Systemic Multimorbidity Clusters in People with Periodontitis · Larvin H, Kang J, Aggarwal VR et al.

Discussion

In this study, we applied hypergraph analysis to a large cross-sectional cohort to identify the systemic multimorbidity clusters in people with periodontitis. Hypertension, arthritis, and obesity were the single diseases most central/influential to multimorbidity clusters for people with periodontitis; the most frequent systemic multimorbidity cluster was “hypertension, obesity.” Diabetes was more central in participants with a higher degree of CAL, and systemic multimorbidity clusters were more evenly weighted in these participants as compared with those who had lower levels of CAL. Subgroup analysis showed that diabetes and stroke were more central to systemic multimorbidity clusters in nonsmoking participants with higher CAL as compared with smokers, and this difference was not observed in the lower quartile of CAL.

Synthesis with Previous Studies

The focus of this study was to identify systemic multimorbidity clusters that present in people with periodontitis by using the proportion of CAL ≥ 3 mm and its quartiles as an indicator for the extent of periodontitis. Previous studies mainly focused on the association between periodontitis and only 1 of the systemic conditions, such as cardiovascular disease (Larvin et al. 2021a), hypertension (Czesnikiewicz-Guzik et al. 2019), diabetes (Winning et al. 2017), and COVID-19 outcomes (Larvin et al. 2020; Larvin, Wilmott, et al. 2021). Some studies demonstrated that periodontitis is coprevalent with several systemic conditions, such as obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease, but these were predefined at study inclusion (Kang et al. 2019; Bilgin Çetin et al. 2020; Takeda et al. 2021). Through use of hypergraph analysis as a data-driven technique, our study has identified some common systemic multimorbidity clusters in people with periodontitis and the most influential single diseases to multimorbid presentation. For example, we identified “hypertension, obesity” as the most frequent multimorbidity cluster in people with periodontitis. Hypertension and obesity are 2 common conditions known to usually precede development of further systemic disease due to the inflammatory stresses that they trigger on the body (Liu and Nikolajczyk 2019; Ruan and Gao 2019). Past findings based on cluster analysis also showed that the prevalence of hypertension is common in systemic multimorbidity clusters of the general population (Formiga et al. 2013; Zemedikun et al. 2018). Cluster analyses are historically limited, as they group conditions by how closely related they are, rather than identify tangible systemic multimorbidity clusters as in hypergraph analyses. Our study highlighted that hypertension and obesity are central to multimorbidity in people with periodontitis, and this could be important to develop more targeted treatment intervention for this particular population.

Furthermore, our study has demonstrated that diabetes is more central in multimorbidity clusters for people with severe periodontitis versus people with mild periodontitis. This finding aligns with suggestions of a bidirectional relationship between periodontitis and diabetes (Casanova et al. 2014; Stöhr et al. 2021). The systemic inflammation associated with severe periodontitis likely disrupts immune function and glucose handling associated with diabetes and vice versa (Donath et al. 2019; Berbudi et al. 2020). The European Federation of Periodontology and the International Diabetes Federation have developed a roadmap for health care professionals in managing these patients with collaborative care pathways (Sanz et al. 2018). Our findings advocate consideration of the wider systemic multimorbidity clusters in which these patients may also present; specifically, such clusters should be reflected in the recent classification of periodontal disease as separate diagnostic entities.

No previous studies have systematically investigated the systemic multimorbidity clusters in people with periodontitis, particularly the impact of individual factors on clustering patterns. To account for the high correlation between multimorbidity and age and sex, we performed 1:1 matching across CAL quartiles to ensure that identified multimorbidity clusters were independent of age and sex. In addition, we assessed the impact of ethnicity, smoking status, and deprivation on multimorbidity clusters. We found that ethnicity and deprivation affect the clustering pattern of arthritis and obesity more in people with mild periodontitis, while smoking status and deprivation affect the clustering pattern of diabetes and cancer in people with severe periodontitis. These findings highlight the difference in multimorbidity clusters by patient factors, and such difference should be taken into account when designing and planning health care provision and strategies for disease prevention.

Strengths and Limitations

As the first to use hypergraph analysis in oral health research, our study has notable strengths. The hypergraph technique is in its relative infancy within the health research sector and is showing great promise in using cross-sectional data as a nonintrusive information source and to move beyond descriptive analysis, revealing more about patient multimorbid presentation. Hypergraph analysis for multimorbidity research is distinct from traditional regression methods as it uses the data to identify multimorbidity clusters of several diseases simultaneously. Previous regression analyses are limited to single predefined outcomes and pairwise methods to surmise multimorbidity. Our study has demonstrated the utility of this technique in oral health research, as a means of using big data to identify and compare tangible systemic multimorbidity clusters in populations with periodontitis. As awareness of multimorbidity in dental patients is coming to the forefront of oral health research (Watt and Serban 2020), our findings improve understanding of multimorbidity in people periodontitis that may present to the dental clinic. Another strength of our study is the clinical periodontal examination data including CAL, which enables exploration of periodontitis severity with clinical validation and high intraclass correlation (Dye et al. 2019). Furthermore, as a representative national survey across multiple years, the results from NHANES data can provide improved generalizability than typical epidemiologic studies that can be limited by selection bias.

Our study was limited to 3 NHANES cycles due to the availability of periodontal examination data, which limited our sample size; future NHANES cycles with periodontal examination could supplement our findings with more data and more robust findings. The NHANES data set does not supply linked electronic health records; therefore, our analysis relied on self-reported multimorbidity. As NHANES was a cross-sectional national survey, we could not ascertain whether periodontitis occurred before or after the multimorbidity clusters, because the timing of disease diagnosis was not available. We used quartiles of CAL ≥ 3 mm as a surrogate for a periodontitis case definition. While this ensured equal sample sizes across groups, it should be noted that clinical guidelines recommend CAL and probing depth for periodontitis classification (Caton et al. 2018).