3. Results
An initial search on five electronic databases yielded 2289 records, of which 748 were from PubMed, 894 from Scopus, 412 from Science Direct, 128 from PsycNET, and 95 from Web of Science. Further, an additional 12 studies were identified via the Google Scholar search. After deduplication and removal of retracted items, the remaining 1562 records were screened for selection based on the inclusion criteria (Figure 1). Subsequently, 1401 records were removed after the title and abstract screening. Of the 161 reports sought for retrieval, the full text was not available for 16 studies. The remaining 145 reports were assessed for eligibility. The full-text analysis excluded 66 reports that were not about the psychological factors of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. Thus, the final analysis included 79 quantitative studies on COVID-19 vaccination with an emphasis on the psychological factors associated with vaccine hesitancy.
3.2. Study Characteristics
Of the 79 studies selected for the final analysis, two were published in 2020, 58 were published in 2021, and the remaining 19 were published in 2022 (Table 1). The included studies were conducted in the United States (US) (n = 10), China (n = 5), UK (n = 4), Saudi Arabia (n = 4), Italy (n = 3), Kuwait (n = 3), India (n = 3), Bangladesh (n = 3), South Korea (n = 3), Jordan (n = 3), Turkey (n = 2), Tunisia (n = 2), Qatar (n = 2), Turkey (n = 2), Thailand (n = 2), Ireland & UK (n = 2), Hong Kong (n = 2), and one study each from Malta, Austria, Canada, Pakistan, Palestine, France, Egypt, Iran, Mexico, Mongolia, Norway, Brazil, UAE, Africa, Ethiopia, Cyprus, Greece, Portugal, Australia, Iraq, Zimbabwe, and Nigeria. Of the remaining two studies, one was conducted across nine low- and middle-income countries and the other was in Jordan, Kuwait, and other Arab countries. The selected studies included those completed prior to COVID-19 vaccine authorization (which analysed the psychological factors of future vaccine hesitancy by assuming that vaccines would be available) and those studies conducted after the authorization of COVID-19 vaccines. All the finalized articles used cross-sectional designs (n = 79). Most of the studies were conducted among the general population (n = 48). Other studies covered healthcare workers, medical students, university students, parents, physicians, mothers with a mental health history, vaccine priority population, adults with multiple sclerosis, nursing students, nurses and midwives, college students, and pregnant and lactating women.
3.3. Quality Assessment
The quality assessment of 79 studies included in the current systematic review was conducted using JBI critical appraisal tools. The risk of bias for the assessed studies was generally at a moderate to high level. Moreover, no studies were eliminated based on the level of quality appraisal. The quality assessment results can be found in the supplementary file.
3.4. Psychological Factors Associated with Vaccine Hesitancy
The current review findings provide a comprehensive list of various psychological factors associated with vaccine hesitancy but further suggest such factors could be conceptualized into seven main themes: appraisals of the COVID-19 pandemic, vaccine safety and side effects, general vaccine confidence/trust, trust in government and healthcare professionals, scepticism around vaccine production, conspiracy beliefs, emotions, and information and knowledge about the vaccine (Table 2).
3.4.1. Appraisal of COVID-19 Pandemic
The literature review clearly evidences the association between appraisals of COVID-19 and vaccine hesitancy. Specifically, vaccine hesitancy was reported more likely among respondents with little to no fear of COVID-19 infection [42,45,46,51,62,69,75]. One study revealed that respondents who considered the vaccination to be unnecessary and with lower perceived danger of COVID-19 with greater vaccine hesitancy showed vaccine complacency [79]. Further, individuals who experienced no symptoms during the pandemic were more likely to report vaccine hesitancy [83]. Thus, participants who more strongly perceived their risk of being infected by COVID-19 as lower demonstrated a higher tendency toward vaccine hesitancy [84]. Similarly, vaccination was accepted by more people who were afraid of COVID-19 than those who were not [105]. Specifically, a study including an Irish and UK sample reported higher fear of COVID-19 among the vaccine accepting groups than those who were vaccine-hesitant [115].
3.4.2. Vaccine Safety and Side Effects
One theme extracted from the investigated studies was that perceptions of the safety and side effects of the COVID-19 vaccine had a greater influence on vaccine hesitancy. Participants’ concerns regarding the safety and efficacy of the COVID-19 vaccine were found in many studies [38,39,41,44,48,49,50,53,57,58,63,71,76,77,78,83,84,85,86,88,89,96,102,104,111,115]. More evidently, the respondents in a reviewed study reported 29 reasons for vaccine hesitancy/rejection, wherein the top reason was safety concerns about vaccines [59]. Moreover, people perceived vaccines as unsafe [94] and believed that vaccines may interfere with the treatment outcome or efficacy of other medical/health conditions [75,81]. Whereas, some individuals were hesitant to uptake the vaccine because of the possible side effects of vaccines, as reported in Refs. [48,53,56,57,58,59,60,63,65,71,75,80,86,88,89,92,93,95,96,97,98,100,101,104,107,114]. Concerns about side effects and the efficacy of the vaccine were perceived as barriers that negatively influence willingness to accept vaccination [39]. The findings revealed that such concerns may range from possible vaccine side effects, beliefs regarding the disease itself, people’s perception of rushing to conduct vaccine trials, profiteering of pharmaceutical companies from vaccines, and preferred dependence on natural immunity. In general, participants who were ready to receive a vaccine against COVID-19 showed lesser concerns when compared to individuals who are hesitant to vaccinate.
3.4.3. Vaccine Confidence/Trust
Individual vaccine confidence/trust in general was found to negatively correlate with COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. The findings emphasized that respondents with high levels of vaccine confidence or trust in general reported low vaccine hesitancy when compared with those people who had low vaccine trust [42,44]. Several studies reported the association of low confidence in vaccinating against COVID-19 or vaccines in general with vaccine hesitancy [61,65,83,103,105]. Further, mistrust in the vaccine made many individuals unwilling to get vaccinated [42,53,56,98]. Moreover, individuals who were less likely to have received previous vaccines against influenza were less likely to receive a COVID-19 vaccine [38,45]. Previous vaccination behaviour against the flu increased the intention to uptake the vaccine but decreased with an increase in general doubts regarding the vaccine [40]. In one study, participants reported uncertainty and mistrust in vaccines as the most common reason for avoiding COVID-19 vaccination [60].
3.4.4. Trust in Government and Healthcare Professionals
The findings identified medical mistrust as a major cognitive factor influencing vaccine hesitancy during the COVID-19 pandemic. Some of the studies revealed that, during the COVID-19 pandemic, there was widespread medical distrust that made a vast number of people refuse vaccination [25,59,69,72,75,82,115]. Moreover, lack of trust in the government led to vaccine hesitancy by generating concerns about the vaccination information provided by government agencies [25,47,50,62,69,77,84,98,104,108,115]. Specifically, in one study, slightly more than half of the participants lacked trust in the ability of governments and other relevant authorities in ensuring the availability of a safe and effective vaccine [111]. Another study reported that trust in the government or voting behaviour was related to vaccine hesitancy. People who voted for opposition parties or did not even vote were more likely to hesitate than respondents who voted for the governing parties [47]. Further, “anti-vaccine” attitudes were also found to be related with “anti-authority” attitudes [25,46].
3.4.5. Scepticism around Vaccine Production
Expedited vaccine production is reported as a contributing factor to vaccine hesitancy across many studies [59,71,95,100,109]. The individual assumption that vaccines were developed rapidly without reasonable trial duration and with safety issues may result in hesitancy to accept their vaccination to ensure effectiveness [41]. Relatedly, mistrust in vaccine-developing companies [59], pharmaceutical lobbying [82], and policymakers’ and managers’ motivations to recommend the vaccine [83] were also reported as concerns that led people to refuse or delay COVID-19 vaccination. Moreover, less trust in science or scientists [25,61,62] has influenced perceptions of people about vaccination.
3.4.6. Conspiracy Beliefs
The evidence suggested that people who reported vaccine hesitancy were less likely to receive pandemic-related information from sources including healthcare professionals and scientists [46], and their perception of the causes of COVID-19 largely constituted conspiracy theories held by individuals [25,46,54,62,66,67,68,69,72,110]. For instance, participants in one study had a conspiracy belief that COVID-19 has an “artificial origin” [46], whereas another study reported individuals’ belief in a pre-planned pandemic [99]. Further, participants in another study revealed conspiracy beliefs such as the injection of microchips into recipients and infertility related to vaccination, respectively [68]. Relatedly, the findings revealed that people who exhibited vaccine hesitancy reported that they were concerned about misinformation related to the vaccine [54,64,67]. Whereas, addressing misinformation on the COVID-19 vaccine can enhance public confidence in healthcare experts, mitigate the effects of conspiracy beliefs, and motivate individuals to follow COVID-19 preventive measures [69].
3.4.7. Emotions
People’s anxiety about COVID-19 vaccines and their rapid production can result in vaccine hesitancy [46,59,71,95,100,109]. Relatedly, worry that the COVID-19 vaccine might adversely affect their present medical/health condition may make people unlikely to obtain the COVID-19 vaccine [75,81,109]. The findings also revealed that people with less fear of COVID-19 were more likely to exhibit vaccine hesitation [42,45,46,115]. Conversely, the findings from another study suggested that individuals who refused to vaccinate had low levels of anxiety, were less worried about the current pandemic, and found the pandemic to be media hype that induced fear. Moreover, their level of resilience perception was high [69]. Further, individuals who reported fear of injection were more likely to hesitate to accept COVID-19 vaccination than individuals who reported no such fear [43,44,105]. Conversely, concerns of losing loved ones to COVID-19 and worries regarding healthcare system overload were found as positive predictors of willingness to uptake the vaccine [69].
3.4.8. Information and Knowledge about Vaccines
The findings indicated social media platforms as a major source of information on COVID-19 vaccines [57,62,66,68,70,73,76]. Further, individuals who were resistant to vaccination expressed less reliance and trust in authoritative and traditional sources of information [25] and broadcast and print media information [62]. Meanwhile, participants in one study indicated healthcare and social service providers as the most trusted sources of vaccination-related information [62]. Conversely, findings from another study indicated that individuals who reported vaccine hesitancy were less likely to receive pandemic-related information from sources including healthcare professionals and scientists [46]. Moreover, inconsistent information from elected authorities and public health professionals was found to influence vaccine hesitancy [103]. In addition, a lack of correct information on the COVID-19 vaccines acts as a potential barrier to COVID-19 vaccine uptake [38,44,58,60,102]. Besides, individuals who were unaware of the vaccine type authorized in their nations were more likely to exhibit vaccine hesitancy [59]. Furthermore, another study revealed that low levels of knowledge of the preventive measures related to COVID-19 led to vaccine refusal [69].
CC BY 4.0. "What Contributes to COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy? A Systematic Review of the Psychological Factors Associated with COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy" by Romate J, Rajkumar E, Gopi A et al., Vaccines (2022). https://doi.org/10.3390/vaccines10111777. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC9698528). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.