Fluoride in Dental Caries Prevention and Treatment: Mechanisms, Clinical Evidence, and Public Health Perspectives · Yeh CH, Wang YL, Vo TTT et al.

3. Clinical Evidence and Efficacy of Fluoride Interventions

Substantial clinical evidence confirms the caries-preventive effectiveness of topical fluoride measures. Meta-analyses indicate that toothpaste containing ≥1000 ppm fluoride reduces caries incidence by approximately 23% in children and adolescents compared with non-fluoridated toothpaste, with additional benefits observed at higher concentrations, particularly in high-risk populations [5,13]. However, heterogeneity across trials, including variations in outcome measures, study duration, and patient compliance, makes it difficult to establish precise dose–response relationships. A Cochrane review reported that professionally applied fluoride varnish can reduce caries incidence by 37% in primary dentition and by 43% in permanent dentition when applied two to four times annually [41]. Despite these promising results, questions remain about the optimal frequency and long-term sustainability of these effects in real-world clinical settings. Another Cochrane review demonstrated that fluoride mouthrinses reduce caries incidence by about 27% in the permanent teeth of children and adolescents, confirming their value as an adjunctive preventive strategy [22]. Yet, adherence to regular rinsing regimens is often suboptimal, especially among younger children, which may reduce effectiveness outside of controlled trial conditions. Furthermore, a systematic review and meta-analysis has shown that SDF is highly effective in arresting dentine caries in primary teeth, offering a valuable treatment option for pediatric populations [27]. Nevertheless, evidence in permanent dentition and adult populations is comparatively limited, and concerns about esthetic staining continue to affect broader acceptance. Taken together, evidence from multiple Cochrane reviews and systematic analyses consistently demonstrates that topical fluoride interventions, including toothpaste, varnishes, mouthrinses, and SDF, play a central role in effective caries prevention across diverse patient groups. Still, most available evidence comes from studies in children and adolescents, with fewer robust data for older adults, medically compromised patients, or populations in low-resource settings. The summarized efficacy of these fluoride interventions across different studies is presented in Table 2. Future research should therefore aim to address these gaps through multicenter trials that include diverse populations, standardized outcome measures, and patient-reported outcomes.

3.2. Comparative Efficacy: SDF vs. Other Interventions

Clinical trials and systematic reviews have established SDF as a highly effective agent for arresting active carious lesions, particularly in populations with limited access to restorative dental care. A systematic review by Gao et al. found that 38% SDF achieved caries arrest in approximately 81% of treated lesions in primary teeth, a notably higher efficacy than that typically observed with sodium fluoride varnishes under similar conditions [25]. Nevertheless, differences in study design, lesion activity assessment, and follow-up duration complicate direct comparisons between interventions. Randomized controlled trials have also demonstrated that SDF yields significantly higher caries-arrest rates than NaF varnish in moderate-to-deep dentinal lesions, although esthetic concerns related to black staining remain a limitation [26]. This drawback has been shown to significantly influence parental acceptance, with uptake varying across cultural and socioeconomic contexts. Furthermore, a meta-analysis by Chibinski et al. reported pooled caries-arrest rates of around 66% for SDF over follow-up periods of up to 12 months [27]. Longer-term evidence beyond two years, however, is limited, leaving uncertainty about the durability of caries arrest with repeated applications. These data emphasize that while both SDF and traditional fluoride varnishes are effective, SDF may offer superior efficacy in managing established carious lesions, particularly in high-risk populations. However, in community-based programs, the esthetic drawback of black staining may reduce parental acceptance and influence broader adoption, whereas in clinical settings SDF is often more readily accepted due to its proven efficacy and simplicity of application. Thus, the balance between clinical efficacy and esthetic acceptability remains a critical consideration in determining the broader adoption of SDF. Future studies should therefore include patient-reported outcomes and cost-effectiveness analyses to clarify contexts in which SDF provides the greatest benefits relative to traditional varnishes.

3.3. Efficacy in High-Risk Populations

Specific populations derive significant benefits from fluoride interventions. Older adults, for example, are particularly susceptible to root caries due to factors such as gingival recession and xerostomia. Evidence indicates that biannual applications of fluoride varnish or daily use of high-fluoride toothpaste can arrest or reverse the progression of root carious lesions [42]. Still, much of this evidence comes from relatively small cohorts, and the generalizability to diverse older populations with multiple comorbidities remains uncertain. In patients undergoing orthodontic treatment, fluoride interventions such as varnishes and high-fluoride toothpastes have been shown to effectively reduce the occurrence of white spot lesions associated with fixed appliances. Yet, compliance with fluoride regimens during orthodontic treatment is highly variable, which may diminish effectiveness outside of controlled trial conditions. Reviews have reported significant reductions in enamel demineralization when fluoride products are integrated into orthodontic care protocols [45]. Among individuals with special healthcare needs, including young children with early childhood caries (ECC) or patients who are unable to tolerate conventional restorative procedures, SDF serves as a valuable non-invasive alternative. Studies have demonstrated high rates of caries arrest with SDF, even in community-based settings [25]. Nevertheless, the absence of standardized protocols for reapplication and the lack of long-term follow-up data represent important research gaps.

3.4. Uncertainties and Future Research Directions

Despite extensive evidence supporting fluoride’s effectiveness in preventing dental caries, certain areas remain under investigation. Materials such as fluoride-containing bioactive glasses have demonstrated the ability to promote remineralization and reduce dentinal hypersensitivity in laboratory studies, but clinical data confirming clear advantages over conventional fluoride therapies are still limited [3]. Moreover, most available evidence is derived from in vitro or short-term trials, raising concerns about their translational value to routine dental practice. In addition, esthetic concerns associated with SDF, particularly the black staining of treated lesions, continue to pose challenges for broader acceptance, especially in anterior teeth. Acceptance is also influenced by cultural and socioeconomic factors, suggesting that esthetic concerns cannot be addressed solely through material modification but must also involve patient-centered counseling strategies. Research is ongoing to develop modified formulations or complementary treatments to mitigate these esthetic issues, although robust clinical trials are still needed to validate such approaches. At present, small pilot studies provide promising but inconclusive results, and there is a clear need for multicenter randomized controlled trials with standardized outcome measures. Future research should focus on long-term clinical studies to determine whether such emerging materials and technologies provide significant benefits beyond those achieved with established fluoride interventions. In particular, comparative effectiveness research is essential to clarify whether new technologies add meaningful clinical value or simply duplicate the effects of traditional fluoride modalities at higher costs. Improving patient compliance and addressing socioeconomic barriers also remain important goals to enhance the effectiveness of caries prevention strategies in diverse populations [3]. Addressing these socioeconomic barriers also requires policy-level interventions, including subsidy programs, public health education, and strategies to ensure equitable access to preventive care.