Perceptions of Psychological Intimate Partner Violence: The Influence of Sexual Minority Stigma and Childhood Exposure to Domestic Violence among Bisexual and Lesbian Women · Islam S

1. Introduction

Intimate partner violence (IPV) is a preventable, widespread public health crisis that disproportionately harms women [1]. In the United States, over one in three women will experience IPV in their lifetime [2]. When grouping women by sexual orientation, prevalence rates reveal that the burden of IPV is even higher in sexual minority women (SMW; bisexual, lesbian) compared with heterosexual women. Over 60% of bisexual women and nearly 40% of lesbian women will be harmed by an intimate partner [3]. These elevated risks cannot be fully understood without acknowledging the under-representation of same-gender relationships in society. Dominant sociocultural norms simultaneously accept heterosexual relationships and reject same-gender relationships; such values may play an important role in how people perceive aspects of intimate relationships, including IPV [4,5]. The stigma experienced by bisexual and lesbian women may have a damaging influence on healthy partnerships [4]. The exposure to harm that can occur in same-gender relationships from IPV may be compounded by the harm of sexual minority stigma occurring outside of intimate relationships [6]; a cumulative effect may further isolate bisexual and lesbian women and compel them to tolerate IPV especially when it takes a nonphysical form. The cost of tolerance poses a major risk to safety as it produces confusion about defining violence [7]; the risk to safety may also be a product of the existing inequities and other related forms of exclusion experienced by SMW outside of the intimate relationship; namely, bisexual and lesbian women encounter the same IPV barriers as heterosexual women, but they are further disadvantaged by the stigma attached to their sexual identities, attractions, and relationships [8].

The lack of consensus in psychological IPV definitions [9] may reflect the ambiguity attached to this type of abuse, and therefore, positions of ambivalence may be strengthened and complicate collective agreement that psychological IPV be treated as harmful. Despite this, studies on psychological IPV have been instrumental in determining prevalence rates that are comparable to and higher than physical and sexual forms of IPV [1,9,10]. Research has also highlighted that, among women experiencing IPV, those who indicated the presence of psychological IPV were more likely to report adverse mental and physical health outcomes compared with women who reported only physical forms of IPV victimizations [11]. In disentangling the health implications of psychological IPV, other works have underscored victim-centered approaches to illuminate that psychological IPV incurred more suffering than physical IPV, and among these study samples, such women also showed higher levels of shame, fear, and mental distress [12]. The vast majority of such scholarships have been limited to a heteronormative framing of IPV, necessitating a centering of bisexual and lesbian women and their IPV experiences.

A comprehensive understanding of IPV attests to all forms of power and control. Through verbal and nonverbal tactics, psychological IPV relies on manipulation, deception, shame, intimidation, isolation, and coercion [13,14,15], which may also extend to the harassment, discrimination, and prejudice enacted against bisexual and lesbian women outside of a relationship. Hence, the scope of psychological IPV is complex for SMW. These overlapping forms of victimization call for greater attention to the multiple forms of sexual minority stigma within IPV studies of bisexual and lesbian women.

Existing research on psychological IPV has largely focused on health consequences and behavioral correlates [3,4,16]. In comparison, there have been fewer studies on how psychological IPV is viewed and even less examination of how those perceptions may be related to sexual minority stigma. Given a public sentiment of uncertainty surrounding psychological IPV, there may be a tendency for oppressed individuals and groups to minimize the harm they may experience because of their diminished status [17]. Germane works from social exchange theorists illuminate the negotiations and valuations that individuals attribute to their perceptions and decision-making [18,19]. As a result of their socially ascribed stigmatized statuses, bisexual and lesbian women may have fewer alternatives for help-seeking and support. Thus, it is imperative to explore how sexual minority women may specifically be driven to tolerate psychological IPV when it may be congruent with the hostility that they face in their neighborhoods, workplaces, communities, and greater society.

There has been limited research into the factors that influence permissive perceptions of IPV [20], especially among bisexual and lesbian women. Social-ecological and minority stress models offer a theoretical framework that accounts for factors operating at and above the individual levels as well as group-specific stressors and general life stressors occurring within a heterosexist context [5,21,22]. Sexual minority stress has been modelled through distal (e.g., perceived and enacted forms from others) and proximal stressors (e.g., directing external forms at the self through internalization) that create a climate of perpetual stigmatization [5]. Deteriorating effects of sexual minority stigma on both physical and mental health have been consistently found across varied sexual minority samples [5,23,24,25]. While the underlying processes are not yet clear, evaluations of internalized sexual minority stigma among bisexual and lesbian women have shown its significant effects on IPV victimization [4,26,27]. Parallel examinations of external sexual minority stigma, while limited, have yielded mixed findings with discrimination as the leading measure in IPV studies [4,28]. It remains possible that perceived and enacted forms of external sexual minority stigma are potent subtypes to consider.

To extend the body of knowledge that has demonstrated linkages of sexual minority stress to behavioral correlates of IPV [4,27,29,30], this study examines the relationships of well-documented risk factors and, for SMW and women in general, sexual minority stigma and childhood exposure to domestic violence. Within the trauma literature, specific attention to adverse experiences occurring in childhood has shown that an accumulation of abuse, neglect, and dysfunction within the household poses profound risks to health across the lifespan [31,32,33]. Witnessing and direct victimization of domestic violence is not uncommon and may heighten risks for future IPV, including perpetration and victimization [33,34,35,36]. The negative impacts of such experiences may be intensified in bisexual women, whose lives are disrupted by the dual sources of stigma from heterosexism and monosexism [37,38,39]. Given monolithic assumptions of stigma that eclipse the existence of variations among SMW, an exploration of group differences may be central to addressing the pervasive nature of violence within the lives of bisexual and lesbian women.Overall, the IPV literature has importantly focused on behavior; however, this may have the unintended effect of suggesting that IPV is not a problem until a person perpetrates or is victimized. Therefore, the current investigation of perceptions had the following goals:To assess the association between sexual minority stigma and permissive perceptions of psychological IPV and how they differ by sexual orientation.To examine the extent to which childhood exposure to domestic violence moderates the relationship between sexual minority stigma and permissive perceptions of psychological IPV.To examine the extent to which sexual orientation moderates the relationship between sexual minority stigma and permissive perceptions of psychological IPV.