Collaborative Retrieval Practice Reduces Mind-Wandering During Learning · Knopps AG, Wissman KT

Introduction

A typical college student is expected to learn (and remember) a lot of information, which inevitably requires paying attention on behalf of the student. Of course, a student cannot be expected to pay attention all the time. Mind-wandering is a phenomenon described as a shift of attention away from an intended or primary task (for a seminal review, Smallwood & Schooler, 2006; also see, Pachai et al., 2016; Randall et al., 2014) and is a commonly occurring experience (Kane et al., 2017; Killingsworth & Gilbert, 2010; Seli et al., 2018; Smith et al. 2018). Although mind-wandering can be beneficial in some situations (e.g., for creativity, Baird et al., 2012), a majority of research indicates negative consequences of mind-wandering (for cognitive functioning, Cheyne et al., 2006; for reading comprehension, Unsworth & McMillan, 2013; for memory retrieval, Martin et al., 2018). As such, one way to support student learning is finding ways to reduce the frequency of mind-wandering. The current research investigates a novel technique that may reduce the likelihood of mind-wandering during learning: collaborative retrieval practice.

Mind-wandering is a common experience, with research estimating that individuals mind-wander between 30% and 50% on any given day (Killingsworth & Gilbert, 2010). Astoundingly, research conducted in authentic classroom settings suggests that students may be distracted every 5–6 min (Judd & Kennedy, 2011; Rosen et al., 2013). Given the frequency at which students tend to mind-wander, research has investigated how mind-wandering impacts the recall and memory of information (Risko et al., 2012; Wammes et al., 2016). Unfortunately, research has found that mind-wandering can negatively impact understanding of to-be-learned information (Unsworth & McMillan, 2013; for a review, Szpunar, Moulton, & Schacter, 2013). As such, research has started examining different techniques that can be used to reduce the likelihood of mind-wandering (for testing during encoding, Szpunar, Khan, & Schacter, 2013; for retrieval practice, Peterson & Wissman, 2020; for interleaving, Eglington & Kang, 2017; for spaced practice, Metcalfe & Xu, 2016). For example, Peterson and Wissman (2020) explored how mind-wandering rates were impacted when participants engaged in retrieval practice versus restudy. Across two experiments, participants were asked to learn categorical word lists. Critically, after encoding, participants engaged in either retrieval practice or restudy to further learn the word lists. Of interest for current purposes, during this review phase, all participants responded to four mind-wandering probes. Following review, all participants completed a final recall test. In both experiments, the results showed that participants reported significantly less mind-wandering in the retrieval practice group compared to the restudy group, providing evidence that (individual) retrieval practice testing reduces the frequency of mind-wandering during learning.

Although research has shown individual retrieval practice can reduce mind-wandering during learning, it is an open question as to whether collaborative retrieval practice will have the same effect. Exploring how collaborative retrieval practice impacts mind-wandering rates has important implications for applied purposes. Indeed, across many academic content domains, students are often required to learn in collaborative environments. Research indicates that faculty increasingly incorporate collaborative learning into their classrooms (National Research Council (U.S.), 2012), with outcomes suggesting that working in small groups is beneficial (for an overview, Slavin, 2012; for a meta-analysis, Kyndt et al., 2013) while also providing the opportunity for building connection amongst peers (Kuh, 2001; Summers et al., 2005). Of course, the term “collaboration” can be operationalized in various ways. For example, research has examined the effects of collaborative encoding (Barber et al., 2010), collaborative learning activities (for recall, Harris et al., 2008; for think–pair–share, Deshpande et al., 2020; for jigsaw groups, Button et al., 2021), and collaborative exams (LoGiudice et al., 2023). Survey research has also revealed that learners report studying in groups (Geller et al., 2018; Hartwig & Dunlosky, 2012) and that they specifically use retrieval practice as a learning technique in these collaborative settings (Wissman & Rawson, 2016). The current research involves collaboration during learning, with a focus on the use of collaborative retrieval practice.

In a typical collaborative learning design, participants are first asked to individually study some type of to-be-learned material. Participants then engage in retrieval practice, which often involves more than one recall trial and occurs either individually or collaboratively. After some delay, participants complete an individual, final test. The two most common findings are that recall during retrieval practice is lower for participants working in a group versus alone (collaborative inhibition; Basden et al., 1997; Weldon & Bellinger, 1997), whereas recall on the final test is greater for participants who previously worked in a group versus alone (postcollaborative benefits; Blumen & Rajaram, 2008; Wissman & Rawson, 2015). The finding that collaborative retrieval practice can enhance subsequent, individual memory suggests this is an effective study technique for students to use. More generally, research indicates that faculty and students use collaboration in educational settings and that collaborative retrieval practice can have a positive impact on memory; another unexplored benefit of collaborative retrieval practice is it may help students stay on task.

Existing theoretical accounts from mind-wandering research suggest this technique may reduce mind-wandering rates even further (for an overview of theories, see Pachai et al., 2016). For example, the executive failure hypothesis (McVay & Kane, 2009, 2012; Smallwood, 2013) posits that individuals have a limited number of cognitive resources, so to focus on the primary task, the executive control system attempts to reduce both internal and external distractions; according to this account, mind-wandering occurs when the system fails to inhibit internal distractions. When working in a collaborative setting, one must not only focus on the primary task but also work to coordinate cognitive efforts with social efforts (Grau & Whitebread, 2012), which presumably requires more executive control (as compared to working alone, as would occur with individual retrieval practice). Furthermore, research has shown that when more executive resources are required to maintain focus, the less likely one is to mind-wander (Hawkins et al., 2022; Kane et al., 2017; McVay & Kane, 2009). Another reason collaborative retrieval practice may reduce the frequency of mind-wandering concerns motivation. Research has shown that individuals report greater engagement and motivation when working in a group (Seli et al., 2019) and that higher levels of motivation reduce mind-wandering rates (Kang & Pashler, 2014; Seli et al., 2019). Thus, increased motivation would also suggest the frequency of mind-wandering may be lower when engaging in collaborative versus individual retrieval practice.

The goal of the current research was to evaluate how collaborative retrieval practice impacts the frequency of mind-wandering during learning. Learners were asked to study a list of words and then engage in collaborative or individual retrieval practice. All learners responded to eight mind-wandering probes during retrieval practice by providing self-reports of whether they were on or off task. Following retrieval practice, all learners completed an individual final recall test. Based on prior research and theoretical accounts, we predicted that mind-wandering would be lower for learners engaging in collaborative versus individual retrieval practice.