Mentalization and dissociation after adverse childhood experiences · Wagner-Skacel J, Riedl D, Kampling H et al.

Introduction

Dissociation is a mental process which allows an individual to tolerate distressed events by splitting off highly incoherent or overwhelming thoughts, memories and feelings1. A disruption is a disconnection in the integration of consciousness, memory, identity, emotion, perception, body representation, motor control and behavior. It affects all areas of personality functioning and of the integration of self2. The dissociative process could be understood as a primary response to stress related with morphological alterations in the brain and is linked with enhanced amygdala response to emotional cues and cognitive control2,3. There is considerable evidence regarding the relationship between childhood abuse or neglect and dissociation symptoms in adulthood4 with in an earlier age of onset, as well as a longer duration of abuse and parental abuse significantly predicted higher dissociation scores5. Chronic exposure to a stressful environment may lead to several alterations5. In line with psychodynamic theory, experiences of childhood trauma play a crucial role in the etiology of psychiatric disorders and hence show somatic diseases epigenetic modifications of the glucocorticoid receptor gene on the stress response in several studies with individuals with childhood abuse6. Childhood abuse is regarded as an event so intense that it is impossible for the victim to integrate this experience on a symbolic level and thus fosters a pathological active formation of impaired personality functioning and affective forces6.

Thus, it is reasonable that such adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) might hinder the development of good mentalizing abilities. Mentalizing is defined as the process by which we make sense of each other and ourselves with forming beliefs about mental states of those with whom we interact and our own7.

Mentalization can be seen as an extension and complement to the theory of mind research and to other approaches of perspective shifting competency with a special consideration of the processing of biographically relevant relationship experiences. The clinical concept particularly focuses on the area of metacognitive access to one's own self-states, attachment representations and interactions in affective contexts8. Mentalizing as a key aspect of social cognition is a highly complex ability based on two types of explicit and implicit mentalization9. Implicit is characterized by fast and intuitive, pre-reflexive and non-verbal information process without awareness. The explicit form of mentalizing is relatively slow and relies on verbal and conscious information processing with cognitive skills9. In many previous studies the concept has been analyzed in relation to childhood trauma and dissociation. A significant interaction can be seen between adverse childhood experiences and attachment security with more post-traumatic stress disorder and trauma symptoms in those with insecure attachment representation10. Attachment style may play a role in precipitating and protecting against post-traumatic stress11. Trauma is theorized to activate the attachment system, so there is a reciprocal relationship between attachment and trauma.

Mentalization is a dynamic multifaceted ability that has particular salience in the context of attachment relationship12. Several studies documented trauma-induced neurobiological changes within the amygdala13, recognized as a primary locus of differentiated reactions to trauma and long-term socio-emotional consequences14. Neuroimaging studies show amygdala hyperactivity in individuals with acute trauma exposure heightened emotional response (e.g. hyperarousal, re-experiencing) and blunted emotional response (e.g. emotional numbing, dissociation) in cases of early and prolonged onset14.These blunted emotional responsiveness has been seen in mothers with unresolved trauma to infant distress15. Attachment trauma results in an increased amygdala response to salient stimuli16. For the child who is exposed to violence and abuse, there is hardly any opportunity to reflect on their own inner world as they are forced to concentrate exclusively on the external traumatic world17.

Emotional processes are linked to cognitive operations and reflective awareness with a language based broad spectrum of complex memory. Cognitive and executive functions are linked to mentalization identity narratives and mindfulness18. The relation of cognition and emotion with the underlying structure of personality might be important when considering personality functioning and vulnerability. Personality changes can lead to distinct impairments in self and interpersonal function19. Internalized early adverse experiences lead to corresponding inner working models that obstruct the functional regulation of dissociation. These mental processes might be modified in stressful circumstances and aggravate to difficulties.

It is reasonable to assume that the psychophysiological processes of mentalization may be involved in the dynamic of dissociation with its impact on imagination, our various verbal and conceptual information, as well as our interpersonal and subjective meaning made of perception. Individual differences in the mentalization process along with cognitive and emotional responses to dissociation and PTSD symptoms might be critical for both the construction of new management models as well as the development of novel treatment strategies. However, research in this field remains scarce. Thus, the aim of this study was to analyse the relationship between ACEs, mentalizing and dissociation in adult individuals (see Fig. 1). We hypothesized that participants with low mentalizing capacities may report more dissociation and emotional loading associated with psychological symptoms (anxiety, depression, somatization). Furthermore, we assume that mentalizing may be a mediator of the relationship between ACEs and dissociation in adulthood.