Teachers' Growth Mindset, Perceived School Climate, and Perceived Parental Autonomy Support Moderate the Relationship Between Students' Growth Mindset and Academic Achievement · Zhang K, He WJ

1. Introduction

Research on the growth mindset has increasingly shifted toward a deeper exploration of cross-cultural compatibility and the role of contextual factors in influencing mindset development, particularly in light of emerging counterintuitive findings (Burnette et al. 2023). This evolving focus, captured by the mindset-plus-supportive-context framework (Yeager et al. 2022), underscores the importance of embedding mindset interventions within the broader cultural and contextual landscape. However, despite these theoretical advancements, there remains a need for more empirical evidence to enable a full understanding of the contextual heterogeneity of various learning environments, which may influence the successful replication of growth mindset interventions and their predictive power regarding learning outcomes. In response to this need, the present study explores the moderating effects of several contextual factors, including teachers’ mindset (Kroeper et al. 2022), perceived school climate support (Bear et al. 2011), and perceived parental autonomy support (Mageau et al. 2015). These factors have all been highlighted as being closely related to the development of a growth mindset in recent research findings (e.g., Ma et al. 2020; Macnamara and Burgoyne 2023). This study expects that supportive contexts—teachers’ growth mindset, perceived school climate, and perceived parental autonomy support—will moderate the relationship between students’ growth mindset and academic achievement.

1.1. Contextual Sensitivity of the Growth Mindset

Dweck’s (2006) mindset theory initially posited that students who believe their intelligence can grow through effort tend to perform better academically. Some studies have indeed shown a positive effect of having a growth mindset on academic achievement (e.g., Polirstok 2017). However, many other studies have presented inconsistent findings, illustrating that the effect of a growth mindset is not always robust or replicable across different populations and contexts; these include large-scale studies such as international comparative research (e.g., Sun et al. 2021; Yeager and Dweck 2020) and meta-analytical studies (e.g., Macnamara and Burgoyne 2023). These inconsistencies emphasize the importance of contextual adaptability in understanding the dynamics of mindset effects, an increasing number of researchers have highlighted the importance of investigating possible contextual heterogeneity in explaining such inconsistent findings regarding the effect of a growth mindset on academic achievement. For example, Yeager et al. (2022) proposed that teachers’ mindsets are a critical factor in determining the results of their students’ growth mindset. Other researchers have also highlighted that perceived school climate support (e.g., Zhang and He 2024) and perceived parental autonomy support (e.g., Chen et al. 2024) are closely related to achieving effective outcomes of a growth mindset. Collectively, these research findings suggest that the capacity to adapt to the needs of the context is more important than endorsing a single mindset independently of the context. This focus on contextual adaptability helps explain the variability in the effectiveness of growth mindset interventions across different settings.

In fact, when Dweck (1999) first proposed mindset theory, certain contextual factors were identified for developing or encouraging the formation of a growth mindset, although she did not discuss them at length. Specifically, Dweck (1999) developed her growth mindset theory in light of Bandura’s (1986) Triadic Reciprocal Determination (TRD) model within the framework of social cognitive theory, which emphasizes the reciprocal dynamics among behavioral, environmental/contextual, and personal factors. In particular, growth mindset theory posits that an individual’s beliefs about intelligence are shaped by the context of the environment, such as feedback from parents and teachers. For example, parents’ praise (context) can influence children’s beliefs about intelligence, which then affects their behavioral outcomes, such as persistence in academic tasks (Gunderson et al. 2013). This theoretical perspective underscores the importance of social and contextual factors in shaping one’s belief in the ability to grow. More critically, it highlights the need for a flexible, context-sensitive approach to leveraging growth mindset theory, particularly in diverse educational settings. Empirical studies have increasingly revealed cultural heterogeneity in terms of the effect of a growth mindset on academic achievement (e.g., Zhang et al. 2020), further underscoring the importance of tailoring growth mindset interventions to the unique demands of the context.

1.2. Supportive Contexts for Students’ Growth Mindset

In school settings, recent research has identified several important contextual factors with a significant effect on the formation of students’ growth mindset and the effectiveness of such a mindset. These contextual factors are expected to have a significant moderation effect on the link between students’ mindset and their academic outcomes by amplifying, diminishing, or even changing the direction of the impact of the growth mindset on academic outcomes. This is elaborated below.

1.2.1. Teachers’ Mindsets

Research has increasingly highlighted the pivotal role of teachers’ mindsets in shaping students’ growth mindset, which could significantly influence the way students perceive their own abilities and approach academic challenges (Vestad and Bru 2024). Teachers who believe that abilities can develop through effort tend to provide encouraging feedback and create classroom environments that reinforce these beliefs in students, fostering a growth mindset (Mesler et al. 2021). This process of reinforcing a growth mindset highlights the importance of contextual factors, as the teacher’s mindset serves as a moderator that influences how students interpret and internalize these beliefs. This alignment between teacher and student beliefs creates a positive feedback loop, increasing students’ confidence and resilience, which ultimately contributes to improved academic performance. Yeager et al. (2022) demonstrated that growth mindset interventions are most effective when implemented in environments where teachers themselves hold growth mindsets. In such environments, teachers actively reinforce growth-oriented principles in their teaching practices, providing the support that students need to internalize these beliefs. As a result, students in these settings are more likely to believe in their capacity for growth, leading to better academic outcomes. The interaction between the teacher and student mindsets is thus crucial for fostering a growth-oriented learning environment, where students feel safe in taking risks and embracing challenges.

A practical illustration of this dynamic is provided by Ronkainen et al. (2019), who conducted a case study in a Finnish elementary school. They found that a teacher’s growth mindset was evident in the feedback provided to students, e.g., using phrases such as “not yet” to encourage students to see challenges as growth opportunities. This strategy helped students gradually transition from a fixed mindset to a growth mindset, underscoring the direct impact of teacher behavior on student mindset development and academic performance. Furthermore, Yu et al. (2022) reported that students were more likely to develop a growth mindset in classrooms where teachers used growth-mindset-oriented tasks such as inquiry-based learning techniques that promote exploration, resilience, and an open mind to encourage positive development through effort. Conversely, when teachers used fixed-mindset-oriented tasks such as ability-based learning techniques, students tended to adopt a fixed mindset. These findings illustrate how different instructional strategies can either support or hinder the development of a growth mindset. In another study, Kroeper et al. (2022) identified additional teacher behaviors that signal growth-mindset beliefs to students. Teachers who provided frequent encouraging feedback, responded supportively to struggling students, and prioritized learning over performance were more likely to foster growth mindsets in their students. These behaviors revealed how teachers, through their day-to-day interactions, actively nurtured the development of growth mindsets. Taken together, these studies demonstrate that teachers’ growth-mindset beliefs are critical moderators of the relationship between students’ growth mindset and their academic achievement. Teachers who emphasize effort, focus on growth, and provide supportive and constructive feedback significantly increase the effectiveness of growth mindset interventions, which can lead to better academic outcomes. In this regard, a positive moderation effect of teachers’ growth mindset on the link between students’ growth mindset and academic outcomes is expected.

1.2.2. Perceived School Climate Support

The perceived school climate refers to individuals’ perception of the quality and characteristics of their school environment, including teacher–student relationships, support systems, and institutional structures (Worrell and Hale 2001). This variable was chosen due to its critical role as a contextual moderator that shapes how students interpret and respond to growth mindset interventions. Previous research has consistently demonstrated that a positive school climate provides the psychological safety and encouragement necessary for students to embrace challenges, persevere through setbacks, and develop a growth mindset (Bear et al. 2015; Paunesku et al. 2015). These perceptions shape students’ beliefs about their abilities and their capacity to grow (Yu et al. 2022). Students who perceive their school climate as supportive and inclusive are more likely to embrace challenges and persist through setbacks, which are both key components of a growth mindset. The literature has identified several dimensions of perceived school climate support in school settings, including (1) teacher–student relations, (2) student–student relations, (3) fairness of rules, (4) school safety, and (5) liking of school (Bear et al. 2011).

First, the dimension of teacher–student relations is crucial. Students who experience positive, supportive interactions with teachers tend to feel encouraged to take academic risks and learn from mistakes. In contrast, students who experience distant or disengaged relationships with their teachers may adopt a fixed mindset, seeing challenges as insurmountable barriers (Charlton et al. 2021). Second, the dimension of student–student relations plays a significant role in shaping students’ mindsets. In schools where students perceive a respectful and collaborative peer culture, they are more likely to engage in cooperative learning, reinforcing the belief that intelligence can develop through effort and shared learning experiences (Le et al. 2018). This aligns with the idea that abilities are not fixed but can improve with perseverance (Zeng et al. 2019). Conversely, negative peer interactions—in which competition dominates and success is seen as scarce—may lead to a fixed mindset. In such environments, students may feel threatened by others’ success and avoid academic risk, reinforcing isolation and disengagement (Dweck 2006). Third, with respect to the fairness of rules, when students perceive school rules and disciplinary actions as fair and consistently applied, they are more likely to engage positively with their learning environment (Özer and Demirtaş 2010). Fairness fosters a sense of trust in the system and encourages students to persist in the face of challenges, knowing that their efforts will be justly recognized. This perception is in line with the growth mindset, wherein effort leads to improvement and setbacks are part of the learning process (Mrazek et al. 2018). In contrast, perceptions of unfairness may undermine students’ motivation and lead to disengagement, contributing to the adoption of a fixed mindset (Yeager and Dweck 2012).

Fourth, school safety is integral to creating an environment in which students feel secure enough to take risks, make mistakes, and embrace learning challenges. When students perceive their schools as safe, they are more likely to step out of their comfort zones, viewing challenges as opportunities for growth rather than threats to their self-worth (Timm 2015). Conversely, schools that are perceived as unsafe or chaotic may encourage a defensive, risk-averse attitude, which can stifle the development of a growth mindset (Hughes et al. 2015). In such environments, students might avoid challenges altogether, fearing failure or negative consequences. Finally, the fifth dimension—liking of school—reflects overall student satisfaction with their school experience. Students who enjoy school and feel proud of their environment tend to be more motivated and resilient when facing academic challenges (Willingham 2021). A positive connection to the school community can also foster a growth mindset, as students are more likely to embrace challenges and view them as opportunities for personal development when they feel positively toward their learning environment. Additionally, students who feel involved in shaping school decisions—such as by joining student councils or providing feedback—are more likely to perceive their school as a place where their voice matters (Lowery 2008). This sense of agency aligns with growth mindset principles, which emphasize owning one’s learning and viewing challenges as opportunities for personal growth (Mager and Nowak 2012). In contrast, dissatisfaction with school can weaken students’ connection to their learning environment and foster a fixed mindset. Students who feel disengaged or disconnected from their school community may be less inclined to view academic challenges as meaningful or worth their effort (Fredricks et al. 2004). Instead of seeing setbacks as opportunities for growth, they may view them as reflections of their own inherent limitations, leading to decreased motivation and persistence. Such disengagement can further reinforce alienation from school, making students less likely to participate in decision-making processes and thereby deepening their disconnection.

In summary, these findings generally suggest a positive moderating role of perceived school support across five dimensions (i.e., teacher–student relations, student–student relations, fairness of rules, school safety, and liking of school) with respect to the effect of students’ growth mindset on their academic outcomes.

1.2.3. Perceived Parental Autonomy Support

Perceived parental autonomy support refers to the extent to which students perceive their parents as encouraging independence, providing choices, and fostering self-regulation in their learning (Fousiani et al. 2014). This variable was selected because it serves as a key contextual moderator that influences how effectively students internalize and apply growth mindset principles. Autonomy-supportive parenting has been shown to promote intrinsic motivation, resilience, and adaptive learning strategies (Fousiani et al. 2014; Won and Shirley 2018), all of which are closely linked to the development of a growth mindset. This support involves behaviors such as offering choices, acknowledging students’ psychological needs, and promoting self-regulation. Recent research by Ma et al. (2020) indicates that perceived parental autonomy support positively influences students’ growth mindset. By fostering an environment in which students feel empowered to take ownership of their learning, autonomy-supportive parents encourage students to make independent decisions and embrace challenges, thereby promoting persistence through difficulties and viewing failure as an opportunity for growth. The key factors identified in the literature (Mageau et al. 2015) that contribute to students’ perceptions of autonomy support include (1) choice within certain limits; (2) rationale for demands and limits; (3) acknowledgment of feelings; and avoidance of controlling behaviors such as (4) threats of punishment, (5) performance pressure, and (6) guilt-inducing criticism.

For example, providing students with choices within set boundaries promotes a sense of autonomy while maintaining a necessary structure, which has been shown to enhance students’ ownership of their learning and foster a growth mindset (Reeve 2021). Posthumus and Kleinhans (2014) further emphasize that even in environments with external constraints, offering limited choices enables students to exercise agency and approach challenges with a mindset focused on growth. Providing a clear rationale for rules and demands also plays a crucial role. Jang et al. (2010) report that when students are given explanations for why certain limits are necessary, they are more likely to internalize these demands, leading to greater engagement and motivation. Similarly, Reeve (2021) argue that rationales help students perceive rules as supportive rather than controlling, fostering an environment conducive to resilience and growth. This aligns with findings by Johansen et al. (2023), who demonstrate that students in autonomy-supportive environments—where their feelings are acknowledged and rationales are provided—tend to develop higher levels of intrinsic motivation and academic performance. Acknowledgment of feelings is another critical component of parental autonomy support. Froiland and Worrell (2017) highlight that when parents validate their children’s emotions, they foster a psychologically safe environment, allowing students to express frustrations and approach challenges as growth opportunities. Such emotional support is linked to higher intrinsic motivation and academic aspirations, which are key elements of a growth mindset. Such emotional support is linked to higher intrinsic motivation and academic aspirations, which are key elements of a growth mindset. Moè and Katz (2018) further emphasize the role of parental emotions in shaping students’ emotional responses through self-efficacy. Their findings suggest that parents’ positive emotions and autonomous motivation are associated with higher levels of students’ self-efficacy, which in turn supports adaptive emotional and motivational outcomes during academic tasks. This underscores the importance of parents creating an emotionally supportive and autonomy-promoting atmosphere to enhance their children’s academic engagement and resilience.

However, when parents rely on threats of punishment to control behavior, as Katz et al. (2018) note, students may associate failure with negative consequences, leading them to adopt a fixed mindset and avoid risks. Moreover, perceived performance pressure from parents also plays a significant role in shaping whether students develop a growth mindset or a fixed mindset. Pedersen (2017) suggests that when parents prioritize academic outcomes such as grades over the learning process, students may feel that their worth is tied solely to their performance. This emphasis on results can foster a fixed mindset, in which students perceive their abilities as limited. In contrast, reducing performance pressure may help students feel safe in taking risks and learning from mistakes, which is associated with the development of a growth mindset. Finally, guilt-inducing criticism, in which parents use guilt to influence behavior, can further undermine students’ sense of autonomy and resilience. Assor et al. (2004) report that controlling parental behaviors, including guilt-inducing criticism, reduce students’ intrinsic motivation and their willingness to engage with challenges. Brooks (2014) similarly reports that guilt-inducing criticism often leads to anxiety, which hinders students’ persistence and ability to view challenges positively. Mageau et al. (2015) support this, showing that controlling strategies, including guilt-inducing tactics, decrease students’ motivation and self-regulation, reinforcing a fixed mindset.

In summary, the research findings suggest a domain-specific pattern with respect to the moderating role of perceived parental autonomy support in determining the effect of students’ growth mindset on their academic outcomes. Specifically, three dimensions of autonomy support (i.e., perceived choice within certain limits, rationale for demands and limits, and acknowledgment of feelings) are expected to have a positive moderating role that may increase the strength of the relationship between the growth mindset and academic achievement; however, the other three dimensions of autonomy support (i.e., perceived threats of punishment, performance pressure, and guilt-inducing criticism) are expected to play a negative moderating role that may weaken this relationship.

1.3. The Present Study

Contextual heterogeneity has been suggested as an explanation for the inconsistent findings regarding growth mindset interventions. Research shows that contextual factors can strengthen or weaken their impact on academic outcomes (Macnamara and Burgoyne 2023; Yeager et al. 2022). The present study extends this understanding by exploring three potential moderators—teacher mindset, perceived school climate, and perceived parental autonomy support—in the relationship between students’ growth mindset and academic achievement. This study aims to provide a more nuanced understanding of how supportive environments influence this relationship. Derived from the perspective of the mindset-plus-supportive-context framework and relevant research, the following study hypotheses are formulated:

Hypothesis 1 (H1) posits that teachers’ growth mindset positively moderates the relationship between students’ growth mindset and academic achievement.

Hypothesis 2 (H2) posits that students’ perceived school climate support positively moderates the relationship between students’ growth mindset and academic achievement.

Hypothesis 3 (H3) posits a dimension-specific moderating effect of perceived parental autonomy support on the relationship between students’ growth mindset and academic achievement. Specifically, H3a–c postulate that certain dimensions of parental autonomy support—perceived choice within limits, rationale for demands, and acknowledgment of feelings—positively moderate the relationship between students’ growth mindset and academic achievement. Conversely, H3d–f posit that dimensions such as perceived threats of punishment, performance pressure, and guilt-inducing criticism negatively moderate this relationship.