological effort using a scale ranging from 0 to 150, with increments of 10 shown on the left edge of the scale and nine category anchors on the right edge of the scale. These include “no effort at all” (at 3 on the scale), “a fair amount of effort” (at 58 on the scale), and “extreme effort” (at 114 on the scale).

2.11. Statistical Analysis

An independent t-test was used to examine differences in heart rate and RPE during exercise. For blood glucose, and the cognitive, academic and subjective data over the morning, linear mixed modelling was conducted with hierarchical linear and nonlinear modelling (HLM) software (Version 7.01) [39] based on full maximum likelihood estimation. Linear mixed modeling was employed due to the hierarchical structure of the data. That is, each time measurement of a variable (Level 1) was nested within each individual (Level 2). To check if linear mixed modeling was suitable for the present data, an intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was calculated for each of the outcome variables based on an unconditional model in which no predictors were included. After confirming the suitability of multilevel modeling as a method of analysis for the current data, linear mixed modeling was conducted on each of the outcome variables (blood glucose, academic tests, cognitive tests, subjective rating variables). For the variables which were measured more than twice, time and time2 were entered as within-individual (Level 1) predictors in the model. The combined intervention (B-E) was used as a reference group and compared with the control group (F-S) and the two individual interventions (B-S and F-E). This was in order to examine the improvements brought about by the combined intervention over the other interventions. When time, time2 and group were entered into the equation, they were dummy coded (time: 0–2; time2: 0–4; group: B-E = 0, F-S = 1, B-S = 1, F-E = 1) and therefore they were not centered. To statistically control the effect of psychological variables on the outcome variables of academic and cognitive tests, feeling and motivation scores were centered and included into the model as between-individual (Level 2) predictors. For all analyses, significance was set as p < 0.05.