1. Introduction
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by the presence of persistent difficulties in communication and social interaction in several contexts, as well as the presence of restrictive and repetitive patterns of behavior, interests, or activities [1]. In addition to these core aspects of ASD, people with this diagnosis usually have other comorbid difficulties that are highly significant in their daily quality of life [2].
One of these common comorbidities consists of learning difficulties in reading comprehension [3,4], probably one of the most relevant academic skills learned in the school context. In fact, reading comprehension in the initial stages of schooling is a good predictor of later academic success and even variables related to behavioral adjustment [5,6,7].
Theoretically, reading comprehension is a complex task that basically requires two phases: the decoding of the graphemes and the extraction of linguistic meanings [8]. Many studies show that people with ASD have difficulties with understanding texts, taking into account their reading decoding ability [9].
In addition, reading comprehension is conditioned by pragmatic characteristics and language comprehension, such as understanding metaphors, jokes, and ironies, making inferences, understanding idioms, or understanding meanings whose interpretation depends on the context. These issues are challenging for students with ASD, even for those with preserved linguistic and cognitive abilities, as in Asperger Syndrome (AS) (level 1 ASD, according to the DSM-5 criteria) [10].
Due to the great heterogeneity in the presentation of the clinical forms of autism, the possible comorbid difficulties, or the age of onset of the first signs and their evolution [11,12], the reading comprehension difficulties can vary in their severity and intensity in students with ASD [13]. Some possible explanations for these difficulties in reading comprehension are the classic theoretical explanations for ASD [14]. For instance, the theory of weak central coherence [15] states that people with ASD have difficulties integrating elements they perceive in isolation into a whole, an essential skill for construction meaning in reading comprehension; the theory of executive dysfunction [16] explains some of the characteristics of ASD based on difficulties in processes such as inhibition, working memory, or planning, key processes in reading comprehension; also, the theory of mind [17] explains some of the difficulties people with ASD have in attributing intentions or mental states in others, a key skill for understanding narrative texts.
Given the reading comprehension difficulties of children with ASD, and considering the relevance of this learning, a large amount of research has been carried out in recent years to evaluate the efficacy of interventions designed to improve reading comprehension in these children.
In this line, a review study of 11 intervention studies published between 1986 and 2006 included seven studies focused on the teaching of vocabulary and four studies aimed at improving text comprehension processes [18]. Another review study [19], which included 11 interventions published between 2000 and 2011 focused on evaluating the effectiveness of computer-assisted interventions. The results of this study showed that computer use can provide effective support for improving reading comprehension in children with ASD through interventions based on solution strategies and making questions related to the comprehension, identification of the structure of the text, and cooperative learning.
A review study that analyzed a total of 12 intervention studies published between 1980 and 2012 [14] found that providing strategies from a cognitive approach, the use of group methodologies, and direct instruction are useful proposals for improving the reading comprehension of students with ASD. Specifically, three of the studies included in this review found that peer tutoring shows benefits in reading comprehension, as well as in social and emotional development. The authors concluded that the implementation of these strategies can be quite beneficial, not only for children with ASD, but also for all students, especially those who present reading and learning difficulties.
Finally, in a review analyzing 15 reading comprehension interventions in students with ASD published between 1989 and 2015 [20], researchers found that only four of the interventions were potentially highly effective, whereas four other interventions obtained an acceptable-high improvement. These interventions agreed on the need to use cooperative learning and graphic organizers, and that it is not advisable to use electronic supports without supervision and it is preferable to design personalized interventions. Additionally, this review also showed that the skills learned in the interventions are transferable to texts that students with ASD face for the first time.
Considering the literature described above, the aim of the present systematic review is to analyze the effectiveness of reading comprehension interventions in students with ASD, considering studies published between 2000 and 2019. Specifically, we aim to answer the following research questions:
1. What results did the educational interventions to improve reading comprehension in children with ASD published between 2010 and 2019 obtain? 2. Which reading sub-processes have these studies focused on? And 3. What are the main characteristics of the interventions regarding methodologies, duration, implementing agents, and context of intervention?
This review expands and updates the previous conclusions of other literature reviews: it covers an updated period of time and includes empirical work carried out to evaluate the effectiveness of any type of reading comprehension intervention (not specific ones). This objective is relevant because it can help to determine which intervention strategies have been effective to improve reading abilities in students with ASD, and so it can help to guide current and future interventions.
CC BY 4.0. "Interventions for Improving Reading Comprehension in Children with ASD: A Systematic Review" by Tárraga-Mínguez R, Gómez-Marí I, Sanz-Cervera P, Behavioral sciences (Basel, Switzerland) (2020). https://doi.org/10.3390/bs11010003. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC7824210). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.