Determinants of Food Choice and Perceptions of Supermarket-Based Nudging Interventions among Adults with Low Socioeconomic Position: The SUPREME NUDGE Project · Harbers MC, Middel CNH, Stuber JM et al.

3. Results

3.1.1. Intrapersonal Determinants of Food Choice

Physiological Factors

We identified three physiological determinants of food choice: ill health, hunger and satiety, and taste preferences (Figure 1). Eight interviewees shared various experiences about ill health, including coping with cancer, diabetes, heart failure, and physical disability. Interviewees said that these conditions influenced their food choices in various ways, for example through affecting taste perceptions, requiring dietary adjustments, affecting product choice, or triggering stress-related unhealthy snacking. Some interviewees also expressed that their own or a relative’s health motivated them to eat healthy:

The role of hunger and satiety was mentioned by five interviewees. Interviewees talked about hunger with respect to meal-timing, for example, a preference for skipping breakfast due to not feeling hungry in the morning. For two other interviewees, this theme was related to food choice, as they perceived some foods as more satiating than others. The role of taste preferences was mentioned by eight interviewees. Taste preferences were often phrased as if they were part of one’s identity, and they often expressed very definite likes and dislikes for various foods:

Attitudes, Beliefs, and Perceptions

Attitudes towards food varied and could co-occur. Five interviewees had a functional attitude, mainly describing food as a source of energy and nutrients, which are necessary for the body to function. Four interviewees held a hedonic attitude, mainly describing how much they enjoyed food. Five interviewees had a complicated relationship with food by describing that food choice required elaborate contemplation, which was prompted by their health condition or other goals, such as weight loss:

Interviewees held various beliefs regarding properties of foods, which influenced their food choices. Four interviewees expressed that food should be of ‘good quality’, referring to the shop where they bought their food (e.g., fish at a local fish shop), the physical appearance of food, or preferences for certain brands. Seven interviewees expressed to prefer fresh foods (e.g., mostly fresh fruits and vegetables), because they perceived this to have better taste, structure, and to be healthier. For some interviewees, these factors outweigh the perceived higher cost or longer preparation time. Finally, five interviewees expressed a general distrust towards the food industry, which was perceived to ‘trick’ consumers or ‘mess’ with the foods.

Habits

Nearly all interviewees framed food choices as habits that they were ‘just used to’ or that ‘worked out’ for them. Interviewees usually reported a traditional Dutch dietary pattern, characterized by potatoes, vegetables, fruits, meats, fish, bread, dairy, and some simple international dishes, such as fried rice and pastas. Some interviewees reported a distinction in food habits between weekdays, weekends, and holidays. During the latter two, interviewees allowed themselves to make more unhealthy food choices. Skipping breakfast was a recurring food habit, mentioned by four interviewees. Despite the ‘static’ notion of habitual food choices, six interviewees had an open attitude towards trying out new foods. Motivations to try new foods included perceived health benefits (e.g., buying spice mixes without salt because of salt restriction), expectations of good taste, or as a means of dietary variation.

Motivation and Values

Food choices were influenced by several commonly valued characteristics: perceived food costs, convenience, healthiness, and taste. Animal friendliness was also mentioned by one interviewee. These values were often weighted against each other when interviewees faced certain food choices. As such, their relative importance was not static, but rather context-specific.

Food costs were mentioned by ten interviewees. Interviewees who valued (low) food costs highly, perceived it to be a waste of money to spend too much money on food, over other ‘better purposes’. One interviewee also expressed to find it important to teach his children that healthy eating could be affordable. Participants who did not value food costs, generally found other food values (e.g., animal friendliness, taste) to be more important.

Convenience was mentioned in ten interviews. Interviewees generally found it important that meals had a shorter preparation time and required a limited number of ingredients. Three interviewees mentioned that convenience was especially important when they had to cook for themselves; when cooking for others, they were prepared to put more effort into cooking. Interviewees generally appreciated convenience in terms of products sold in supermarkets that aided in preparing convenient and healthy meals (e.g., meal boxes or pre-cut vegetables).

The healthiness of foods was mentioned by thirteen interviewees. Only one interviewee expressed to not value the healthiness of foods; healthy foods were regarded as not being tasty. Other interviewees generally stated that they valued the healthiness of foods, which they often substantiated by explaining how they found it important to eat (fresh) vegetables, vitamins, drink water, and to minimize the intake of pork, additives, fat, sugar-sweetened beverage sand sugar. However, the competing value of taste (mentioned by thirteen interviewees) seemed to be a boundary condition for choosing healthy foods, as participants indicated that foods should not be ‘bland’, but should be ‘enjoyable’.

Knowledge and Skills

Interviewees generally seemed familiar with what a healthy diet constitutes, which they described as eating plenty of vegetables, vitamins, fruit, fish, and minimizing intake of sugar, alcohol, and sugar-sweetened beverages in twelve of the interviews. Four interviewees also expressed concerns about additives and artificial sweeteners present in food, particularly in packaged foods and ready-made meals, which they considered to be detrimental to health.

Eight interviewees mentioned various media sources from which they obtained information about nutrition, including television shows, the internet, and doctors. For example, one interviewee described that she had received medication for her cholesterol, which prompted her to search online for dietary regimens:

Three interviewees perceived nutrition information to be confusing, due to conflicting statements and a lack of clarity regarding which sources are credible.

Five interviewees expressed that they had sought professional help for their dietary behaviours from dieticians or health care institutions, or indicated to have participated in a weight loss program or group therapy for binge-eating. Moreover, five interviewees indicated they were adhering to a diet, such as a low-carb diet or a salt-restricted diet. Furthermore, six participants described various strategies or skills, which facilitated them in making healthy dietary choices. Some strategies were mainly driven by health values, such as making sure that in-home food availability was healthy, restricting snacking after a certain time, or only allowing oneself to fill up their plate once. Other strategies, however, were not only driven by health motives, but also incorporated other values, such as convenience and foods costs. These included: buying foods on offer in large quantities, and/or making meals ahead that one would keep in the freezer, and restricting (unhealthy and unplanned) food purchases by using a grocery list.

3.1.2. Interpersonal Determinants of Food Choice

Partners, family members, neighbours and friends were mentioned as actors influencing food choice in either direct or indirect ways. Partners and direct family members often exerted a direct influence on food choice as they provided input on dinner choices, which was mentioned by nine interviewees. Parents of interviewees exerted more of an indirect influence, as interviewees often perceived certain food habits (e.g., choosing for fresh vegetables) to originate from their upbringing. The composition of the household also influenced food choice, as interviewees were generally more likely to put more effort in preparing meals when they lived or had dinner with others, which was mentioned by three interviewees. Similarly, eating was also often associated with social activities by nine interviewees, such as gatherings with friends and family. Often, these occasions were associated with choosing more unhealthy foods.

3.1.3. Socio-Economic Determinants of Food Choice

Two interviewees explicitly mentioned that they had limited income, which caused them to carefully watch what they spend on food purchases:

Two other interviewees mentioned that they were brought up with limited financial possibilities, which also affected their perceptions on the affordability of food and food behaviours at present:

Strikingly, as the first quote illustrates, a limited income was not necessarily perceived as a barrier to eating healthy, and the portion restrictions imposed by growing up in a family with limited income actually may have been a facilitator to portion control. Employment also influenced food choices and was mentioned by five interviewees, and primarily exerted influence through the (limited) amount of time interviewees perceived to have available for meal preparation and food shopping. For two other interviewees, (anticipated) employment provided motivation to eat healthy, given a physically demanding job, or because employment was considered to give structure to the interviewee’s daily routine:

3.1.4. Environmental Determinants of Food Choice

Twelve interviewees mentioned that food products that were on offer in supermarkets often guided their decisions on their purchases. These foods were sometimes bought in large quantities with which interviewees prepared meals in advance. Moreover, interviewees shared various price comparisons for fruits and vegetables available in the supermarket, including the price of organic vs. regular vegetables, fresh vegetables vs. canned vegetables, freshly squeezed orange juice vs. pre-packaged orange juice, or comparing prices amongst food outlets (e.g., discount supermarket vs. regular supermarket). One interviewee also expressed a dislike of the seemingly increasing prices of fresh fruits and vegetables.

Moreover, eight interviewees described the food environment—and particularly the supermarket environment—as tempting, inducing unhealthy food purchases. One interviewee explicitly mentioned that he was aware of some ‘smart’ marketing strategies employed by supermarkets, including secondary placement of food items. In this light, six participants described various strategies which facilitated healthy food purchasing decisions in the supermarket, including making a grocery list prior to going to the supermarket, or shopping for groceries on a weekly basis instead of daily, and thereby minimizing the temptation to unnecessarily buy unhealthy foods.

3.2. Perceptions of Nudging

The closing parts of each interview explored interviewees’ perceptions regarding a number of nudging strategies, by means of visual examples (Supplementary File S2). Generally, interviewees had positive perceptions towards the nudges shown during the interviews. More specifically, interviewees seemed to perceive nudges more positively when these were aligned with their perceived determinants of food choice, e.g., with their product preferences, information needs, and beliefs about the food environment.

3.2.1. Product Preferences

Generally, nudges were perceived more positively if they nudged foods which aligned with interviewees’ product preferences in terms of taste, healthiness, costs, and preparation time. Similarly, product characteristics that seemingly made a nudge less appealing were perceived non-freshness, expected poor taste, high costs, and complicated or lengthy preparation. For example, an interviewee indicated to dislike a nudge applied to nuts, because she did not like the taste of nuts. This may suggest that a nudge is less likely to affect a consumer if the nudged product itself does not fit their or their family’s food preferences.

3.2.2. Knowledge and Information

Generally, nudges were perceived more positively if they anticipated on some kind of information need, for example, regarding calorie content and other nutritional information. At times, this need was linked to ill health and dietary restrictions (e.g., a sodium-restricted diet), which prompted a need for individualized dietary information. As an exception, one interviewee indicated that a specific type of information (product popularity) was of very low interest to them. Finally, four other interviewees expressed a certain extent of distrust towards nudges presenting such information, or indicating ‘healthy’ products, suspecting ulterior motives of the supermarket or food industry. As such, these types of nudges will need to be designed in a way which strengthens their credibility, or risk not being trusted by part of the target group.

3.2.3. Food Environment

As previously described, some of the interviewees held rather negative perceptions towards the food environment in supermarkets, which they perceived as tempting and counter-productive in making healthy food choices. In light of this, several interviewees expressed that nudges would actually provide them with the freedom of autonomous choice between healthy and unhealthy foods, illustrating intervention acceptability:

Additionally, it appeared that interviewees had different strategies for navigating the tempting supermarket environment: some adhered to a grocery list or described themselves as habitual shoppers, while others let in-store food availability guide their food purchases. This shopping strategy also influenced interviewee’s perception of nudges: when interviewees described themselves as habitual shoppers they had less positive perceptions towards nudging strategies as compared to interviewees who let in-store food availability guide their food purchases.