Financial Literacy and Gambling Behaviour: A Systematic Review · O'Connor F, Ivory N

Introduction

Gambling is a popular recreational activity for many the world over. While most do so without experiencing problems, for others, gambling can turn into a problematic behaviour with serious consequences. Gambling behaviour becomes problematic when it is characterised by persistent and compulsive gambling that persists despite detrimental effects (Jazaeri & Bin Habil, 2012). Individuals struggling with their gambling behaviour may have a desire to stop but be preoccupied by thoughts and urges to gamble (Jazaeri & Bin Habil, 2012).

Problem Gambling has been defined as “gambling behaviour that creates negative consequences for the gambler, others in his or her social network, or for the community” (Ferris & Wynne, 2001, p. 8). It is a broad umbrella term that encompasses both gambling disorder, defined as “persistent and recurrent problematic gambling behaviour leading to clinically significant impairment or distress” (DSM-5-TR, American Psychiatric Association, 2022), and non-clinical individuals affected by gambling problems (Gainsbury et al., 2014). When gambling behaviour becomes excessive, it can lead to high levels of debt and financial strain (e.g., Marionneau et al., 2023). Higher levels of financial literacy have been shown to be associated with reduced financial stress (Steen & MacKenzie, 2013), and therefore may offer protective benefits against financial strains associated with excessive gambling behaviour.

Gambling behaviour has been shown to be consistently and significantly related to financial motives (e.g., Tabri et al., 2022; Maclaren et al., 2015). A study of self-generated reasons for gambling found that 46% of the respondents identified financial motives, or gambling motivated by the desire to win money, as the primary reason for gambling (McGrath et al., 2010). Given that people with higher financial literacy are more likely to understand that gambling is not a financially profitable activity due to the extremely low odds of winning, a reasonable argument is that increased levels of financial literacy could lower levels of financially motivated gambling.

Financial literacy is generally understood to reflect the “knowledge and understanding of financial concepts and risks, and the skills, motivation and confidence to apply such knowledge and understanding in order to make effective decisions across a range of financial contexts” (OECD, 2014, p. 33). However, how best to measure financial literacy is challenging as there is no widely agreed upon definition (Huston, 2010). Most research on financial literacy adopts an objective approach, seeking to measure people’s financial knowledge or understanding (Allgood & Walstad, 2015). In research adopting this approach, financial Literacy is often measured by three questions, known as the Big 3, designed to target understanding of inflation, compound interest, and diversification respectively (Lusardi & Mitchell, 2007). For example, the first question states “Suppose you had $100 in a savings account and the interest rate was 2% per year. After 5 years, how much do you think you would have in the account if you left the money to grow?” Respondents are required to select the correct answer from a selection of possible answers. The Big 5, an extension of the Big 3, is another popular measure which includes the original three questions plus two additional items; one on bond prices and another on mortgages (Hastings et al., 2013). For both measures, a total financial Literacy score is calculated by summing the number of questions answered correctly. The Big 3 and the Big 5 were designed to be a brief and simple approximation of financial literacy. However, the brevity of these scales may present some issues, as financial literacy can arguably be considered a broad concept that is unlikely to be captured fully by just three or five items. In order to address this, some researchers have developed more detailed measures (e.g., Amonhaemanon, 2022; 2023; Cho, 2022). However, this has created marked variability in how financial literacy has been defined and measured across studies.

One dimension along which approaches to measuring financial literacy vary is the distinction between subjective self-assessments and more objective measures. Subjective financial literacy is a self-report perception or evaluation of one’s own financial skills, while objective measures involve an external assessment or knowledge test of a person’s actual understanding of financial concepts. While subjective perceptions or confidence in financial knowledge and objective measures of financial literacy are likely to be positively correlated, they represent distinct constructs that are unlikely to always align perfectly. For example, it is possible for individuals to exhibit varying combinations of the two, such as high subjective confidence paired with low factual knowledge, or conversely low subjective confidence paired with high factual knowledge.

Consequently, studies have measured financial literacy in different ways, some focusing on subjective perceptions or confidence in financial knowledge (e.g., Allgood & Walstad, 2015), while others relying upon objective tests of actual financial Literacy such as the Big 3 (e.g., Becchetti et al., 2018). An even smaller number of studies have chosen a more indirect approach, measuring financial behaviours presumed to reflect levels of financial literacy, such as paying bills on time or being aware of how much savings one has (e.g., Shin et al., 2015). Even in the more objective approaches, which measure financial literacy knowledge, the number of items can vary from two (Razen et al., 2021), to as many as 20 (Wang et al., 2023), creating variability across studies in terms of the breadth of the construct that is being captured. The lack of an agreed definition and approach to measuring financial literacy has been argued to inhibit the ability to make more meaningful comparisons across studies (Huston, 2010). Particularly when comparing the financial literacy of different countries, where inconsistencies across studies make it difficult to discern what is a meaningful cultural difference and what reflects measurement variability.

Despite these challenges, global survey data suggests generally low levels of financial literacy worldwide (e.g. Klapper et al., 2015; OECD, 2016). For example, using consistent measures, the OECD (2016) reported low financial Literacy among adults across 30 countries. However, financial literacy rates also appear to vary somewhat across countries. For example, Klapper et al. (2015) found relatively low rates of financial literacy in South Asian countries (25% or less), compared to countries Like Australia, Canada, and the United Kingdom, where rates were around 65%.

As the financial world continues to grow in complexity, the importance of financial literacy in navigating daily financial decisions is similarly increasing (Allgood & Walstad, 2015). Indeed, evidence indicates that financial literacy is associated with improved financial wellbeing (Zhang & Chatterjee, 2023). Financially literate individuals are more likely to plan for retirement (Lusardi & Mitchell, 2007) and accumulate more wealth than people lower in financial literacy (Behrman et al., 2012). Low levels of financial literacy have been associated with ineffective spending, poor debt management, and poor financial planning (Lusardi, 2019), which can be costly in both the short and long-term (Allgood & Walstad, 2015). While there is a significant and growing body of evidence to support the importance of the relationship between financial literacy and financial behaviours, research examining the relationship between gambling and financial literacy is still in its infancy.

In comparison to other financial behaviours, the relationship between gambling and financial literacy is likely to be particularly nuanced or complex, as gambling might not always be considered a financial behaviour. That is, while gambling has been linked to financial or winning motivations (Francis et al., 2015; Wardell et al., 2015), and for these individuals, increasing financial literacy may offer protective effects against problem gambling as a financial behaviour. Many individuals gamble for other reasons, such as for social reasons, for entertainment, for distraction from negative emotions, or enhancement of positive emotions, and it is possible that increased financial literacy may not have a protective effect against excessive gambling in these cases, where gambling for these individuals might not be considered a financial behaviour. Therefore, it is important to examine the evidence linking financial literacy to gambling behaviour as well as the interactions between financial literacy and the motivations underlying the gambling behaviour.

Thus, the purpose of the current review is to present the state of research on the relationship between financial literacy and gambling. The research question explored in this review is whether financial literacy offers a protective benefit against problematic gambling. Financial literacy has only relatively recently emerged as a research topic of interest, but is recognised as an increasingly important competency, given the ubiquity of participation in financial decision making in the modern world. Similarly, problem gambling has seen a surge in research since its inclusion as a recognised disorder within the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5; American Psychiatric Association, 2013). Therefore, while research addressing both topics are still somewhat in their infancy, it is arguably timely to explore this emerging research now to identify strengths and gaps in the knowledge base, as well as to support standardisation of research methodologies.