Financial Literacy and Gambling Behaviour: A Systematic Review · O'Connor F, Ivory N

Discussion

To the authors knowledge, this is the first systematic review to summarise the body of literature examining the association between financial literacy and gambling behaviour. The results of this review suggest that higher levels of financial literacy may be associated with lower frequency of gambling and to a much lesser extent, lower likelihood of gambling-related problems. However, these conclusions are based on a very limited number of studies, most of which did not measure gambling problems per se. Thus, we recommend that these conclusions and interpretations are accepted with some caution.

All but one of the studies found a negative relationship between financial literacy and gambling, with the findings suggesting that gamblers tend to have lower levels of financial literacy on average compared to non-gamblers (Becchetti et al., 2018; Wang et al., 2023) or that higher levels of financial literacy are associated with lower frequency of gambling (e.g., Cho, 2022; Watanapongvanich et al., 2021). This is consistent with research that suggests increased financial literacy has a positive effect on financial decision-making and behaviours (e.g., Lusardi, 2019; Lusardi & Mitchell, 2009; Lusardi & Tufano, 2015). However, one study in this review identified financial literacy as a positive predictor of problem gambling (Grable et al., 2021). Specifically, they found subjective perceptions of financial knowledge positively predicted the likelihood of engaging in a risky gambling behaviour, that is, betting a day’s income at the casino. Notably, only one other study in this review measured problem gambling, as opposed to gambling frequency (Wang et al., 2023), however that study found negative associations between financial literacy and problem gambling, consistent with the majority of other studies in this review. The limited number of studies focusing on problem gambling rather than gambling frequency challenges the robustness of the evidence for financial literacy as a protective factor against problematic gambling. Most of the existing research has centered on gambling frequency, which may not fully capture the severity or harms associated with gambling behaviours. Consequently, while financial literacy appears to show protective effects against gambling frequency, its role in mitigating problem gambling remains less well understood.

There are several possible explanations for the positive association found between financial literacy and problem gambling by Grable et al. (2021). Firstly, financial literacy may be negatively associated with gambling frequency but positively associated with problematic gambling. While these findings may seem contradictory, they could suggest that the association between financial literacy and gambling behaviour varies based on the severity of the gambling behaviour. For example, once gambling reaches problematic or pathological levels, rational thought (i.e. greater financial literacy) may no longer be helpful in reducing it, an argument previously expressed by others (Watanapongvanich et al., 2022; Cho, 2022). Secondly, high levels of financial literacy may lead to overconfidence in financial decision-making capacity which could impair decision-making in a way that leads to taking greater financial risks in people who gamble at problematic or pathological levels. Thirdly, subjective evaluations of financial knowledge may not correlate well with objective measures of financial literacy. That is, while high confidence in financial literacy was found to positively correlate with problem gambling, the actual or objective financial literacy of these participants was not measured and is not known. Their subjective evaluations may have represented an inaccurate or overestimate of their actual financial literacy levels. While these possibilities may explain this discrepant finding, given this discussion is based around a single study that found contradictory results, it is important not to place too much weight on this single finding. It is also possible that the positive association is simply an outlier result. Replication studies are needed to better understand how financial literacy may be associated with problem gambling versus frequency of gambling. Future research should strive to include both frequency-based and problem-focused measures to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the potential protective role of financial literacy.

Cultural differences across the studies may also help explain the current findings. Research shows there are cultural differences in rates of gambling (e.g., Raylu & Oei, 2004) and there is evidence that the gambling patterns of populations are shaped by cultural and historical contexts as well as variations in regulatory policies between countries (e.g., Kairouz et al., 2016). As such, it is possible that the relationship between financial literacy and gambling may be different in countries where gambling is more readily accepted, widely available, and legal, such as the United States and Australia, versus countries which have stricter laws and/or largely prohibit gambling, such as China. For example, increasing financial literacy in cultures with generally positive attitudes towards gambling and easy accessibility to gambling venues may not reduce frequency of gambling. Due to wide social acceptance of gambling in these cultures, motivations for gambling may often be for entertainment reasons rather than financial reasons. In contrast, increasing financial literacy may offer greater protective effects against gambling behaviour in countries where gambling is more widely perceived as a negative financial behaviour and is less socially accepted. Further research is needed which explores the interplay among social attitudes towards the acceptability of gambling, availability of gambling, motives for gambling and financial literacy, to further explicate these ideas. While the studies included in this review originate from five different countries, there are too few studies in the current review to engage in any meaningful discussion of the role that culture may play in the associations between financial literacy and gambling behaviours, however the potential impact of cultural differences in gambling behaviours is important to be acknowledged and explored in future studies.

Cultural and regulatory differences also appear to influence how various forms of gambling, such as lottery participation, are perceived and studied across countries. We noted that several studies considered lottery purchases as their sole form of gambling behaviour (e.g., Amonhaemanon , 2022, 2023; Cho 2022). This finding stood out to the current researchers, as lottery ticket purchasing in Australia, where the authors are located, is typically regarded as a low-risk form of gambling (Armstrong & Caroll, 2017). In Australia, lottery gambling is rarely associated with problems and is seldom the primary focus of research given the ubiquity of the behaviour and its non-significant relationship with problem gambling (Browne et al., 2023). Lottery gambling is considered a low-risk form of gambling primarily because it lacks a continuous-play format. Continuous-play gambling, such as Electronic Gaming Machines (EGMs) or pokie machines, is characterised by a high play-rate and minimal delay between the bet and outcome. This gambling format has been shown to affect brain structures in ways that perpetuate compulsive gambling (Murch & Clark, 2016).

The delayed outcome of a lottery ticket purchase is unlikely to perpetuate compulsive gambling in this way. Thus, it is possible that by only capturing lottery purchases and not other forms of gambling, a number of the studies included in this review may not be capturing the most problematic forms of gambling. Notably, cultural differences might mean that lottery ticket purchases have stronger associations with gambling problems in some countries. However, given the delay of a lottery ticket outcome versus continuous play format games, it is unlikely that the comparison between these two gambling behaviours could be considered completely equal. Increasing financial literacy could be more likely to impact a pre-meditated behaviour such as lottery ticket purchases (Amonhaemanon, 2022, 2023; Cho 2022), than a compulsive and inherently addictive behaviour such as EGM use or online gambling (Grable et al., 2021; Watanapongvanich et al., 2021). These are interesting questions for future research to explore.

Limitations

A potential limitation of the current research is the lack of demographic information, some studies did not explicitly report their participant’s basic demographics such as age or sex (e.g., Amonhaemanon, 2022, 2023; Becchetti et al., 2018). The lack of demographic information may negatively affect replicability of the findings. Notably, survey research demonstrates significant differences between men and women’s financial Literacy levels, with 63% of men and 48% of women demonstrating an understanding of the three basic financial literacy concepts (Preston, 2020). Similarly, age may also impact financial literacy, with younger and older people having the lowest levels of financial literacy, with the highest levels occurring during mid-life (Preston, 2020). Younger people have also been shown to have higher rates of problem gambling than older adults (Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, 2023). Considering these known demographic differences, understanding the sample characteristics of the included studies has important implications. However, it should be noted that many of the samples of the included studies were very large which reduces concerns about generalisability.

Unclear or incomplete reporting was a common theme throughout the included studies. For example, it was not always clearly reported how many items were used to measure financial literacy within the studies. As an example, Amonhaemanon (2022) reported that they adapted their measure of financial literacy on the basis of previous work (specifically Lusardi, 2012; Lusardi & Mitchell, 2007; and Bank of Thailand, 2016 as cited in Amonhaemanon, 2022). The exact number of items in the final measure was never clearly reported, with the authors only stating that their measure of financial literacy “addressed seven topics” (Amonhaemanon, 2022, p. 637). This may mean they employed seven items, however the exact number of items nor the possible range of scores on this variable were not reported. This made it challenging to identify if financial literacy in their sample was high or low and how levels of financial literacy in their sample compared to other studies. The heterogeneity in measurement across studies, combined with opaque reporting at times, made drawing comparisons across the studies challenging. This body of literature as a whole would benefit from clearer, more complete, and more transparent reporting of methods.

Additionally, the way in which gambling frequency was defined in some studies could have been stronger. For example, Watanapongvanich et al. (2021) coded their continuous gambling frequency variable into a binary variable: non problem and problem gamblers. Their non-problem gambling group included participants who did not gamble at all with those who gambled once a month or so (and those in between). This grouping is likely too broad, and may have confounded their results, given people who abstain from gambling have been found to be a distinct group from non-problem gamblers in previous research (Ferris & Wynne, 2001).

Of the nine studies, only two specifically sought to capture whether the gambling was problematic (Wang et al., 2023; Grable et al., 2021), with the other studies instead observing gambling frequency. This limits the generalisability of the findings to problem gambling, given gambling frequency and gambling problems are arguably distinct constructs which may relate differently to financial literacy. Given individuals’ varying budgets, differing spend per play, and emotional states or outcomes when gambling, it is reasonable to argue that gambling frequency alone does not adequately capture problematic gambling behaviour. Furthermore, many of the included studies used only a single item to measure gambling frequency, which may not be comprehensive. Thus, there is a need for research in this area to employ measures with a greater range of questions to better capture the nuanced aspects of gambling behaviour and in particular, gambling problems. The Problem Gambling Severity Index (PGSI; Ferris & Wynne, 2001) and South Oaks Gambling Screen (Lesieur & Blume, 1987) are both reliable and valid tools that are used widely in psychological research and would serve as effective and consistent measures for advancing research exploring the association between financial literacy and gambling behaviours. The use of clinician diagnosis for gambling disorder, in addition to these self-report measures, may also be ideal when research budgets permit.

Areas for Future Research

Further study could explore how financial literacy and gambling motives may interact in the prediction of problem gambling. Independent research has shown financial motives are positively associated with gambling frequency and levels of gambling problems (e.g., see Tabri et al., 2022 for a meta-analysis). Lower levels of financial literacy may be associated with greater endorsement of financial motives for gambling, which may then explain the pathway between low financial literacy and increased gambling. Financial stress may also interact with financial motives and financial literacy to explain gambling behaviours.

Another important consideration for future research is how to measure the construct of financial literacy. While most of the included studies based their questions on Lusardi and Mitchell’s ‘Big 3’ or ‘Big 5’ (Lusardi, 2019), Grable et al. (2021) used a subjective measure to ask participants how financially literate they believed they were. Participants’ confidence in their financial literacy compared to their financial understanding has been shown to differ (Kiliyanni & Sivaraman, 2016), and thus it is important that research seeks to understand both objective and subjective financial literacy and their relationship with gambling behaviour. For example, it is likely that someone with low financial literacy but high confidence in their financial abilities may be most at risk of problem gambling, as they may be less likely to accept advice, seek help for their behaviour, or be receptive to education efforts. While the ‘Big 3’ have been found to be a consistent and useful measure for understanding financial literacy, it is also unlikely that such a short measure is able to accurately capture this broad construct. From a psychometric perspective, a factor with three items may not be particularly stable. A minimum of five items per factor has been recommended (Costello et al., 2005). Given the three questions are argued to measure three unique facets of financial literacy, a stronger scale psychometrically would include at least five items per facet. Therefore, it is promising to see Wang et al. (2023) utilise a more in-depth measure of the financial literacy construct. It may be beneficial for future research to employ this scale in different populations beyond China to further explore utility across diverse samples and cultural contexts.

Practical Applications

If increased financial literacy does negatively correlate with problematic gambling behaviour, this could guide intervention efforts by focusing on financial literacy education. Indeed, the positive impacts of increased financial literacy in reducing gambling behaviour were demonstrated in a South African study that embedded financial lessons into a nationally televised soap opera (Berg & Zia, 2017). Berg and Zia (2017) found that participants who watched the soap opera with embedded financial literacy content demonstrated improvement in their financial behaviours, including reductions in household gambling. They also found viewers scored significantly higher on financial knowledge following viewing the show. Novel research such as this demonstrates that there may be benefits of financial literacy education as an intervention for problem gambling at a population level.