Introduction
Females are the fastest growing justice involved population in the United States, with nearly 1 million females under the supervision of the criminal justice system (Bureau of Justice Statistics, 2023). In 2022, 14% of incarcerated persons in jails were women and from 2021 to 2022, the female population grew at a faster rate (9%) than the male population (3%) (Bureau of Justice Statistics, 2023). The overall rate of juvenile arrests for both females and males has declined in the past decade, yet the decline has been greater for male youth (Puzzanchera, 2021). Although researchers and policymakers increasingly recognize the importance of understanding the unique risk and protective factors related to female’s involvement in the justice system (Zahn et al., 2010; Lynch et al., 2012; Kerig, 2018) and exploring gender-responsive approaches within the context of juvenile justice (Kerig and Schindler, 2013), there is relatively little empirical research on the collateral consequences of juvenile justice involvement specifically for females.
A growing body of empirical research underscores the detrimental effects of juvenile justice involvement, both in the short and long term. This literature reveals that youth incarceration not only fails to effectively reduce crime rates but also leads to a myriad of adverse collateral consequences (Holman and Ziedenberg, 2013; McCarthy et al., 2016; Mendel, 2022b). Among these collateral consequences is the association between juvenile incarceration and the exacerbation of mental health problems. For example, high rates of posttraumatic stress and depression symptoms have been observed following juvenile incarceration and are associated with the traumatic experiences youth report while in secure confinement (Dierkhising et al., 2014). Collateral consequences of juvenile justice involvement are far reaching and include barriers to housing, employment, education, and public benefits (Dierkhising et al., 2023). Juvenile incarceration has been causally linked to lower academic attainment and adult criminal justice involvement (Aizer and Doyle, 2015). Adolescents with juvenile justice histories are ultimately burdened with less social and economic capital as they enter young adulthood.
The literature on collateral consequences of juvenile justice involvement has not specifically focused on females. However, much is known about the extensive histories of trauma and victimization, particularly experiences of sexual violence (Johansson and Kempf-Leonard, 2009; Kerig and Becker, 2010), that females involved in the juvenile justice system have experienced. Females often come to the system and/or are confined for offenses related to their experiences of violence and victimization (e.g., running away, truancy, housing instability, commercial sexual exploitation); for example, in 2021 females were more likely to be detained for status offenses (24%) compared to males (19%) (Puzzanchera et al., 2023). In addition, females involved in the juvenile justice system are two times more likely to report a history of sexual abuse (16% vs. 32%) and four times more likely to report a history of sexual assault/rape (9% vs. 39%) compared to males (Dierkhising et al., 2013). These findings have led to the identification of a sexual violence to prison pipeline that is often the trajectory for females (Saar et al., 2015). Females, particularly those in secure confinement, are also at increased risk for additional trauma exposure once system involved (Saar et al., 2015). For example, youth with histories of sexual abuse or assault are at greater risk for sexual abuse or assault during incarceration (Dierkhising et al., 2014). In addition, there is growing recognition that females are more likely to be held in secure confinement, often for lower-level offenses, not for public safety, but because they are seen as vulnerable (Beck et al., 2010). This approach is deeply rooted in gender biases (Spivak et al., 2014), and highlights the need for a deeper understanding of the collateral consequences of justice involvement among females in order to identify more appropriate alternatives to detention or prevention and intervention options for this population.
In this paper, we describe the long-term collateral consequences for females involved in juvenile justice. To do so, we draw from a rich, longitudinal dataset of 166 women who were initially recruited in adolescence due to serious and chronic involvement with juvenile justice1 (Chamberlain et al., 2007). The sample has been followed for the past 26 years with 14 different assessment points (see Figure 1). The current assessment wave includes the Turning Points for Women Study (TPWS), which is unique because prospective, longitudinal studies in criminology rarely focus on women and those that exist, often follow community samples (e.g., The Pittsburgh Girls Study [PGS]; Keenan et al., 2010). A small number of high-quality prospective, longitudinal studies have examined patterns of offending from adolescence into adulthood and have included subsamples of females (e.g., Pathways to Desistance, 16% female; Mulvey, 2004; The Northwestern Juvenile Project, 36% female; Teplin et al., 2013). TPWS is an important complement to the existing literature and well equipped to understand the collateral consequences of female justice involvement because it: (1) involves a robust assessment battery across substance use, psychiatric disorders, trauma history, official records of offending and types of offenses; (2) includes trauma history information and assessment of multi-system involvement (e.g., child welfare, juvenile justice, criminal justice); (3) follows a sample that not only had serious and chronic delinquency during adolescence but was court-mandated to out of home care, (4) documents biological indicators of stress and health. Therefore, the objective of the current paper is to provide rich, descriptive data on the adolescent and early adulthood experiences of this unique sample of women to characterize the psychosocial, health, relational, and systems involvement consequences they have sustained.2
Figure. Description of the turning points for women study. (See the original article for the figure.)
CC BY 4.0. "The long-term collateral consequences of juvenile justice involvement for females" by Schweer-Collins ML, Dierkhising CB, Leve LD, Frontiers in psychology (2023). https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1321355. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC10800427). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.