Relationship between Duration of Fluoride Exposure in School-Based Fluoride Mouthrinsing and Effects on Prevention and Control of Dental Caries · Komiyama E, Kimoto K, Arakawa H

2. Subjects and Methods

Examinations were performed in the scheduled spring dental examinations, based on the School Health Law, for 1,005 first-year students in all seven municipal junior high schools. When children who were absent from school on the date of the examination and children who had transferred from other elementary schools were excluded, the S-FMR exposure group (F+ group) consisted of 599 children (boys 319, girls 280), and the group not exposed to S-FMR (F− group) consisted of 282 children (boys 147, girls 135). The F+ group had participated in S-FMR for six years in ten elementary schools, while the F− group had participated in S-FMR for less than one year in the sixth-year of nine elementary schools (S-FMR in three schools started from May or June, and S-FMR in six schools started from September or October). S-FMR in elementary school consisted of fluoride mouthrinse for 60 seconds once a week using 10 mL of 0.2% sodium fluoride solution, containing 900 ppm fluoride.

For the protection of privacy, compliance with the Personal Information Protection Law was assured, and survey forms for the subjects used random numbers to indicate gender and S-FMR experience (elementary school attended). The survey was performed in compliance with the Ethical Policies for Epidemiological Research of the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare and the Helsinki Declaration, and the results were computed based on relevant ethical considerations (Notification number 40 of the approval of the Ethics Committee of Kanagawa Dental College).

2.2. Examiners

The examiners were three dentists in the Division of Oral Health, Department of Health Science, Kanagawa Dental College. These three dentists had undergone adequate training for this examination and performed calibration before the date of examination. The agreement rate (κ value) for caries diagnosis among the examiners conducted several times using extracted teeth was not less than 0.8. Information on whether the subjects had participated in S-FMR was not given to the examiners.

2.3. Contents of Examination

The examination was performed based on tooth surface units using visual dental caries detection by WHO standards [19]. Dental caries examination standards used in this survey were based on the contents of examinations according to the School Health Law, and the examination details for each child were transferred to the student health records (dental/oral cavity) after examination. The contents of the examination used for analyses in this survey were as follows: (1) current permanent teeth; (2) dental caries: permanent teeth were examined for caries by tooth or tooth surface units; and (3) questionable caries under observation (CO), for example, white spot lesion, without dental caries lesion on visual. Examination was based on the Enforcement Regulations of the School Health Law of Japan (amended in 1995). In Japan, CO is diagnosed as a sound tooth, “0” under WHO code [19].

2.4. Method of Calculation and Account

Calculations and accounts for dental caries in evaluation of the effects of S-FMR were performed only on permanent teeth. Using the decayed-missing-filled (DMF) caries status, the DMF incidence, and mean DT-DS, MT-MS, FT-FS, DMFT, and DMFS (T: tooth; S: tooth surface) are shown for each subject. DMFT and DMFS were also calculated for specific dentition and groups of teeth. For CO teeth, the person rate of CO, mean CO number and percentage of CO teeth among total teeth, and mean CO tooth surface number and percentage of CO tooth surfaces among total tooth surfaces were calculated. As CO teeth are not considered to have dental caries, they were not included in the totals for untreated teeth or untreated tooth surfaces (DT, DS). The numbers of CO teeth or tooth surfaces were shown as percentages of the total number of teeth and total number of tooth surfaces as indices for assessing the effects of S-FMR. The caries reduction rate of S-FMR was calculated using the total values of the F+ and F− groups for the elementary school that the children attended. It was assumed that children showed no differences in dental caries in the permanent teeth at the time of entering each elementary school. Therefore, the results were obtained by compiling (1), (2), and (3) previously.

For the prefectural mean value in the targeted municipality, the status of 12 year olds (total number surveyed: 20,867 first-year junior high school students) in the 2006 prefectural survey on school health statistics was used as a reference. The prefectural mean estimate was 1.4 (1.3 for boys and 1.5 for girls). For the nationwide value, the status of 12 year olds (sampling survey: about 284,000 first-grade year junior high school students) in the 2006 National survey on school health statistics of the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology was used as a reference. According to this report, the number of untreated teeth was 0.60 (0.57 for boys and 0.63 for girls), the number of missing teeth was 0.03 (0.02 for boys and 0.03 for girls), the number of treated teeth was 1.08 (0.98 for boys and 1.18 for girls), and DNFT index was 1.71 (1.57 for boys and 1.85 for girls). However, as these values include cases treated due to causes other than dental caries (untreated teeth, treated teeth, and missing teeth due to traumatic injury, missing teeth due to orthodontics, etc.), the values are given as reference.

2.5. Statistical Analysis

Excel was used for calculations. Statistical analysis of the results was performed by chi-squared test and Wilcoxon's rank sum test.