Mentalization and dissociation after adverse childhood experiences · Wagner-Skacel J, Riedl D, Kampling H et al.

Discussion

The aim of our study was to assess the relationship between ACEs, mentalizing and dissociation in adult individuals. In our sample, there was a clear association of ACEs with dissociative symptoms. However, the direct association of ACEs on dissociation was not longer statistically significant when mentalization was added to the model as a mediator of said relationship.

In accordance with previous literature, we found a significant association between dissociative symptoms and mentalization, which can be understood as a dysfunctional adaptation process to a traumatic environment26 with disruption of biobehavioral mechanism related to self and identity. Dysfunctional and maladaptive coping strategies influencing the stress response with so called stress depending changes from explicit to an implicit mentalizing process27. A stress dependent switching from explicit to implicit mentalizing comes to bear when coping strategies are no longer sufficient to regulate personal stress arousal in the interaction with the attachment system.

From the perspective of mentalization theory, the typical emotion regulation in patients with a borderline personality disorder is seen as an imperfect balance between the cognitive and affective poles as well as the explicit and implicit mentalization poles. An individuals’ on the effects of dysfunctional behavior on self and others is limited. In the case of interpersonal stress, it would be more functional if controlled and cognitive mentalizing (explicit) were available to the individuals. According to psychodynamic theory, a patient with a lower personality functioning based on maladaptive early attachment experiences shows symptom intensification and a lower therapy response28. A broad range of research show that ACEs can be considered as a transdiagnostic factor with implications in a variety of emotional and functional disorders and problems29. The impact of traumatic experience plays a key role in the regulation of distress based on the attachment system30 with subsequent problems in mentalizing. Social embedded stress response may enforce the pathway between dissociation and mentalization in patients with attachment insecurity. This theory is supported by a recent study, which showed that attachment insecurity in combination with lower mentalizing mediated the link between childhood trauma and PTSD symptoms in adults who had experienced childhood neglect and abuse31. Early maltreatment may increase the risk for the development of attachment insecurity with long-lasting effects. The development of mentalizing is thought to be fostered by secure attachment relationship with a process of contingent mirroring of child’s affects and subjective emotional experiences. This mental representation is important for strategies to regulate stress and to communicate with the self and the other32. Sharp et al. describe a social-cognitive model of PTSD and attachment insecurity with impaired mentalizing abilities mediating associations with dissociative experiences33. Dissociative mental representations engendered by childhood trauma could be understood as as a dysfunctional adaptive function to minimize the fear of shame and guilty. The mentalizing ability could lead to a damping of this social-cognitive model of PTSD and dissociative experiences. Social embedded mentalizing may influence important aspects of individual function.

Our data also demonstrate that lower mentalization was associated with higher depression, anxiety and somatization as well as PTSD symptoms (avoidance, hyperarousal, intrusions). Depression and depressive symptoms with impairments in interpersonally transmitted information may be highly linked to mentalizing abilities based on developmental aspects of attachment and social relationships. A few empirical studies reported associations linking change in interpersonal functioning and attachment security with change in depressive symptoms34. Relevant early developmental epigenetic modification of gene expression influences behavioral and emotional patterns in patients with depressive symptoms35. This biobehavioral mechanism involved in problems related to self and identity should be a part of social capacity treatments. Interpersonal therapy focusing on helping patients to create or renew social contacts and social support may benefit from better mentalizing36. Mentalization with its linkages to attachment theory offers possibilities for understanding the dynamics of depression regarding differences in severity and course of disease37. Functional domains, that are often impaired in patients with ACEs, include personality functioning, affective, cognitive and self-regulatory resources as well as the quality of the self-other representation36. These functional domains are important for the dynamic interplay of meaningful relationships.

Somatization refers to psychological stress caused by the perception of physical dysfunctions focusing on body symptoms with strong autonomous mediation38. Subjective perception, thoughts, emotions and behavior associated with the individual somatic status are sometimes clinically more important than a medical diagnosis39. The specific weight for the patients' perception is a body-related cognitive ability or competence, justified from a neuroscientific and a health science perspective. Interoceptive awareness and conscious body-related self -regulation seems to be a basic function, which may serve in patients with ACEs as an important homeo-static/allostatic control40. Subjective representations of illness determine the coping behaviors and consequently the illness outcome. Somatization thus may be viewed as a primary driver for higher perception, symptom reporting, health care use, symptom persistence, and negative treatment outcome41.

Internalized traumatic early experiences (as often the case when experiencing ACEs) may lead to corresponding working models and obstructions in the functional regulation of emotions with less flexibility and more adaptive personality patterns42. Overcontrol of emotions such as in the dissociative subtype of PTSD need effective treatments as fostering mentalizing with a top-down regulation43 and strengthening the individuals capacity to feel and to simultaneously reflect on his or her feelings.

Impaired mentalization in individuals with posttraumatic symptoms is associated with more psychological distress and higher symptom perception43. Similarly, individuals with ACEs and an insecure attachment style show more psychological stress and higher symptom load. The modulation of primary affective states into cognitive -affective key features is disrupted by attachment trauma with leading to impairments in the capacity for self-regulation and the capacity for accessing the adaptive functioning of the social imaginations in relation to the intersubjective self12. Understanding my inner world and the world of the other with mentalizing capacities can contribute to the understanding of psychological resilience.

We are essentially tied to who or what we consider ourselves to be. The images we make of our selves characterize who or what we are44.

The present study has several strengths and limitations. A major limitation is the limited sample size. Even though the sample size calculations indicated that the sample was sufficiently powered to detect medium effect sizes and results indicated positive findings, results should be interpreted with caution with regard to a possibly reduced variability of the scales’ scores. In addition, we did not assess attachment (insecurity) in our study. Given that previous research has shown the close association between ACEs, attachment and mentalization, attachment might be an important additional component in a mediation model addressing adult psychopathology. Future research should address the role of attachment in the interplay of childhood trauma, adult dissociation and mentalization as a mediator. To our knowledge, this is the first study to investigate the mediation effect of mentalization in the association between ACEs and dissociation, which is a major strength of this study. A second strength is the applied study methodology: in the present study carefully telephone-based structured interviews were conducted by highly trained specialists in psycho-traumatology. This approach was not only chosen to improve the quality of collected data, but also to guarantee safety of this highly vulnerable patient collective and to support affected persons if necessary.