Determinants of Food Choice and Perceptions of Supermarket-Based Nudging Interventions among Adults with Low Socioeconomic Position: The SUPREME NUDGE Project · Harbers MC, Middel CNH, Stuber JM et al.

1. Background

Obesity presents a global threat to public health: in 2016, more than 1.9 billion adults suffered from overweight and obesity worldwide [1], predisposing them to a range of non-communicable diseases, including type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease. The burden of overweight and obesity demonstrates a strong social gradient. In the Netherlands, those with the lowest educational attainment—a key indicator for socioeconomic position (SEP)—are 1.6 times more likely to be overweight and 2.7 times more likely to be obese, compared to people with the highest educational attainment [2] and similar inequalities have been observed in other European countries [3]. Addressing social inequalities is an important step to improving general public health.

One of the major drivers of overweight and obesity is an unhealthy diet, characterized by high intakes of nutrient-poor and energy-dense foods [4], stressing the need for improvement of diet quality, especially among populations with low SEP. However, not all interventions that aim to improve healthy food choices are equally effective across levels of SEP. Individual-based interventions (e.g., mainly focusing on information provision) preferentially improve healthy eating outcomes in individuals with high SEP [5], whereas interventions focused on creating healthier food-environments seem to affect all SEP levels equally [5,6], and could be instrumental in reducing the social inequalities in the burden of overweight and obesity.

Nudging in particular has become an increasingly popular strategy in creating healthier food environments. Nudges make healthy choices easier or more intuitive, without constraining choice for unhealthy alternatives or using financial incentives, for example by placing healthy foods at eye level. Although a wide range of nudging strategies have been applied in various contexts, such as supermarkets and cafeterias [7,8,9,10,11], they often follow a one-size-fits-all approach. The challenge is that customers often constitute a heterogeneous population [12], with potentially differing responses to nudges based on their determinants of food choice (e.g., food values, taste preferences, cooking habits). In order to tackle this issue, recent literature has explored the potential of choice and delivery personalization, which in fact uses these heterogeneity data in order to determine which nudge and which outcome (e.g., food product) will be most effective for targeting a certain group of individuals [13]. Thus, to maximize the potential effectiveness of nudges in populations with low SEP, we need to understand the determinants of food choice in this group, in order to improve the design of nudges so that they fit with their habitual food behaviour practices.

Previous research has reported food costs, familiarity, habits, role models, and food outlet availability as important determinants of food choice among populations with low SEP [14,15,16,17,18], but evidence is relatively scarce. Furthermore, although there is evidence to suggest that people perceive nudging strategies to be acceptable [19], little is known about perceptions regarding supermarket-based nudging strategies among adults with low SEP and how determinants of food choice—such as food costs and habits—may shape these perceptions.

The SUPREME NUDGE project aims to improve lifestyle behaviours and lower cardiometabolic risk among adults with low SEP through implementing nudging and pricing strategies in a real-life supermarket setting [20]. For the design of the nudges in this project, we aimed to explore how the determinants of food choice shape the perceptions regarding supermarket-based nudging strategies among adults with low SEP, in order to better inform the design of the nudges.