Interventions for Improving Reading Comprehension in Children with ASD: A Systematic Review · Tárraga-Mínguez R, Gómez-Marí I, Sanz-Cervera P

4. Discussion

In the present study, we have carried out an updated systematic review of empirical studies that analyzed the effectiveness of interventions in different sub-processes of reading comprehension in children with ASD. Specifically, the study raises three research questions.

The first one refers to what results have been obtained by the reviewed research. The main conclusion is that almost all the interventions analyzed produced positive results in the reading comprehension skills of students with ASD. Only one of the 25 studies reviewed did not show significant improvements [22]. This result shows that, when specific interventions are carried out, students with ASD are able to take advantage of the instruction they receive and compensate for difficulties. This result leads to the conclusion that teachers and other practitioners should be encouraged to continue to focus and increase efforts in teaching reading comprehension skills in children with ASD. As shown in this review, these efforts can produce positive short-term results in reading comprehension.

Regarding this, it should be taken into account that advances in reading comprehension were moderated by language skills in some studies. For this reason, language ability became a powerful predictor of reading comprehension [32,33,37,38].

The second research question aims to determine which reading sub-processes have the reviewed studies focused on. Reading comprehension is a complex process involving several sub-processes: vocabulary and syntactic structure knowledge, making inferences, and integration of simple ideas into macro ideas, among others [46]. The results of this review show that understanding inferences and understanding the main idea of the text were the most common reading comprehension sub-processes included in the reviewed interventions. Understanding the main idea of a text is a key point, according to the theory of weak central coherence, which explains that people with ASD have difficulties integrating the elements they perceive in isolation into a whole [10]. Despite these initial difficulties, the present review shows that, if specific strategies are explicitly taught and opportunities for practice are provided, students with ASD are able to extract the main idea from the texts they read.

The third research question refers to several characteristics of the interventions, such as methodologies, duration, implementing agents, and context of intervention.

The results show that a large number of studies used direct instruction, some of them as the only technique [27,30,31,32,33,40,41] and others as a part of the intervention [26]. Direct instruction consists of a teaching approach based on breaking down tasks into sequences of more concrete steps with the aim that students acquire the different skills worked in sequence. It is an approach that emphasizes the structuring of the teaching processes through scripts that guide the teaching process. The results of this review confirm that, according to previous reviews [14,20], this is a positive methodology for teaching school content to children with ASD, considering that these children need individualized attention, and that this systematic methodology is particularly well adapted to the order and structuring needs of students with ASD.

Nevertheless, direct instruction should not be considered as the only option to teach reading comprehension to students with ASD. Collaborative, guided, and shared reading have also been shown as effective methodologies [21,35,36,39,43,44]. These techniques have the value of treating reading as a shared act, highlighting the social value of reading, which can be especially positive for children with ASD. Therefore, given that both direct instruction and shared reading have shown good results, it seems appropriate for practitioners to take both methodological approaches into account when designing educational interventions with their students with ASD, considering the characteristics and particular needs of these students.

Regarding the duration of the interventions, the results show great heterogeneity between the different studies, finding durations from just one session to more than 30. This variety in the length of the interventions is due to the different scope of the objectives of each investigation, as well as the age, skills and previous knowledge of the participants. Reading comprehension training is a process whose results depend to a large extent on reading practice and experience. Therefore, one of the most relevant aspects that we must take into account when designing educational interventions is its ability to be implemented in real contexts. These interventions should have a duration to be feasible over time, considering issues such as the motivation of the students and the availability of time and personal resources to carry them out in natural contexts, either by teachers at school or by families in the home.

If we analyze the ecological validity of the research included in this review, regarding the implementer, the number of interventions carried out by teachers is low (only 7 of the analyzed studies). However, reading comprehension is one of the main forms of learning that take place in school (in fact, it is an instrumental learning, which serves as a base tool for later learning). So, it is necessary to design educational interventions that, once shown to be effective in the field of research, could be applied in schools with the usual resources in this context. To transfer the results of the research to the school environment, it is important to consider: the skills and teachers’ resources, the ratio of students per classroom, and the possibility of implementing interventions following the schools’ schedules.

Some studies have taken these aspects into account, since the interventions have been carried out in school contexts by the teachers (not by researchers) throughout all the research process or at least in a generalization phase [22,25,27,30,43,45]. These investigations provide added value to the field, since they furnish greater confidence about the ecological validity of the results obtained.

Nonetheless, there is a large amount of research that has been conducted in different settings other than the school context. In these cases, these educational interventions have demonstrated its effectiveness in improving the reading comprehension of children with ASD under controlled conditions. However, we cannot reliably affirm that teachers in the typical conditions of their classrooms can apply these same intervention procedures carried out in control conditions.

In fact, we found two studies in this review that have used the same intervention procedures (based on ABRA, a free computer-assisted literacy program) in two different contexts. In a first study [23], ABRA intervention was conducted by a researcher on a 1:1 basis in participants’ homes, obtaining good results also in reading fluency as in reading comprehension. In a later study [22], ABRA was conducted by teachers at school in a more naturalistic context, obtaining also good results in reading fluency, but not in reading comprehension. The possibility of comparing these two studies, which apply the same intervention in two different settings, obtaining different results, gives us the opportunity to reflect on the importance of designing interventions that can be put into practice in the usual school conditions.

In addition to the necessary school and teacher involvement, reading is an activity that can be carried out at home as a dyadic activity with families. Reading at home with parents can have benefits not only in improving reading skills, but also in improving joint attention and certain aspects related to communication and social interaction [47,48]. For this reason, in addition to designing interventions to carry out in the school context, future research should design interventions that can be implemented in the home context.

Finally, regarding students’ motivation towards reading, this research has shown that some tools and strategies used to carry out interventions are interesting and could be attractive to children with ASD. That is the case of ICT support [21], the ABRA computer assisted intervention [22,23], and the inclusion of content according to the students’ interests [19], among other initiatives. Additionally, it is important to consider the use of maps and graphic organizers as tools to enhance the comprehension of text information. In fact, in the articles reviewed that used these aids [26,27,35,45], and according to a previous review study [20], the results were highly effective and the improvements in reading comprehension were more noteworthy, compared to studies that did not use visual aids.

4.1. Limitations of the Study

Conclusions about the effectiveness of the interventions analyzed in the present review should be viewed with caution because they could be influenced by publication bias. The 25 studies included in this review have been published. Nevertheless, this review does not include any unpublished studies. Because interventions that do not obtain good results usually remain unpublished, not including any of these studies could skew the conclusions about the effectiveness of these interventions.

In addition, reading comprehension is a complex task that includes a large variety of cognitive and meta-cognitive sub-processes. Some of the studies included in this review did not specify which sub-processes were addressed in their interventions, and most of the studies in which the sub-processes were specified included many different types of activities. Therefore, it is difficult to determine what specific types of interventions are more effective. Future studies should analyze the effectiveness of the interventions while considering the sub-processes that were worked on in each case in greater depth.

4.2. Future Research

Future lines of inquiry should carry out research to identify which specific aspects cause the greatest difficulties for children with ASD, and continue to investigate specific aspects of ICT that can contribute to improving the reading comprehension of children with ASD. These interventions should be implemented by teachers in their ordinary school environment in order to be considered valid.