Systemic Multimorbidity Clusters in People with Periodontitis · Larvin H, Kang J, Aggarwal VR et al.

Results

A total of 6,542 participants were eligible for inclusion across 3 NHANES cycles (2009 to 2014; Appendix Fig. 1). After age and sex matching across the CAL quartiles, 3,736 participants were in the hypergraph analysis. The average age of participants in the matched study cohort was 58.16 y (SD: 13.22), and there were 2,156 (57.7%) females. The proportion with a history of smoking was higher in the highest CAL quartile (55.8%) than in the lowest (40.7%). The most prevalent diseases in the overall study population were arthritis (47.6%), hypertension (63.9%), and obesity (45.9%; Table 1). Population characteristics of the unmatched cohort can be found in Appendix Table 1.

Table. Characteristics of People by CAL Quartile. (See the original article for the full table.)

A total of 106 unique systemic multimorbidity clusters were identified. Figure 1 illustrates a hypergraph with nodes representing diseases and hyperedges showing some of the most common systemic multimorbidity clusters identified in the population.

Single Diseases

The most frequent co-occurrent diseases illustrated in the heat maps by darker green/blue were arthritis, hypertension, and obesity (Appendix Fig. 2). The eigenvector centralities of the hypergraph show that hypertension was the most central disease in the overall population (centrality [C]: 0.50), followed closely by arthritis (C: 0.45) and obesity (C: 0.42). Diabetes appeared more central in the highest CAL quartile (C: 0.31) than the lowest (C: 0.26; Table 2).

Table. Centrality Values for Single Diseases in the Overall Population by CAL Quartile. (See the original article for the full table.)

Stratification by individual factors showed in races other than White that the centrality of arthritis was lower in the lowest CAL quartile (White, C: 0.45; other races, C: 0.38) and the highest (White, C: 0.48; other races, C: 0.43). In the highest CAL quartile, diabetes and stroke were more central to systemic multimorbidity clusters in nonsmokers (diabetes, C: 0.40; stroke, C: 0.25) than smokers (diabetes, C: 0.29; stroke, C: 0.13). These differences were not observed in the lower CAL quartile. Differences between low and high household income were negligible (Table 3).

Table. Centrality Values and Their Rank in the First and Fourth CAL Quartiles Stratified by Individual Factors. (See the original article for the full table.)

Multimorbidity Clusters

“Hypertension, obesity” was the largest weighted systemic multimorbidity cluster across all CAL quartiles. There was a more even distribution in weights of systemic multimorbidity clusters in the highest CAL quartile than the lowest (Fig. 2). The overall centrality values of systemic multimorbidity clusters across CAL quartiles were similar, and the most central clusters contained hypertension and obesity (Appendix Table 2).

Figure. Bar plots for the weights of multimorbidity clusters, stratified by clinical attachment loss quartiles. CHF, congestive heart failure; CHD, coronary heart disease. (See the original article for the figure.)

Sensitivity Analysis

Removal of the 2011–2012 cycle, which did not include the question on osteoporosis diagnosis, did not have a notable effect on single-disease or cluster centrality values (Appendix Tables 3 and 4). Further analysis replacing missing diagnoses to positive cases did not show significant difference to the main findings (Appendix Tables 5 and 6).