4. Discussion
This study deepens our understanding of how contextual factors—particularly teacher mindset, perceived school climate, and parental autonomy support—moderate the relationship between students’ growth mindset and their academic achievement. Recent work on mindset theory increasingly emphasizes the importance of environmental and contextual factors in shaping how growth mindsets are developed and implemented in educational settings (Burnette et al. 2023; Kroeper et al. 2022). While the findings align with the mindset-plus-supportive-context framework (Yeager et al. 2022), the evidence from this study is correlational and thus does not establish causal relationships. This limitation underscores the need for caution when interpreting how contextual factors amplify or diminish the effects of a growth mindset. Teachers’ growth-mindset beliefs are associated with students’ mindset formation and application, as teachers may create classroom environments that nurture persistence and learning through effort (Mesler et al. 2021). When teachers themselves demonstrate a growth mindset, their beliefs are linked to fostering an environment that supports the internalization of these beliefs and are associated with improved academic performance. However, while these findings reinforce prior research, the relatively high average scores for teachers’ growth mindset in this study suggest a potential ceiling effect that may limit the variability needed to fully understand the range of moderating impacts. This result reinforces the findings by Yeager et al. (2022), which show that the effectiveness of growth mindset interventions significantly increases when teachers actively model and promote growth-mindset beliefs. Furthermore, the perceived school climate—particularly dimensions such as teacher–student relations and fairness of rules—was found to strengthen the link between students’ growth mindset and academic achievement. This supports the findings by Bear et al. (2011), who argue that positive school environments, which foster safety, respect, and fairness, provide the necessary psychological foundation for students to embrace academic challenges and persevere. Such environments may provide the psychological safety needed for students to take intellectual risks, a core element of the growth mindset framework. Additionally, positive teacher–student relationships have been shown to promote resilience and engagement, supporting students as they encounter academic difficulties (Zhang and He 2024). This highlights the importance of fostering inclusive school climates, where the principles of effort and growth are actively reinforced. The study also elucidates the crucial role of parental autonomy support in moderating growth mindset outcomes. In addition to exploring the positive relation between perceived parental autonomy support and students’ growth mindset, as found in previous research by Ma et al. (2020). The findings suggest that parents who provide autonomy, such as by offering rationales for decisions and acknowledging emotions, positively moderate their children’s growth mindset and academic achievement. In contrast, controlling parental behaviors, such as performance pressure and guilt-inducing criticism, were negatively associated with students’ growth mindsets, undermining the positive effects of mindset interventions. Collectively, these findings underscore the complex interplay between individual beliefs and environmental support systems in shaping academic outcomes. Growth mindset interventions are most effective when they are integrated with supportive teaching practices, a positive school climate, and autonomy-supportive parental behaviors. By examining the growth mindset within specific contextual factors such as teacher mindset, perceived school climate, and parental autonomy support, this study provides insights into how interventions may be influenced by the environmental contexts of students. Moving forward, future research should explore how specific aspects of school and family environments interact with mindset development to optimize educational outcomes, particularly across different cultural settings.
4.2. Practical Implications
The findings of this study underscore the potential importance of creating supportive contexts for fostering students’ growth mindset and enhancing academic achievement. Teachers’ mindsets, the school climate, and parental autonomy support serve as potential moderators in this process. For example, teachers’ mindsets significantly shape how students approach challenges. When teachers adopt a growth mindset, they are more likely to use effective feedback strategies and promote resilience in their students (Mesler et al. 2021). Training programs for teachers can focus on enhancing these beliefs to create growth-oriented classrooms. Research has shown that professional development that encourages a growth mindset in teachers is associated with better student outcomes (Yeager et al. 2022). Schools should thus focus on such teacher training initiatives to amplify the impact of mindset interventions (Yeager et al. 2022). For instance, Burnette et al. (2023) highlight the importance of implementation fidelity in mindset interventions, suggesting that teacher training programs should include clear guidelines and structured activities to ensure consistent application of growth mindset principles. For teachers’ training, incorporating growth mindset principles into pre-service teacher education may ensure these strategies are integrated early in a teacher’s career, creating a foundation for long-term positive impacts on students. Additionally, aligning mindset-focused training with the formal curriculum objectives may be important. Teachers should consider how their mindset beliefs may align with and relate to broader educational goals, such as fostering creativity, critical thinking, or academic excellence. In settings where the curriculum emphasizes competitive outcomes, it might be beneficial for teachers to explore strategies that integrate growth mindset principles while addressing performance-driven objectives. For example, interventions that carefully balance performance goals with personal development could help ensure that curriculum demands are met while promoting adaptive mindset practices. However, it is also important to recognize that endorsing a single mindset universally, without considering the demands of specific educational contexts, may not always yield optimal results. In competitive or high-stakes environments, a fixed mindset may help students focus on performance outcomes, which could align better with the immediate demands of such systems. Therefore, fostering the capacity to adapt mindsets based on contextual needs—rather than strictly promoting one mindset—may ultimately be more beneficial. This adaptability could be an important consideration in the design of future interventions. In addition, a positive school climate fosters an environment in which students feel supported and are more likely to embrace growth-oriented behaviors (Bear et al. 2011). Key dimensions such as teacher–student relations, fairness of rules, and school safety have been identified as influential factors in this process (Bear et al. 2011). Schools can implement programs that strengthen these dimensions, creating an inclusive and supportive learning environment in which students are encouraged to view challenges as growth opportunities (Charlton et al. 2021). This aligns with research by Yu et al. (2022), who reported that supportive school environments enable the development of a growth mindset, particularly in contexts that promote fairness and respect. Moreover, the role of parental autonomy support in enhancing the growth mindset cannot be overlooked. Schools can engage parents through workshops or informational sessions on autonomy-supportive behaviors, helping them understand how minimizing performance pressure and guilt-inducing criticism positively influences their children’s academic motivation (Assor et al. 2004). For instance, parent-focused programs could include interactive role-playing activities to practice autonomy-supportive communication techniques, making the application of these strategies more tangible and effective. Ma et al. (2020) reported that students who perceive higher levels of parental autonomy support demonstrate greater persistence and academic resilience, providing clear implications for fostering a growth-oriented home environment. By aligning these supportive factors—teacher mindset, the school climate, and parental autonomy support—educational institutions may create environments that support students’ growth mindset and contribute to their academic development. Future research should also explore how different mindsets can be flexibly applied in various educational systems to balance both growth- and performance-oriented demands. These results contribute to a broader understanding that growth mindset interventions are most effective when they are embedded in a supportive context (Yeager and Dweck 2020). Future research and policy initiatives should focus on integrating these contextual elements to optimize growth mindset interventions across diverse educational settings.
4.3. Limitations and Future Research
While this study contributes valuable insights into how supportive contexts moderate the impact of a student growth mindset on academic achievement, several limitations must be acknowledged. First, the cross-sectional design limits our ability to make causal inferences. The data were all captured at one point in time, and there is no evidence that the measures were assessed prior to final exam scores. This limitation prevents us from determining the causal direction of the relationships. For instance, it is possible that higher student grades could contribute to a higher growth mindset score, rather than the reverse. Most importantly, there is no experimental control, and thus all we have are correlations, leaving the possible causal direction ambiguous. While we identified significant moderation effects, it remains unclear how these relationships evolve over time. Future research should adopt longitudinal studies to track changes in students’ growth mindsets and academic performance across different educational stages, which would enable a better understanding of the long-term impact of these supportive contexts (Maxwell and Cole 2007). Second, this study primarily uses academic performance, as reflected by standardized test scores, to evaluate students’ outcomes. Future research could incorporate additional measures, such as self-efficacy, motivation, and learned helplessness, to provide a more comprehensive understanding of academic performance. Third, the sample used in this study, consisting of middle school students from Shanghai, may limit the generalizability of the findings to other cultural or educational contexts. Research has suggested that the effects of growth mindset interventions can vary significantly across different cultures and educational systems (Zhang and He 2024). Cross-cultural studies are needed to determine whether similar patterns of moderation hold in other regions, particularly in contexts with different levels of academic pressure or varying degrees of parental involvement. Fourth, while this study explored key moderating variables, other important factors, such as peer influence, socioeconomic status, and school resources, were not examined. Future studies should include these variables to obtain a more comprehensive understanding of how the growth mindset interacts with a variety of contextual factors. For example, peer influence could play a significant role in shaping student attitudes toward learning and challenges, whereas socioeconomic status might influence access to educational resources that promote the development of a growth mindset (Claro et al. 2016). Finally, this study exclusively employed quantitative methods, which, while useful for statistical analysis, may not fully capture the complex experiences of students and teachers in real-world settings. Qualitative methods such as interviews or classroom observations could provide deeper insights into how teacher mindset and parental support are expressed in everyday interactions with students (Creswell and Plano Clark 2017). Employing a mixed-method approach in future research could lead to richer, more nuanced findings that better reflect the lived experiences of students.
Building on the limitations outlined above, future research should also consider including additional variables to better capture the interplay of factors influencing growth mindset. Variables such as self-efficacy, intrinsic motivation, and emotional regulation could provide further insights into the psychological mechanisms underpinning growth mindset development and its impact on academic achievement. For instance, self-efficacy plays a critical role in shaping students’ beliefs about their abilities and their persistence through challenges (Wasylkiw et al. 2020). Moreover, intrinsic motivation may strengthen the link between growth mindset and academic outcomes by fostering greater engagement and perseverance in learning (Bedford 2017). Incorporating such variables could offer a more holistic understanding of the factors driving growth mindset, enriching theoretical frameworks and guiding the development of more targeted, context-sensitive interventions across diverse educational settings.
CC BY 4.0. "Teachers' Growth Mindset, Perceived School Climate, and Perceived Parental Autonomy Support Moderate the Relationship Between Students' Growth Mindset and Academic Achievement" by Zhang K, He WJ, Journal of Intelligence (2025). https://doi.org/10.3390/jintelligence13010008. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC11766234). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.