Determinants of Food Choice and Perceptions of Supermarket-Based Nudging Interventions among Adults with Low Socioeconomic Position: The SUPREME NUDGE Project · Harbers MC, Middel CNH, Stuber JM et al.

2. Methods

Participants were recruited in two low-SEP neighborhoods—defined as having a SEP-score below the national average—in the city of Utrecht during two rounds of data collection. During the first round (October and November 2018), participants (n = 14) were recruited in a shopping centre in the city district of Overvecht. Of the fourteen participants who were recruited, two participants were not eligible for inclusion in the study based on their educational level and therefore are omitted from data analysis. A preliminary analysis of the data was conducted in order to grasp whether data saturation had been reached. As some new topics emerged from the last interviews that prompted further exploration, additional participants (n = 3) were recruited in a community centre in the city district of Rivierenwijk. Formal assessment of thematic saturation using the methodology described by Guest et al. [21] showed that, by using a base size of 4, we reached the 0% new information threshold at 12 + 1 interviews, indicating that during the 13th interview, no additional relevant themes were identified.

During the first round of data collection, the researcher approached shoppers and briefly explained the purpose of the interview. If shoppers were interested in participating in the interview, the researcher immediately invited the participant to a nearby restaurant where the interview took place. Reasons for refusing to participate were mainly related to time concerns (e.g., people were busy doing their groceries). During the second round of data collection, the researcher approached potential participants during an informal coffee morning in a community centre among mostly elderly community members and volunteers. If they expressed interest in participating in the interview, the researcher immediately invited them to a quieter table in the community centre where the interview took place. During the second round of data collection, none of the approached potential interviewees refused to participate. Table 1 provides an overview of participants characteristics.

2.2. Interview Procedure

First, the purpose of the interview was once again explained and informed consent was obtained. Prior to the start of the interview, we asked the participants to fill out a short questionnaire on demographic characteristics, including age, sex, and highest attained educational level. Answer possibilities for educational level were based on the Dutch education system, and lower educational level was defined as primary education up to completing intermediate vocational education. This short questionnaire was used as a screener for the researcher, in order to verify that the participants had a lower educational level which was used as a proxy for SEP. As such, the recruitment of low-SEP participants was achieved in two ways: first, by recruiting in areas which had a low neighbourhood SEP-score, and second, by verifying the highest educational level attained by the participant. If the highest attained educational level was not within the definition of the low educational level, the interview was shortened. All participants were reimbursed with a gift voucher worth EUR 20, including the participants (n = 2) who did not have a lower educational level.

We conducted semi-structured interviews that lasted on average 25 min, following a pre-defined topic list (Supplementary File S1). The topic list was used in a flexible manner by the researcher, based on the issues that were mentioned by the participants. The first part of the interview was focused on the everyday life of participants, in order to get a feeling of the relevant wider contextual factors that shape dietary choices (e.g., employment, living situation) and in order for the interviewee to feel at ease. In the second part of the interview, the participants were asked how they valued food, and what they perceived to determine their food choices. First, the participants were given the opportunity to answer freely and in their own words, and if deemed appropriate, the researcher probed by suggesting other potential determinants of food choice. In the third part of the interview, we asked under which circumstances it was easy or difficult to eat healthy for the participant. If appropriate, the researcher referred back to what was mentioned in the first and second part of the interview in order to probe further.

In the last part of the interview, the researcher showed various photos of nudges that could be applied in supermarkets to promote healthier food choices, and briefly explained them (Supplementary File S2). Instead of using the term of nudging, we introduced the photos as strategies that supermarkets could implement in order to assist customers in making more healthy food choices. Thereafter, we explored the relative judgement of the nudges by asking participants to choose the photo that appealed to them the most, and we also asked them to explain why. Vice versa, we asked participants to choose the photo which appealed to them the least, and explain why this was the case.

The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and was approved by the ethics committee of the University Medical Center Utrecht. Reporting of this qualitative study follows the guidelines set out by the Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research (COREQ) checklist [22].

2.3. Research Team

The first author (female PhD candidate in the field of epidemiology) conducted twelve of the fifteen interviews. The third author (female PhD candidate in the field of lifestyle epidemiology) conducted three of the fifteen interviews. The interviewers piloted the topic guide together in order for it to be used in a consistent manner. Both interviewers had no prior relationship with either of the interviewees. Interviewees were informed on the scientific background of the interviewers and personal motivations for conducting the interviews (e.g., learning how to help people make more healthy choices in supermarkets) were made explicit. The second author is a male PhD candidate conducting research in the field of systems innovation and transition theory using qualitative research methods, and assisted the first author in performing data analysis and data interpretation. The other members of the research team are (assistant) professors in the field of (lifestyle) epidemiology, and were involved in designing the study, data interpretation, and writing of the manuscript.

2.4. Data Analysis

All interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim by a research assistant and a professional audio transcription company, and all personal identifying information was removed from the transcripts. Transcripts were imported in Atlas.ti (ATLAS.ti Scientific Development GmbH, Berlin, Germany). The process of coding was informed by the Qualitative Analysis Guide of Leuven (QUAGOL) [23], and was based on content analysis using a combination of inductive and deductive coding. First, the transcripts were read and re-read in order for the first author to become familiar with the data. This phase included underlining relevant passages and noting emerging themes in the margin of the transcript. In the second phase, the key elements of the transcripts were summarized in ‘narrative interview reports’, which aimed to holistically capture the experience of the participant. In the third phase, key elements that emerged from the transcripts and narrative interview reports appearing to be relevant for answering the research questions were translated into more abstract concepts. These emerging concepts were used to construct the initial codebook (e.g., inductive coding). For the first research question, this inductive approach was complemented with a deductive approach, by also including relevant concepts identified from literature (e.g., deductive coding) [24,25]. For the second research question, the codebook only included concepts that emerged from the narrative interview reports, thus following a primarily inductive coding approach, as research and theory concerning perceptions, needs, and preferences on nudging interventions are scarce. After coding the first five interviews, the codes and quotations were carefully examined and compared by the first and second author, and minor revisions to the codebook were made. The following five interviews were coded using the updated codebook, and the first five interviews were again analysed in order to adjust the coding following the revisions to the codebook. This iterative process of comparing codes and quotations among the first and second author was repeated until all interviews were analysed. Codes were structured into intrapersonal, interpersonal, socioeconomic and environmental determinants of food choice, following socio-ecological models of health [24]. In order to provide an indication of the relative importance of the identified determinants of food choice, the narrative report of findings is accompanied by a bar graph, indicating the number of interviewees mentioning the specific determinant (interview frequency), and the frequency of coding this determinant in the interview reports (quotation frequency).