What Contributes to COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy? A Systematic Review of the Psychological Factors Associated with COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy · Romate J, Rajkumar E, Gopi A et al.

2. Methods

The current review was structured as per the updated guidelines for reporting systematic reviews [36].

2.1. Eligibility Criteria

The following inclusion criteria were used. The current review did not limit studies conducted solely among any specific group of participants as the study objective included understanding the psychological factors of vaccine hesitancy among different populations across the world. Studies were included if they investigated psychological factors associated with vaccine hesitancy. The search was limited to the English language. Further, articles were included if they were published from 2019 onward. The review chose this year as the cut-off as the analysis focused on the COVID-19 pandemic. The review excluded conference abstracts, unpublished manuscripts (preprints), commentaries, editorials, and publications that analysed only the secondary data.

2.2. Search Strategy

Online databases of PubMed, Scopus, Science Direct, PsycNET, and Web of Science were systematically examined using a combination of keywords: “cognitive”, “behavioural”, “determinant”, “emotional”, “psychological”, “vaccine hesitancy”, “vaccine refusal”, “vaccine opposition”, “vaccine reactance”, “vaccine resistance”, “vaccine acceptance”, “COVID-19”, and “SARS-CoV-2”. Boolean operators “AND” and “OR” were employed at this time to integrate keywords on each database. An additional literature search was conducted using Google Scholar to identify any other relevant articles.

2.3. Selection Process and Data Extraction

The first author (John Romate) completed the study conceptualization and came up with the search terms and carried out the search. The first three authors (John Romate., E.R. and A.G.) simultaneously screened the articles for the titles and abstracts independently. The identified references obtained through database search were exported to reference management software, Zotero, and then duplicates and retracted studies were removed. Next, the remaining citations were exported to a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet. These studies were screened against the eligibility criteria based on the titles and abstracts. Subsequently, a full-text review was conducted for articles with abstracts that met the eligibility criteria, again by the first three authors. The PRISMA flowchart was adhered to for each phase of article screening. After the full-text review of the studies for eligibility, data extraction was completed by the first two authors. The following data were extracted from each finalized article: author, year of publication, details concerning the country, sample information, and psychological factors.

2.4. Quality Assessment and Evidence Synthesis

The quality assessment of included studies was completed using critical appraisal tools from the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) [37]. These tools were scored on a rating scale of ‘yes’, ‘no’, ‘unclear’, and ‘not applicable’ across several study domains. Articles were appraised by the second and third authors (E.R. and A.G.) and a third reviewer decided on any discrepancies (John Romate). A narrative synthesis of extracted evidence was carried out comparing and contrasting the overall data and qualitatively presented as themes. The reviewers reached a consensus on the study findings through frequent discussions.