Fluoride in Dental Caries Prevention and Treatment: Mechanisms, Clinical Evidence, and Public Health Perspectives · Yeh CH, Wang YL, Vo TTT et al.

6. Health Risks, Controversies, and Public Health Perspectives

Despite fluoride’s proven efficacy in caries prevention, concerns persist regarding potential adverse health effects arising from excessive intake. Dental fluorosis is the most commonly observed consequence, resulting from excessive fluoride ingestion during enamel formation. It manifests as subsurface hypomineralization, producing white opacities, mottling, and, in severe cases, brown staining and enamel pitting. Data from the U.S. National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) 1999–2004 indicated that approximately 23% of adolescents exhibited some degree of dental fluorosis, with about 2% showing moderate fluorosis and fewer than 1% showing severe forms, underscoring the cumulative exposure from multiple fluoride sources such as drinking water, toothpaste ingestion, and dietary supplements [63]. Importantly, the clinical significance of mild fluorosis remains debated, with some viewing it as primarily cosmetic while others note possible psychosocial consequences. Skeletal fluorosis is another documented health concern, primarily observed in regions where drinking-water fluoride levels substantially exceed recommended standards. Chronic ingestion of fluoride at concentrations typically above 3–6 mg/L can result in increased bone density, joint pain, stiffness, and, in advanced stages, skeletal deformities and disability. Endemic skeletal fluorosis remains a significant public health issue in regions such as India and China, where high fluoride levels in drinking water have led to widespread cases [64]. However, the condition is exceedingly rare in areas where drinking-water fluoride concentrations remain below 1.5 mg/L, the guideline established by the World Health Organization [64]. Emerging research has also investigated potential neurodevelopmental impacts of fluoride exposure. A widely cited meta-analysis by Choi et al. analyzed 27 epidemiological studies and reported an association between higher fluoride exposure and lower intelligence quotient (IQ) scores among children living in areas with naturally high fluoride concentrations [8]. A longitudinal cohort study in Mexico found that higher prenatal fluoride exposure was associated with lower cognitive outcomes in children aged 4 to 12 years [65]. However, most of these studies relied on ecological designs with limited control for confounders, making it difficult to infer causality at fluoridation levels used in public health programs. It is noteworthy that most studies suggesting neurotoxicity were conducted in regions with fluoride levels substantially exceeding those used in regulated water fluoridation programs. Potential effects of fluoride on endocrine function, including thyroid health, have been explored in the scientific literature. Some research has suggested associations between elevated fluoride intake and alterations in thyroid hormone levels, particularly in populations with insufficient iodine intake. However, evidence remains limited and inconclusive, and further research is needed to determine whether fluoride exposure at levels used in public health interventions has significant endocrine impacts [9].

6.2. Controversies and Ethical Considerations

Fluoride’s public health application, especially through community water fluoridation (CWF), has generated ethical debates and public opposition in certain regions. Proponents of CWF emphasize its substantial benefits in reducing caries prevalence and improving oral health equity, particularly in lower-income populations who may lack access to dental care or fluoride-containing products [43]. Conversely, critics raise concerns regarding individual autonomy, arguing that mass-fluoridation programs impose treatment without explicit consent, thereby conflicting with the ethical principle of informed choice [66]. This reflects the broader ethical tension in preventive medicine between maximizing collective benefits and preserving individual autonomy. Numerous cost–benefit analyses support the economic advantages of CWF, noting significant savings in dental treatment costs attributable to reduced caries incidence [67]. The Nuffield Council on Bioethics concluded that decisions regarding water fluoridation should be determined through local democratic processes, balancing public health benefits against individual rights and preferences [68]. In addition to water fluoridation, salt fluoridation has been introduced as an alternative mass-fluoridation strategy in countries such as Switzerland, Mexico, and Costa Rica. While widely regarded as effective and cost-efficient, salt fluoridation raises similar ethical debates concerning informed consent, population-wide exposure, and the challenge of tailoring fluoride intake to individual needs. Proponents argue that salt fluoridation is particularly valuable in countries with fragmented water supply systems, whereas critics note that it may disproportionately affect individuals with dietary restrictions or those at higher risk of overexposure [20,44]. The scientific debate is further complicated by methodological challenges in fluoride research. Critics argue that earlier studies supporting community fluoridation may suffer from confounding factors, while studies indicating harm are often criticized for poor study design, inadequate exposure assessment, and failure to account for confounders such as socioeconomic status or co-exposures [9]. This polarization complicates policymaking, as governments must act despite incomplete evidence while also addressing strong public skepticism amplified through advocacy and media. This scientific polarization contributes to persistent public skepticism and hinders clear communication regarding fluoride’s risks and benefits.

6.3. Global Public Health Perspectives

Global perspectives on fluoride utilization exhibit considerable variation due to differences in cultural attitudes, regulatory frameworks, and local geological conditions. In the United States, a substantial proportion of the population receives fluoridated water, with the U.S. Public Health Service recommending a fluoride concentration of 0.7 mg/L to achieve an optimal balance between caries prevention and the risk of dental fluorosis [43,69]. In contrast, numerous European countries have opted against widespread implementation of CWF, instead favoring targeted interventions such as salt fluoridation, milk fluoridation, or topical fluoride applications. Countries including Germany, Sweden, and Switzerland have discontinued water fluoridation programs, citing ethical considerations, low prevalence of dental caries, and public opposition [20]. Case studies provide critical insights into the public health implications of policy shifts regarding fluoridation. For example, the discontinuation of CWF in Calgary, Canada, in 2011 was followed by an observed increase in the prevalence of dental caries among children [70]. This increase, combined with substantial debate and new epidemiological findings, ultimately prompted the reinstatement of fluoridation in 2021. This case illustrates how policy reversals create natural experiments but also highlights the difficulty of disentangling fluoridation effects from broader social and behavioral determinants of oral health. Conversely, in regions affected by endemic fluorosis, national programs prioritize defluoridation technologies and alternative fluoride delivery methods to mitigate excessive exposure while preserving the preventive benefits against dental caries [64,71]. Contemporary policy challenges encompass the accurate assessment of cumulative fluoride exposure from diverse sources and the necessity for individualized risk evaluation, particularly in vulnerable populations. Advances in biomarker research, including the analysis of fluoride concentrations in biological matrices such as nails and urine, offer potential for more precise exposure assessment and could inform personalized public health recommendations [72]. Yet, standardization of biomarker use and validation across diverse populations remain major challenges before they can guide policy. Furthermore, there is growing scientific interest in alternative caries-preventive strategies, such as the use of probiotics. However, current evidence for these approaches remains limited compared with the robust body of evidence supporting the established role of fluoride in public health interventions [73]. In summary, while fluoride continues to be recognized as an essential element in the prevention of dental caries, the ongoing evaluation of its benefits relative to potential risks remains a subject of scientific discourse and public deliberation. Future research and policy initiatives must endeavor to refine exposure guidelines, ensure transparent and effective communication, and respect community values to optimize the public health benefits of fluoride while safeguarding individual health.