Perceptions of Psychological Intimate Partner Violence: The Influence of Sexual Minority Stigma and Childhood Exposure to Domestic Violence among Bisexual and Lesbian Women · Islam S

2. Materials and Methods

A cross-sectional online questionnaire was accessed by a sample drawn from Qualtrics Panels, a crowdsourcing tool for obtaining survey responses [40]. Eligibility to participate was limited to individuals who self-identified as a bisexual or lesbian woman, were 18 years of age or older, and lived in the United States. These criteria were used to target potential participants with matching sociodemographic profiles through email and message boards. Access links to the survey routed participants to an online informed consent page before proceeding to the self-administered questionnaire. Participation was voluntary, and all participants were compensated directly through Qualtrics using standard procedures set by the panels. Incentives typically range from cash rewards to gift cards or other redeemable points. The final dataset of survey responses was prepared and deidentified (e.g., removal of IP addresses) by Qualtrics before sharing with the author. Data collection procedures occurred in 2018, after institutional review board approval, as part of a dissertation thesis.

2.2. Measures

2.2.1. Demographics

Variables assessing age, ethno-racial identity, education, household income, and other sociodemographic information were collected.

2.2.2. Perceptions of Psychological Intimate Partner Violence

Vignettes were constructed to measure perceptions of psychological intimate partner violence. They were developed out of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Trans (LGBT) Power and Control Wheel, an adaptation from the original Power and Control Wheel that is commonly used as a psychoeducational tool in therapeutic and advocacy settings [15,41]. The use of gendered language in the initial iteration, however, defined women as victims and men as abusers. A subsequent iteration was created to challenge these assumptions, add LGBT-specific tactics of power and control, and illustrate that IPV occurs within the broader climate of heterosexism that encompasses “homophobia”, “biphobia”, and “transphobia”.

Due to the novelty of the current research, three of the eight “wheel spokes” were chosen to narratively represent psychological IPV. The process of selecting tactics occurred under expert discretion by domestic violence professionals and began by eliminating those that included a physical component. For example, the spoke on the LGBT Power and Control Wheel describing “using intimidation by instilling fear through destroying things and scary body language” was excluded. Finally, spokes focusing primarily on economic abuse were eliminated as recent research has classified this as its own form of IPV [42,43]. This approach to highlight psychological tactics was determined with the selection of the following spokes: denying, minimizing, and blaming; emotional abuse; and intimidation. Each tactic included examples that were taken verbatim from the LGBT Power and Control Wheel [41,44]. Key feedback from community professionals in the field of domestic violence was especially important and ensured that the narratives were accurately expressing the intended psychological IPV tactics and placing the characters in realistic situations to reflect details congruent with common patterns of abuse.

Three vignettes centered on separate tactics of psychological IPV occurring between women in same-gender relationships (see Table 1). Attempts were made to neutralize participant experience in reading the vignettes. Careful consideration in choosing racially and ethnically ambiguous names for the characters was intended to reduce cultural biases (e.g., views related to race, nationality, and/or ethnicity). Limiting persuasive language within the vignettes was also integral to avoid leading the participant to feel sympathy or anger towards a character.

Responses to the vignettes involved rating the behavior exhibited by each character using a 7-point slider scale with designated extremes of “not okay” and “okay”. The participants were prompted to evaluate both partners in each scenario to minimize inclinations in labelling one character as the aggressor over the other. The order in which the vignettes appeared was also randomized. Mean scores associated with the partners that perpetrated psychological IPV in each scenario were computed to assess perceptions. Higher scores indicated that the participant perceived the behavior of the character employing psychological IPV less harshly. Overall interpretations of the perceptions related to the extent to which the participants, at the observer level, identified a particular act of psychological aggression in the vignette to be problematic.

2.2.3. Internalized Sexual Minority Stigma

Internalized sexual minority stigma was assessed using the Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Identity Scale (LGBIS). This scale was developed to evaluate eight dimensions of sexual minority identity [45]. Response options for the LGBIS are presented on a 5-point scale assessing agreement (e.g., “If it were possible, I would choose to be straight”.) and averaged across items by subscale [45]. The Internalized Homonegativity subscale, consisting of three items, demonstrated very good reliability, α = 0.83 [46].

2.2.4. Perceived Sexual Minority Stigma

Perceived sexual minority stigma is a subscale from the Adapted Homophobia Scale (AHS), a measure of an external form of stigma casted upon bisexual, lesbian, and queer women [47]. Also referred to as “felt-normative stigma”, perceived sexual minority stigma describes consciousness of the cultural devaluation and negativity that exists for SMW social groups. Items of the AHS determine frequency ranging from “never” to “many times” on a 4-point scale (e.g., “How often have you felt your family was hurt and embarrassed because you are LBQ?”). Internal consistency for this subscale was acceptable, α = 0.75 [46].

2.2.5. Enacted Sexual Minority Stigma

The AHS also includes a subscale measure of enacted sexual minority stigma, a different type of external stigma that captures direct experiences with rejection and exclusion occurring through acts of violence and discrimination, such as police harassment and sexual assault [47]. This subscale had very good reliability, α = 0.83 [46].

2.2.6. Childhood Exposure to Domestic Violence

A subset of items taken from the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) tool has been psychometrically validated to assess abuse occurring within the household [48]. The original measure was developed by Kaiser Permanente and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to evaluate stressful and traumatic events during childhood [31]. Items in the ACE-abuse subscale pertain to witnessing and being victimized by physical and psychological violence before the age of 18 years. An additional ACE item on sexual victimization (i.e., “Did anyone at least five years older than you or an adult ever touch you sexually?”) was also included. For each experience, participants were asked to report on occurrence by selecting one of four answer options: (1) yes, (2) no, (3) don’t know/not sure, and (4) prefer not to say [31]. Responses were dichotomized to create groups of only participants who indicated “yes” (coded as 1) and collapsing the remaining participants into separate groups (coded as 0). On account of distinct forms of domestic violence, each childhood exposure was analyzed by item.

2.3. Statistical Analyses

Surveys with nonvarying responses (e.g., a participant selecting “1” for every question on the entire questionnaire) and high levels of missing data (e.g., more than half of the items in a single scale) were removed from analyses. In addition, only data from participants who provided complete responses to the vignettes assessing permissive perceptions of psychological IPV were retained for the analytic sample.

Descriptive statistics were computed for each variable, and distributions of the main variables were examined. To address the first research question, bivariate analyses were performed to assess the association between sexual minority stigma and permissive perceptions of psychological IPV. The secondary and tertiary research questions were achieved using a moderated regression approach. Centering was performed to assist with interpretations. To test the moderating role of childhood exposure to domestic violence, separate interaction terms were created for each type of sexual minority stigma with childhood exposure to domestic violence. Similarly, individual interaction terms were created for each type of sexual minority stigma paired with sexual orientation. These tests were performed with permissive perceptions of psychological IPV as the dependent variable. All analyses were conducted using IBM SPSS for Windows, Version 27.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA).