Discussion
The current study showed that among this group of women who had experienced high levels of arrests, out of home placements, and incarceration as juveniles, many continued to have involvement in the justice system in adulthood. Nearly three-fourths of the women were involved with the adult criminal legal system, yet, the last arrest was, on average, at age 22 years indicating a pattern consistent with the age-crime curve: high offending in adolescence with a sharp decline in offending into adulthood (Farrington, 1986; Moffitt, 1993; Piquero et al., 2003). The variability in the age range of 12–37 years at last arrest also indicates both desistance and persistence within the sample.
Women in the sample experienced significant early adversity, with an average of nearly six ACEs. This is striking as data show the majority of U.S. adults have experienced three or fewer ACEs (Swedo et al., 2023). Given the high ACEs in this sample and the known link between ACEs and health problems (Felitti et al., 1998), it is not surprising to also see high rates of mental and physical health concerns in adulthood. Notably, nearly two-thirds of the sample had experienced child sexual abuse, which is likely an underestimate given this was based on caseworker report or official cases in the child welfare system. This finding provides empirical support to the emerging theory on the sexual violence to prison pipeline among females (Saar et al., 2015). Overall, the sample experienced significant trauma in childhood and adolescence as documented by their ACEs, involvement in the child welfare system, and high prevalence of mental health concerns in their initial assessment. Ongoing system involvement was also prevalent and likely contributed to ongoing stress and trauma in the lives of the females as they entered adulthood. Indeed, nearly two-thirds of the sample reported a lifetime history of treatment and/or a diagnosis of anxiety and/or depression, and half of women (50%) met criteria for a diagnosis of PTSD at the most recent assessment in adulthood. This statistic reflects their symptom expression at the time of the assessment. In comparison, lifetime PTSD rates in the general population are estimated at 8% among women (Lehavot et al., 2018). Thus, the prevalence in this sample is 6.25 times the prevalence rate among the general population of women and is also underestimated given it does not include lifetime prevalence.
The physical health outcomes shown in this study as participants approached middle adulthood corroborate evidence of the known physiological burden of chronic psychosocial and systems stress on the body (McEwen and Stellar, 1993; Guidi et al., 2021). Participants self-reported below average levels of health, rating their general health with the SF-36 at 46 on a scale of 0–100, where 50 is considered average health. Conversely, a normative score on general health for women in the U.S. is 70.6, corresponding to “good” to “very good” general health (Obidoa et al., 2010). Females in the study also endorsed high rates of chronic health conditions. For example, more than one-third of the sample reported experiencing asthma and anemia, and 15%–20% of the sample reported experiencing obesity, high blood pressure, and musculoskeletal conditions such as arthritis. These conditions may be indicative of greater allostatic load (Guidi et al., 2021) and many of these chronic conditions place individuals at risk for cardiometabolic morbidity and subsequently, premature or increased mortality (Reilly and Kelly, 2011; Xu et al., 2018; World Health Organization [WHO], 2021), which was also observed in this sample as eight participants (nearly 5%) were deceased by the last wave of this study.
Nearly nine out of ten females were dual system youth, youth who experienced both juvenile justice and child welfare system involvement. Prevalence rates of dual system involvement are generally 50%–70% (Herz et al., 2019, 2021). However, dual system youth are more likely to be female and tend to experience more out of home care while in either child welfare or juvenile justice compared to the general juvenile justice population (Herz et al., 2019). Given that the current sample was recruited based on their gender and disposition for out of home care it is not surprising the prevalence of dual system involvement is higher in the current sample.
Perhaps most striking are the outcomes related to pregnancy and parenting. The total number of pregnancies in the sample was 717, with 309 (43%) resulting in loss (i.e., miscarriage, abortion, stillbirth). The majority of first pregnancy and childbirth experiences were in adolescence at, on average, 16 and 19 years old, respectively. Of the 408 children born to the full sample of 166 females, nearly two in five children were referred to the child welfare system and nearly one-third experienced out of home care (e.g., foster care). These findings are aligned with the literature on pregnant and parenting youth with histories in foster care (Eastman et al., 2019), which reveal that one in three females in foster care give birth by age 21 (Putnam-Hornstein et al., 2016). The high levels of involvement with child welfare that participants experienced in their childhood and again as parents also corroborate research documenting intergenerational involvement in the child welfare system among youth in the juvenile justice system (Putnam-Hornstein et al., 2015). Research also reveals that risk for intergenerational involvement in child welfare is nuanced, with mothers with mental health problems (Hammond et al., 2017), those experiencing housing instability while in out of home care, and those living in congregate care at the time of birth (Eastman and Putnam-Hornstein, 2019) at greatest risk for intergenerational involvement in child welfare. Future research should seek to understand the protective factors that buffer risk for intergenerational involvement in child welfare, particularly in females with multiple intersecting risk factors. Such findings will be central to developing tailored supports for pregnant or parenting females involved with the juvenile justice system.
The majority of the sample reported being in a relationship (74.4%). Although approximately one-third of participants reported positive dyadic adjustment, reaching levels indicative of a satisfied and happy couple relationship (Spanier, 1976), 59% of participants also reported experiencing some form of intimate partner violence (IPV) in their current relationship. This included being a victim of psychological, sexual, or physical abuse or mutually engaging in these behaviors in the relationship with their significant other. These findings are consistent with empirical studies showing that IPV is a correlate and predictor of crime, arrest, and incarceration for women (Brennan et al., 2012; DeHart et al., 2014; Gottlieb and Mahabir, 2021), yet they highlight the need for the legal system to consider IPV when considering the best ways to support women who come into contact with the system. Further, prior research has documented that women may show desistance through supportive relationships (Rodermond et al., 2016), demonstrating the need for examining nuanced measures of relational quality, including positive aspects of the couple relationship, as predictors of legal systems involvement.
Limitations
This study described the collateral consequences of females who, from early adolescence, experienced extensive involvement in the juvenile justice system. Although data were collected prospectively, we note that this paper does not describe the causal outcomes of juvenile justice involvement. This is an important limitation as it is well documented that youth who enter the juvenile justice system are also more likely to have multiple risk factors prior to entry that may be linked with the psychosocial, relational, and health consequences outlined in this paper. In addition, the sample had severe and chronic juvenile justice system involvement, and thus the current results may not extend to women with lighter involvement in the system (e.g., no out of home care), to males, or to women from other geographic regions or racial-ethnic backgrounds. Additionally, data on participant experiences of interpersonal violence was collected through self-report and therefore, participants may have underreported or minimized their experiences.
Future directions
The current study documents the many potential risks and outcomes that may be associated with severe and persistent juvenile justice system involvement for females. In addition to the consequences of justice system involvement, research documents that females enter the juvenile justice system with significant trauma histories (Kerig and Becker, 2010; Anderson and Walerych, 2019) and are frequently incarcerated for reasons unrelated to public safety. There are now initiatives to end the juvenile incarceration of females. Hawaii, for example, had zero females incarcerated in their youth facility as of 2022 (Healy, 2022) and in California, the Vera Institute of Justice, is working at the County level to end the incarceration of females and gender expansive youth (Vera Institute, 2023). A primary goal of these initiatives is to serve youth in their community and/or divert youth from the system entirely. Community-based approaches to youth arrests and increases in diversion options have become best practice across the nation in order to reduce confinement of youth and the collateral consequences of juvenile justice involvement (Mendel, 2022a, 2023). Findings from the current study support these efforts and future research should evaluate how alternatives to incarceration for females differentially relate to the long-term collateral consequences of juvenile justice involvement for females.
Future research efforts with the TPWS will disentangle the effects of juvenile justice and adult criminal legal system involvement, while considering other salient life events such as trauma, relationships, parenting, and involvement in multiple public systems, that may function as turning points to explain the heterogeneity in outcomes among the women. As suggested in this paper and in line with a developmental psychopathology perspective and emerging work in positive criminology (Ronel and Elisha, 2011; Ronel and Segev, 2014; Kewley, 2017), it is imperative that future research measure and explore positive, protective factors across intra and interpersonal, and systemic levels to advance a nuanced understanding of how an individual harnesses internal resiliency and/or benefits from social supports as they desist from crime.
CC BY 4.0. "The long-term collateral consequences of juvenile justice involvement for females" by Schweer-Collins ML, Dierkhising CB, Leve LD, Frontiers in psychology (2023). https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1321355. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC10800427). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.