Discussion
The current study investigated how engaging in collaborative retrieval practice impacts the frequency of mind-wandering. Outcomes provide the first demonstration that collaborative (compared to individual) retrieval practice significantly reduced the frequency of mind-wandering during learning. Replicating prior collaborative memory research, outcomes also showed a cost of collaboration during practice (i.e., collaborative inhibition), but a benefit to later individual memory (i.e., postcollaborative benefits). The current outcomes suggest an additional, and novel, benefit to using collaborative retrieval practice as a learning technique – it helps reduce mind-wandering.
Why might collaborative retrieval practice reduce the frequency of mind-wandering? As briefly discussed earlier, the executive failure hypothesis suggests mind-wandering occurs when the control system fails to inhibit internal distractions (McVay & Kane, 2009), and we posited that coordinating recall efforts with another individual during retrieval practice may help reduce the likelihood of such internal distractions. Complementary to this account is research showing that mind-wandering requires executive resources, and when these resources are utilized elsewhere (for example, in a collaborative context), mind-wandering rates decrease (Smallwood, 2010). If working collaboratively is a more demanding task that requires more effort and executive control on the part of each individual, this may in turn help decrease the likelihood of internal distractions. Further research that systematically examines underlying mechanisms that contribute to reductions in mind-wandering rates in collaborative settings is an important direction for future research.
In the current research, time on task during learning was equated to ensure that all participants responded to the same number of mind-wandering probes at the same time. An interesting direction for future research would be to explore the efficiency of working collaboratively versus individually, and how this may impact mind-wandering rates. For example, initial research suggests it takes longer to achieve similar levels of performance when engaging collaborative versus individual retrieval practice (Wissman & Rawson, 2018, Experiments 2 and 3). In terms of mind-wandering, off-task thinking may become more likely as time elapses if working alone is simply more efficient.3 To explore this, participants could engage in self-paced (collaborative vs. individual) retrieval practice during which they respond to self-caught mind-wandering probes. Although beyond the scope of the current study, exploring the relationship between collaborative versus individual retrieval practice and the frequency of mind-wandering from an efficiency standpoint would be informative.
The finding that collaborative retrieval practice reduces mind-wandering has promising implications for educational purposes. An important next step will be to investigate this effect in more authentic, learning contexts (for example, inside the classroom or out-of-class group study sessions). Indeed, in more real-world settings, there will be an increased likelihood of other external distractions, such as noisy classrooms and electronic devices. In addition, in real-world collaborative settings, learners are more likely to know one another as opposed to being strangers (as was the case with the current study). Interestingly, previous research has shown that collaborative inhibition is attenuated when groups comprise friends (Andersson, 2001; Andersson & Rönnberg, 1995, 1996). One possibility is the likelihood of mind-wandering during collaboration may also be affected by group composition. Investigating how collaborative retrieval practice impacts the likelihood of mind-wandering in more authentic, educational settings is another fruitful avenue for future research.
Although not of primary interest, it is worth highlighting that recall outcomes replicate prior collaborative memory research such that collaborative inhibition was observed during practice and postcollaborative benefits were observed on the final test. The latter is particularly important, as most studies have focused on investigating collaborative inhibition with far fewer studies focusing on postcollaborative benefit, which is arguably the more important effect from an applied standpoint as learning and retention are ultimately assessed at the individual level. One interesting idea is to examine if reductions in mind-wandering rates during learning have downstream effects. For example, one could include mind-wandering probes during the final test to determine the extent to which collaborative retrieval practice impacts the likelihood of mind-wandering on later individual tests.
The current study provides novel outcomes to the literature by showing that engaging in collaborative versus individual retrieval practice significantly reduces the likelihood of mind-wandering during learning. Given the importance of replicating novel findings (e.g., Camerer & Wu, 2018; Pashler & Harris, 2012; Roediger et al., 2012; Simons, 2014), future work should replicate and further evaluate the effects observed here, as understanding when and why collaborative retrieval practice decreases mind-wandering rates will have important implications for supporting student learning. Importantly, the current research provides foundational outcomes as a basis for further investigation of how collaborative retrieval practice impacts the frequency of mind-wandering during learning.
CC BY 4.0. "Collaborative Retrieval Practice Reduces Mind-Wandering During Learning" by Knopps AG, Wissman KT, Experimental psychology (2023). https://doi.org/10.1027/1618-3169/a000589. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC10929687). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.