Relationship between Duration of Fluoride Exposure in School-Based Fluoride Mouthrinsing and Effects on Prevention and Control of Dental Caries · Komiyama E, Kimoto K, Arakawa H

3. Results

Table 1 shows the prevalence of dental caries in permanent teeth in terms of teeth and tooth surfaces by gender for 12 year olds (first-year of junior high school) in the two groups. The person rate with DMF was 46.1% in the F+ group and 64.9% in the F− group, which represented a statistically significant difference (P < 0.05). Particularly in the F− group, the prevalence was significantly higher in girls (71.9%) than that in boys (58.5%) (P < 0.05). In the F+ group, a difference between boys and girls was not observed. The DMFT index was 1.28 in the F+ group and 2.02 in the F− group, and the DMFS index was 2.05 in the F+ group and 3.69 in the F− group. Values in the F− group were significantly higher (P < 0.05). No gender differences were seen in the F+ group. However, in the F− group, DT, FT, DS, and FS were clearly higher in girls. In particular, the person rate with DMF, DMFT index, and DMFS index in both boys, and girls decreased in S-FMR. Eruption of permanent teeth was earlier in girls than in boys and the preventive effects of S-FMR were greater in girls, with about one more erupted tooth. In comparison with the prefectural mean value of 1.4, the value in the F+ group was lower. In comparison with the nationwide value of 1.71, the value in the F+ group was lower, but the value in the F− group was higher. In particular, the DT in the F+ group was lower than the nationwide value of 1/7, which was a good result, but the FT tended to be slightly higher. The caries reduction rate of S-FMR in the permanent teeth showed lower values of 36.6% for DMFT and 42.8% for DMFS.

Table 2 shows the status of the teeth and tooth surface units by dentition of permanent teeth. For mean DMFT and DMFS by dentition of teeth, values were about the same in the F+ and F− groups for the premolars that erupted during the middle years of elementary school and the second molars that erupted from the sixth grade. However, in the first molars, central incisors, and lateral incisors that erupted before attending school or in the early grade years of elementary school, the values were significantly lower in the F+ group than those in the F− group (P < 0.05). No gender differences in dental caries were observed in the F+ group, and mean values of DT, FT, DS, and FS were clearly higher in girls in the F− group. The caries reduction rate in the F+ group showed a DMFT of 66.7% and DMFS of 64.5% for the central and lateral incisors. For first molars, DMFT was 35.1% and DMFS was 42.5%. Figure 1 shows the caries reduction rates for teeth with early eruption, and for premolars and second molars that were not markedly affected by fluoride mouth rinsing in elementary school, as the time of eruption was late. For teeth with late eruption, the value for the F+ group was slightly lower than that for the F− group, but the difference was not marked. However, in teeth with early eruption, high caries reduction rates of 35.1% to 66.7% were observed (P < 0.05). About 85% of caries in permanent teeth occurred in the first molars with no relation to participation in S-FMR.

Although not shown in the table, the effects of fluoride mouthrinsing on caries status in the first molars were examined. As no gender differences were seen in the F+ group, the totals for both genders were calculated. No differences between the right and left sides were seen, but the maxillary mean DMFT was 0.42 in the F+ group and 0.67 in the F− group, while the mandibular mean DMFT was 0.68 in the F+ group and 1.00 in the F− group. The maxillary mean DMFS was 0.69 in the F+ group and 1.32 in the F− group, and the mandibular mean DMFS was 1.14 in the F+ group and 1.86 in the F− group. However, no significant differences were observed between the prevalence of dental caries in the first molars in the maxilla and mandible. In the mean DMFS of the first molars, the percentages for tooth surfaces that experienced high levels of caries were 60.9% in the occlusal plane of the maxilla, 26.1% in the palatal plane, 57.9% in the occlusal plane of the mandible, and 29.8% in the buccal plane in the F+ group, as compared to 52.3% in the occlusal plane of the maxilla, 28.0% in the palatal plane, 53.8% in the occlusal plane of the mandible, and 25.8% in the buccal plane in the F− group.

3.2. Findings for CO

Findings for teeth and tooth surfaces of CO are shown in Table 3. The person rate with CO, mean CO number and CO teeth percentage per total teeth, and mean CO tooth surface number and CO tooth surface percentage per total tooth surfaces were significantly higher by 1.5-fold, 1.9-fold, 1.9-fold, 2.6-fold, and 2.7-fold, respectively, in the F− group than those in the F+ group (P < 0.001). For the CO teeth percentage per total teeth and CO tooth surface percentage per total tooth surfaces, the percentages with findings were 1.9-fold and 2.7-fold higher, respectively, in the F− group than in the F+ group. Similarly to caries prevalence, mean CO number and CO teeth percentage per total teeth and mean CO tooth surface number and CO tooth surface percentage per total tooth surfaces showed no gender differences in the F+ group.

Therefore, for an investigation of future directions in aftercare and dental health guidance, the relative frequency in the CO tooth number and CO tooth surface number in subjects with CO teeth are shown in Figures 2 and 3. No CO gender differences were noted under S-FMR management, but there were high-risk students with numerous CO teeth or CO tooth surfaces. For high-risk students, the same cumulative curves were seen for both CO teeth and CO tooth surfaces.